Players to target at the end of the year

[Jesse Christ 2,884]

I heard once that they are going to stop giving compo pics to teams that lose players to FA, what a load of [censored]!

We better get our affairs in order before that happens

[rjay 23,927]

Just hope the AFL don't pull the bottom out of the bag downgrading any Frawley compo. Wouldn't surprise to see a derailment to protect GWS.

Free agency can be a [censored].

That's the danger where the AFL are the default owner of the club (GWS). It wouldn't surprise me either.

[Wiseblood 24,636]

Viney does things those boys cant. Alot of Macrae's possessions are cheap and useless. Wines is very good, but there are some key things he lacks.

I think most supporters would agree without much hesitation that the first bolded part is flat out wrong and the second one isn't explained in any depth at all, but that both Wines and Macrae are further along in their careers than Viney at this stage. Don't get me wrong, I love Jack and think he is having a very good season, but he isn't in their league right now. I think he can be but both Wines and Macrae are having sensational years.

[Deemotivated 550]

That's the danger where the AFL are the default owner of the club (GWS). It wouldn't surprise me either.

The deception and under handed decision making by the AFL is deplorable... Would not surprise me if they step in to some how to protect their "investment"

[dee-tox 4,827]

The deception and under handed decision making by the AFL is deplorable... Would not surprise me if they step in to some how to protect their "investment"

The deception and under handed decision making by the AFL is deplorable... Would not surprise me if they step in to some how to protect their "investment"

They have a pretty decent 'investment' in us at the moment as well!

[the grint 71]

I know he's been mentioned but seems to be forgotten at the moment. Craig Bird is out of contract still and maybe we could do a deal for him and Malceski? Maybe 2nd rounder + Tapscott or Blease? Im not great at hypotheticals.

[jackaub 1,402]

How are we front runners to get Cameron? Whoever finishes bottom of the ladder whether it be saints or lions will want him and they'll have a better pick than us, our only hope would be if Chip does leave and we package our first pick and compo for him- and I'm not too sure that would be the wisest move considering we have more pressing needs in other parts of the field.

Gws would want too much for Cameron. My guess is whoever lands pick 1 will deal with GWS, GWS will then use that to grb petranca, which could enable us to use pick 2/3/4 to land shiel or perhaps a quality mid from another team who are interested in one of the fancied KPF types who are touted to go early.

Or of course we keep both our early picks and just take them straight to the draft.

Let's not forget, if we lose Chip we have cover for him in one Hoges.

We are stil a big chance to finish bottom in my opinion Only issue is we would have to be careful about beating Brisbane

[blue and red in the head 95]

Would we do our first and second pick for sheil Tomlinson or a sheil and green maybe throw a bugg in as steak knifes

[JackVineyForPresident 310]

I just cant see us having 2 or 3 GWS players in our team next year.

In my opinion, we'll get one of them or maybe even none.

I promise you we will not end up with Trealor, Cameron and Shiel or Cameron, Shiel and Greene.

We may get one, like Cameron or Shiel.

Dont get me wrong, that'd be a good result.

[Beats 190]

I think most supporters would agree without much hesitation that the first bolded part is flat out wrong and the second one isn't explained in any depth at all, but that both Wines and Macrae are further along in their careers than Viney at this stage. Don't get me wrong, I love Jack and think he is having a very good season, but he isn't in their league right now. I think he can be but both Wines and Macrae are having sensational years.

Agree with the statement - Viney is probably the best inside mid, mainly due to his explosiveness and toughness, but the other two are definitely better at this stage of their careers, both in quantity and quality. Macrae is doing what we wish Toumpas could/ will and Wines (mainly due to his size - did anyone see him brush away Viney's tackling attempt on the w/e?) is playing like a 200 game veteran.

[TRIGON 4,719]

I just cant see us having 2 or 3 GWS players in our team next year.

In my opinion, we'll get one of them or maybe even none.

I promise you we will not end up with Trealor, Cameron and Shiel or Cameron, Shiel and Greene.

We may get one, like Cameron or Shiel.

Dont get me wrong, that'd be a good result.

No sources, just my opinion JVFP, but I can easily see us getting a couple of GWS players onto our list next year. Given GWS's salary cap constraints (yes I naively still believe that they may apply to them) and their need to reduce the overall number of players on their list.

Edited July 24, 2014 by I Give a Gawnski

[The Big Ticket 94]

I know O'Rourke's been very underwhelming so far but does anyone know if GWS see him as expendable?

[JackVineyForPresident 310]

I know O'Rourke's been very underwhelming so far but does anyone know if GWS see him as expendable?

I dont rate him at all. He has shown zero

[olisik 4,060]

I dont rate him at all. He has shown zero

I agree, isnt much difference to another teams supporters constantly talking about recruiting Toumpas from the Dees...

[ThreeOneSix 953]

O'Rourke or Plowman would be good as steak knives in a deal.

[Ethan Tremblay 28,434]

O'Rourke or Plowman would be good as steak knives in a deal.

The steak knives would make our excess of butter knives look good

Edited July 24, 2014 by Ethan Tremblay

[ThreeOneSix 953]

The steak knives would make our excess of butter knives look good

I agree.. I think both Plowman and O'Rourke will be good players.

I hope the club can arrange a Tyson type trade, where our risk isn't great if they bust.

[Machsy 2,858]

Can't believe the ignorance required to write off a kid at a bottom team in only his 2nd season.

A top 5 pick, no less.

And 3 of them!

[Deemotivated 550]

Can't believe the ignorance required to write off a kid at a bottom team in only his 2nd season.

A top 5 pick, no less.

And 3 of them!

Finally some sense on demonland

[Ted Lasso 16,855]

Can't believe the ignorance required to write off a kid at a bottom team in only his 2nd season.

A top 5 pick, no less.

And 3 of them!

A lot of slices of the humble pie might well be dished out.

plenty of players that take 2-3 years before they start to get going at the top levels and go on to be elite

[Ethan Tremblay 28,434]

Can't believe the ignorance required to write off a kid at a bottom team in only his 2nd season.

A top 5 pick, no less.

And 3 of them!

Who's writing them off?

[Deestar3 167]

Dillon shield likely to stay at GWS....only club to show any interest is Hawks. The melb connection is simply because Greg Healy had known him all his life & would love him at melb.... So line through him. Oh by the way, realise this has only come from the closest person to him & not from the reliable rumours & innuendo from halfwit journalists & social media flogs, but as per the paul Stewart info...make of it as you will !

[Ted Lasso 16,855]

Dillon shield likely to stay at GWS....only club to show any interest is Hawks. The melb connection is simply because Greg Healy had known him all his life & would love him at melb.... So line through him. Oh by the way, realise this has only come from the closest person to him & not from the reliable rumours & innuendo from halfwit journalists & social media flogs, but as per the paul Stewart info...make of it as you will !

strange I have heard the opposite, he has interest from several clubs, and extremely keen to get home to Vic

[Deestar3 167]

Extremely strange because I would say that I heard it literally from the horses mouth .....& I do believe hawthorn (as I mentioned) is in vic?? But the extremely keen part is not in the equation

[Tyson_Viney_Toumpas 269]

Who's Dillon Shield??