My 3 word player analysis V The Saints

[joeboy 3,166]

N.Jones- wonderful all game

Grimes - was often outplayed

Watts - genius at work

Toumpas - clever with possessions

Frawley - was rarely beaten

Trengove - possessions weren't significant

Byrnes - slow thinking liability

Tyson - classy and prolific

Dunn - wonderful first half

Cross - just a game

Pederson - fat and talentless

Michie - will be better

Vince - clever and prolific

Kennedy -Harris - surprisingly wasteful possessions

McDonald - excellent until injured

Howe - career quietest game

Spencer - failed to assert

Bail - disappeared second half

M.Jones - was he playing?

Terlich - never inspired confidence

Fitzpatrick - quiet until injured

Georgiou - promising first game

Edited March 22, 2014 by joeboy

[Redleg 41,464]

McKenzie - was rarely sighted

Actually didn't play.

[RalphiusMaximus 6,088]

Actually didn't play.

Beat me to it

[Ted Lasso 19,549]

Bit hard on Matt Jones I reckon, he was very good in the second half.

[DeeZee 7,445]

Frawley, turnover king.

[Maldonboy38 6,406]

N.Jones - pure A-grader now

Grimes - still can't kick

Watts - 93% disposal efficiency

Toumpas - good with ball

Frawley - mistakes overshadowed class

Trengove - strength and grunt

Byrnes - that was awful

Tyson - prolific plus mistakes

Dunn - back line general

Cross - we need more

Pederson - below AFL standard

Michie - didn't gather possessions

Vince - some genuine class

Kennedy -Harris - not his best

McDonald - decision making horrible

Howe - very subdued game

Spencer - not too bad

Bail - disappointing poor game

M.Jones - improved 2nd half

Terlich - a bit shaky

Fitzpatrick - improving before injury

Georgiou - just a game

[deeflog 679]

Kennedy-Harris - poor sub choice

[Bobby McKenzie 2,385]

Watts - Polish, Class, Sublime!

[BarnDee 287]

sorry but where does joeboy mention McKenzie ?????????????

[daisycutter 29,743]

sorry but where does joeboy mention McKenzie ?????????????

it's in the bit bucket now barndee

i.e. he edited his op

[joeboy 3,166]

it's in the bit bucket now barndee

i.e. he edited his op

In all likelihood , what I'd originally (albeit mistakenly) written for McKenzie would have applied

[tonatopia 278]

Toumpas - Will end up being a goal sneak. A very good one. Loves the limelight and is a show pony. lots of class, limited grunt. I would play him in the forward pocket this year.

Jones - Champion

Watts - Star quality. Way better the nic nat.

Dunn - Captain Dunn

Tyson - Impressive debut

Vince - Star quality. Could have kicked 5 goals.

Spenser - Good in the ruck contest. needs to get smarter in reading the play around the ground.

Matt Jones - solid game

Bail - must do more

Howe - was playing injured

Mcdonald - Good until injured

Fitzpatrick - wtf happened?

Byrnes - little lepricorn played well

Terlich - average game. Dogged

Geiorgiou - will hold his spot until Garland returns

Mitchie - Some good signs, otherwise, workman like

Cross - below average, workmanlike

JKH - not ready yet, Blease will take his spot next week

Pederson - if he kicked those goals, a good game.

Frawley - A solid game

Grimes - A solid game. Eclipsed enormously by Dunn

Edited March 23, 2014 by tonatopia

[Arrow 1,257]

Toumpas - Will end up being a goal sneak. A very good one. Loves the limelight and is a show pony. lots of class, limited grunt. I would play him in the forward pocket this year.

Jones - Champion

Watts - Star quality. Way better the nic nat.

Dunn - Captain Dunn

Tyson - Impressive debut

Vince - Star quality. Could have kicked 5 goals.

Spenser - Good in the ruck contest. needs to get smarter in reading the play around the ground.

Matt Jones - solid game

Bail - must do more

Howe - was playing injured

Mcdonald - Good until injured

Fitzpatrick - wtf happened?

Byrnes - little lepricorn played well

Terlich - average game. Dogged

Geiorgiou - will hold his spot until Garland returns

Mitchie - Some good signs, otherwise, workman like

Cross - below average, workmanlike

JKH - not ready yet, Blease will take his spot next week

Pederson - if he kicked those goals, a good game.

Frawley - A solid game

Grimes - A solid game. Eclipsed enormously by Dunn

Overall I like the optimism of your post Tona, so don't take this personally but Cross was one of our best players. It really annoys me now, in the day and age of stats that we rate players subconsciously on their possessions or supercoach scores when watching the game if gives such a different picture.

Cross tagged Armitage on Saturday, who is the Saints best mid by far, kept him to 11 touches playing 90% game time in the middle. Cross had 15 touches, and 11 tackles. He spanked his opponent. If Tyson, Michie or Trengove had manned up on Clint Jones, Dunstan or Farren Ray we would've been alot closer to winning the football game.

It's a bit of a rant but just because Dom Tyson scored 100 supercoach didn't make his debut good. He turned the ball over very poorly 4 times. Like TAC Cup kicking errors. I'll give him the benefit of the doubt because he's a great player; but god I'm glad I'm not a tagger. They can't catch a break.

[Dee93 19]

N.Jones - sensational all game

Watts - an encouraging game

Dunn - has really improved

Toumpas - too small ATM

Frawley - casual and sloppy

Grimes - an average player

McDonald - decent until injured

Tyson - a promising debut

Howe - very very disappointing

Bail - a VFL player

Vince - a great pick up

Spencer - does useless taps

M.Jones - didn't notice him

Pedersen - an absolute spud

Fitzpatrick - needed more from

Byrnes - wasn't our worst

Cross - surprisingly very quiet

Georgiou - good body work

Michie - an average game

JKH - will be better

Terlich - involved in play

Trengove - slow and ineffective

[angrydee 842]

Cross - never stopped tackling

[Satyriconhome 10,879]

Overall I like the optimism of your post Tona, so don't take this personally but Cross was one of our best players. It really annoys me now, in the day and age of stats that we rate players subconsciously on their possessions or supercoach scores when watching the game if gives such a different picture.

Cross tagged Armitage on Saturday, who is the Saints best mid by far, kept him to 11 touches playing 90% game time in the middle. Cross had 15 touches, and 11 tackles. He spanked his opponent. If Tyson, Michie or Trengove had manned up on Clint Jones, Dunstan or Farren Ray we would've been alot closer to winning the football game.

It's a bit of a rant but just because Dom Tyson scored 100 supercoach didn't make his debut good. He turned the ball over very poorly 4 times. Like TAC Cup kicking errors. I'll give him the benefit of the doubt because he's a great player; but god I'm glad I'm not a tagger. They can't catch a break.

Absolutely correct

[Satyriconhome 10,879]

N.Jones - sensational all game

Watts - an encouraging game

Dunn - has really improved

Toumpas - too small ATM

Frawley - casual and sloppy

Grimes - an average player

McDonald - decent until injured

Tyson - a promising debut

Howe - very very disappointing

Bail - a VFL player

Vince - a great pick up

Spencer - does useless taps

M.Jones - didn't notice him

Pedersen - an absolute spud

Fitzpatrick - needed more from

Byrnes - wasn't our worst

Cross - surprisingly very quiet

Georgiou - good body work

Michie - an average game

JKH - will be better

Terlich - involved in play

Trengove - slow and ineffective

You did watch the game?

[InVINCEable 358]

Toumpas- the new wingard?

[La Dee-vina Comedia 16,909]

N.Jones - pure A-grader now

Grimes - still can't kick

Watts - 93% disposal efficiency

Toumpas - good with ball

Frawley - mistakes overshadowed class

Trengove - strength and grunt

Byrnes - that was awful

Tyson - prolific plus mistakes

Dunn - back line general

Cross - we need more

Pederson - below AFL standard

Michie - didn't gather possessions

Vince - some genuine class

Kennedy -Harris - not his best

McDonald - decision making horrible

Howe - very subdued game

Spencer - not too bad

Bail - disappointing poor game

M.Jones - improved 2nd half

Terlich - a bit shaky

Fitzpatrick - improving before injury

Georgiou - just a game

Actually it was.

But I know what you mean.

[BarnDee 287]

yep ok dc thanks

[#11-TonyAnderson 822]

Matt Jones - (2nd half) took them on, broke the lines, showed some pace - one of the few to do so

[InVINCEable 358]

Matt Jones - (2nd half) took them on, broke the lines, showed some pace - one of the few to do so

*three word player analysis

[KingDingAling 3,758]

Matt Jones - (2nd half) took them on, broke the lines, showed some pace - one of the few to do so

He was electric. Certainly found his niche.

In a side of turnover merchants, M.Jones stands out as a good user of the football - as does Watts.

[ManDee 7,222]

Melbourne - No forking forwards

[Vipercrunch 2,827]

Not sure how anyone could fairly rate Frawleys game as being better than Pedersons.

Pederson had an OK game that could have been good if he kicked those goals. Frawley was well below OK. Would not have given himself a pass mark.

Howe struggled too but not sure how injured he was so may of had an excuse.

Until we get 2 of our key, top class forwards back it's going to be very tough for the team and pretty frustrating to watch. As long as the guys keep learning and Roos can keep them motivated and semi-confident.