Must be the Silly Season... now Dane Swan suspended for 2 wks

[hardtack 10,187]

Collingwood has decided to suspend Brownlow Medallist Dane Swan over a night on the town last Sunday:

http://www.afl.com.a...83/default.aspx

Edited August 7, 2012 by hardtack

[McQueen 17,864]

Collingwood has decided to suspend Brownlow Medallist Dane Swan over a night on the town last Sunday:

http://www.afl.com.a...83/default.aspx

Dream teamers and super coaches rejoice.

Not.

[Ouch! 2,138]

.... and I thought we didn't know how to tank well. Someone tell Bucks it's a little late to start now!!!

[beelzebub 22,724]

theyre tanking !!!

[Robot Devil 1,895]

Resting him before the finals.

Reckon they'll ship him off to Arizona?

Doubt they'll make him "get a real job" like Liberatore.

[Dr. Mubutu 697]

Collingwood FC to be brought before the AFL's integrity committee for rigging the results of the Brownlow medal count.

[daisycutter 28,727]

Make him an offer - forget cloke

He's bound to be really pizzed off

Dobbed in by a team mate

Club didn't believe his story of not drinking

Ruined his Brownlow repeat chance

Publicly humiliated him

If wobblies miss out on top four will be more villified

[Deestroy All 14,262]

Make him an offer - forget cloke

He's bound to be really pizzed off

Dobbed in by a team mate

Club didn't believe his story of not drinking

Ruined his Brownlow repeat chance

Publicly humiliated him

If wobblies miss out on top four will be more villified

If only...

I love Swanny.

[My TD 156]

Doesn't seem like its gonna be my SC year.

I've habitually bought players who were flying (Stanton, Lewis & Cox ) only to watch them slump as soon as in my side.

Didn't buy others others expecting them to slump (Beams) or get injured (Watson) but haven't.

Held on to some waiting for them to find form (Goodes & Broughten) but haven't.

Sold Pendlebury cause he broke his freakin' leg . Came back 4 weeks later as good as gold.

Franklin on the bench for the last month , who knows when he'll be back and now this.

As with the real stuff , ya gotta have some luck in SC.

Edited August 7, 2012 by My TD

[McQueen 17,864]

Doesn't seem like its gonna be my SC year.

At least 95% of other coaches are feeling the same as we are so it's not all doom.

[gsmith12 491]

If only...

I love Swanny.

You can't love 'em all mate !!

So who is it to be, Marat, Marcus, Swanny or Big Cox ?

[nutbean 8,837]

umm... must be a repeat offender.

My squeezes son was in Tramps two or three weeks ago-Dane Swan was there at about 2am drinking and at 4am none other than Brock McLean doing the same.

[DemonWA 3,653]

umm... must be a repeat offender.

My squeezes son was in Tramps two or three weeks ago-Dane Swan was there at about 2am drinking and at 4am none other than Brock McLean doing the same.

I have no problem with AFL players drinking. It's not illigal and if it doesnt effect their on field form then there is no real problem in my eyes.

[hardtack 10,187]

I have no problem with AFL players drinking. It's not illigal and if it doesnt effect their on field form then there is no real problem in my eyes.

You may have no problem with it DemonWA (I certainly have no problem with it either), but if the club has a rule that there will be no late night escapades during the season, then they have no option but to punish the offender. After all, they are paying their players a sh!tload of money (members' money) and require them to be at peak fitness for the entires season... and lack of sleep/over indulgence, is not the best way to maintain peak levels of fitness.

[Dr. Mubutu 697]

I have no problem with AFL players drinking. It's not illigal and if it doesnt effect their on field form then there is no real problem in my eyes.

It was a bit rich of the Age to say this: "His suspension adds to a bad week for the AFL."

How exactly does it reflect badly on the AFL? A man in his 20's went to a pub and had some drinks. Big deal.

[hardtack 10,187]

It was a bit rich of the Age to say this: "His suspension adds to a bad week for the AFL."

How exactly does it reflect badly on the AFL? A man in his 20's went to a pub and had some drinks. Big deal.

Let me think... one guy who happens to be one of Western Bulldogs best performing players found semi conscious with a small amount of "E" in his possession, followed by a brownlow favourite being suspended for two weeks by his own club (who won't give any further details) for being out in the wee small hours and later dobbed in by a team mate for the state he was in at practice?

If I was the AFL, I might just be a little concerned over this kind of publicity for the game.

Edited August 8, 2012 by hardtack

[Dr. Mubutu 697]

Let me think... one guy who happens to be one of Western Bulldogs best performing players found semi conscious with a small amount of "E" in his possession, followed by a brownlow favourite being suspended for two weeks by his own club (who won't give any further details) for being out in the wee small hours and later dobbed in by a team mate for the state he was in at practice?

If I was the AFL, I might just be a little concerned over this kind of publicity for the game.

The first, you'll have no arguments from me. Was a silly thing, and the AFL are right to be worried about this. But the second? Swan didn't do anything illegal. He broke a club rule, and was rightly punished by his CLUB.

I fail to see how his actions reflect badly on the AFL.

[hardtack 10,187]

The first, you'll have no arguments from me. Was a silly thing, and the AFL are right to be worried about this. But the second? Swan didn't do anything illegal. He broke a club rule, and was rightly punished by his CLUB.

I fail to see how his actions reflect badly on the AFL.

In effect, the club maintaining silence over what transpired is, in a way, making it as bad as the Doggies case, because Joe Public will think the worst (why would a club dump a Brownlow favourite for two matches heading towards finals time?) and rightly or wrongly, by extension the AFL will be criticised for not reigning in this sort of behaviour.

[Deestroy All 14,262]

You can't love 'em all mate !!

So who is it to be, Marat, Marcus, Swanny or Big Cox ?

I'm a free spirit Smithy.

[daisycutter 28,727]

The first, you'll have no arguments from me. Was a silly thing, and the AFL are right to be worried about this. But the second? Swan didn't do anything illegal. He broke a club rule, and was rightly punished by his CLUB.

I fail to see how his actions reflect badly on the AFL.

swanny claimed he didn't drink that night

but his teammate observed at training that he was acting strangely

if it wasn't drink could it have been something else?

[The heart beats true 16,706]

He's bound to be really pizzed off

Dobbed in by a team mate

Club didn't believe his story of not drinking

Ruined his Brownlow repeat chance

Publicly humiliated him

I can't think of a single reason why the club would release information that another player dobbed him in. It's got trouble written all over it.

I hope Swanny is [censored] and wants out. I'd look the other way while he did whatever he wanted with his free time if he got 40 touches a week in the Red & Blue.

And think about the marketing opportunities! We've always had a reputation as 'skiers'

Edited August 8, 2012 by The heart beats true

[Jesse Christ 2,884]

What kind of world are we living in when a few drinks on a Sunday night lead to a two week ban. Pretty lame. Hopefully this, and the Cloke decision derails Collingwood's season and window!

[nutbean 8,837]

I have no problem with AFL players drinking. It's not illigal and if it doesnt effect their on field form then there is no real problem in my eyes.

Legality has nothing to do with this issue.

I have a problem with being out at ridiculous hours of the morning drinking alcohol if you are professional athlete. This is a profession these boys have chosen and are paid handsomely for - part of the return is that players present themselves in the BEST physical shape they can.

Point me at any Sports medicine professional that will tell me that staying at 2am drinking (irrespective of how many) does not detract in any way from being physically at your best.

Its not about only about form - its also about a team rules. I am a one pot screamer (I wear it as a badge of honour) as opposed to my girlfriend who could drink Demonland under the table. So do clubs make two rules ? Ms Nutbean- go out and make merry as it has no impact on your form but Mr Nutbean, no going out for you young man.

Team rules are there for a reason.

If you chose AFL as a profession then abide by the standards and rules required. You want to go to Tramps to 2am in the morning and have a drink or two - fine- don't be an AFL footballer. There are choices.

[nutbean 8,837]

What kind of world are we living in when a few drinks on a Sunday night lead to a two week ban.

A world where you are paid in excess of $500K a year to be an elite athlete presenting yourself in the best condition you can.

[Deestroy All 14,262]

A world where you are paid in excess of $500K a year to be an elite athlete presenting yourself in the best condition you can.

Well Swanny has never done that.

Edited August 8, 2012 by Deestroy All