Just how good will Nic Naitanui become?

[Range Rover 1,935]

Taking off my Melbourne glasses for a moment, watching the big dreadlocked unit terrorize Carlton last night, I actually began to wonder if we may be witnessing the emergence of one of the greatest players in the history of the game.

I'm serious.

This is not a Jack Watts bashing thread. I'm a Jack fan. But sporting genius must be acknowledged.

This guy is a freakshow the likes of which the game has never seen before. And now he's putting together four quarter matchwinning performances.

I'd like to know what other posters think.

Edited June 14, 2012 by Range Rover

[Jesse Christ 2,884]

I think we're about to see a Jack Watts thread.

[Jordie_tackles 354]

Taking off my Melbourne glasses for a moment, watching the big dreadlocked unit terrorize Carlton last night, I actually began to wonder if we may be witnessing the emergence of one of the greatest players in the history of the game.

I'm serious.

This is not a Jack Watts bashing thread. I'm a Jack fan. But sporting genius must be acknowledged.

This guy is a freakshow the likes of which the game has never seen before. And now he's putting together four quarter matchwinning performances.

I'd like to know what other posters think.

When was his last match winning performance? i like him too but i think his good games get hyped so they dont focus on his other average games personally.

edit obviously played well last night

Edited June 14, 2012 by Jordie_tackles

[Radar Detector 1,347]

His talents are unquestionable and his game last night was awesome. But in 64 games playing as an on-baller this was only the THIRD TIME IN HIS CAREER he's hit 20 touches. And his kicking is iffy. He could become anything but the hype exceeds his output to date IMO.

[ICU2 Jerry Jerry 257]

When was his last match winning performance? i like him too but i think his good games get hyped so they dont focus on his other average games personally.

edit obviously played well last night

When has Jack Watts even had one?

Seriously there is nothing at all wrong with realising we got the pick wrong and appreciating the superstar that is Nic Nat

[Sir Why You Little 37,128]

Nik Nat is an awesome talent. We gotta deal with that one. His 2nd half tonight was quite scary.

Jack is a solid player thus far.

[binman 43,762]

When has Jack Watts even had one?

Seriously there is nothing at all wrong with realising we got the pick wrong and appreciating the superstar that is Nic Nat

He's a talent no doubt but there is no way we got the wrong player. In time both clubs will win on this deal.

[ICU2 Jerry Jerry 257]

He's a talent no doubt but there is no way we got the wrong player. In time both clubs will win on this deal.

I'm sorry but how can you say that?

Even if Jack turns into a superstar in 3 years, Nic Nat already is one.

We would have at best missed 3 years of having a superstar on our list.

We got it wrong. Why as a collective is it wrong to admit it?

The sooner we do the better for everyone. Including Jack

[Jordie_tackles 354]

When has Jack Watts even had one?

Seriously there is nothing at all wrong with realising we got the pick wrong and appreciating the superstar that is Nic Nat

Did i mention Watts this is a NIK NAT thread.....sorry for suggesting he isnt going to be "one of the greatest players ever to play AFL" lol

[Jordie_tackles 354]

I'm sorry but how can you say that?

Even if Jack turns into a superstar in 3 years, Nic Nat already is one.

We would have at best missed 3 years of having a superstar on our list.

We got it wrong. Why as a collective is it wrong to admit it?

The sooner we do the better for everyone. Including Jack

Nik Nat is not a superstar, he has shown more than watts yes, his best is amazingly good, he hasnt shown the consistency required though imo, non at all is game winner on his day but so is Sylvia

[Sir Why You Little 37,128]

Nik Nat is not a superstar, he has shown more than watts yes, his best is amazingly good, he hasnt shown the consistency required though imo, non at all is game winner on his day but so is Sylvia

Nik Nat is a superstar. Get used to it.

[Range Rover 1,935]

His tackling closing speed and the force with which he dumps blokes is amazing. And he tackles to hurt.

He also has amazing anticipation and seemed to be able to gather up the pill one-touch in the wet when others were fumbling.

These are not things big men are supposed to be able to do.

[ICU2 Jerry Jerry 257]

Nik Nat is not a superstar, he has shown more than watts yes, his best is amazingly good, he hasnt shown the consistency required though imo, non at all is game winner on his day but so is Sylvia

you are deluded.

[Mad_Melbourne 877]

Nic Nat is an athlete rather than footy player, the good stuff he does is really good, and he has a lot of room for improvement, but he often fades out of games, often doesn't really use the ball well, and his disposal doesn't have much influence. What he does do is win hit outs, 26 a game on average, and he does do that one or two flashy things that people talk about! He is an icing on the top player, rather than a cake mix player, a very nice icing to have, but icing none the less

[Range Rover 1,935]

Nic Nat is an athlete rather than footy player, the good stuff he does is really good, and he has a lot of room for improvement, but he often fades out of games, often doesn't really use the ball well, and his disposal doesn't have much influence. What he does do is win hit outs, 26 a game on average, and he does do that one or two flashy things that people talk about! He is an icing on the top player, rather than a cake mix player, a very nice icing to have, but icing none the less

No way. Sorry MM but you're way off here.

He's both a superhuman athlete AND a footy player. He's the cakemix, the self-raising flour, the icing and the strawberries ... all rolled into one.

He's the flash and the bash, the crash AND the dash. And he's turning into a one-man wrecking crew before our very eyes.

He didn't fade out tonight one bit. Looked like he could've gone another hour at full tilt in fact.

Did you actually watch the game?

Edited June 14, 2012 by Range Rover

[Good Times Grimes 2,396]

Nik Nat is a superstar. Get used to it.

He has the potential to be, and he was great last night, but he isn't a superstar yet. He needs to back up his performance last night several times over before he is a superstar, IMO.

[bing181 9,328]

Nik Nat is a superstar. Get used to it.

He's a media star because of who he is and how he looks, and good luck to him.

But he won't make AA this year, or perhaps any year, so difficult to see how he's a footballing superstar.

[Chelly 827]

If anything his form demonstrates our stupidity in allowing Carlton to lose the Kreuzer Cup game. Had we lost we would have had picks 1 & 2 the following year enabling us to take both Watts and Naitanui.

[Mad_Melbourne 877]

No way. Sorry MM but you're way off here.

He's both a superhuman athlete AND a footy player. He's the cakemix, the self-raising flour, the icing and the strawberries ... all rolled into one.

He's the flash and the bash, the crash AND the dash. And he's turning into a one-man wrecking crew before our very eyes.

He didn't fade out tonight one bit. Looked like he could've gone another hour at full tilt in fact.

Did you actually watch the game?

I'm speaking about him throughout his career so far, but he definitely had a blinder today, what I liked most about him was his constant effort for the hard ball! But it's not like he plays to that standard weekly, if he can back it up consistently then he will become the cake mix aswell, but still he is a flash in the pan.

No doubt he is going to be a very good player, but I still think on the whole, at the moment, he tends to fade out of games and be ineffective through his disposal.

[Dr. Gonzo 24,297]

Give him anopther 3 years (like we all say big men need to develop) and he will be beasting the competition. He has not peaked already.

[bush demon 2,062]

His tap-on, running bounces remind me of Ron Barassi, and his towering marks and clever handballs to advantage remind me of Polly Farmer.

[Sir Why You Little 37,128]

Roving his own Ruck Work...he ripped out a handball in the last Quarter last night from a pack of players. Bullet like. Superb.

[satyricon 267]

The journalists and commentators go apeshit and the sheep on here follow.....

he is a very good player but superstar NO

(we would be raving about our own young gun ruckman but unfortunately he injured his knee)

Nik Nat has put one good 4 quarter effort together FINALLY.......open door for the 'let's bag the Club no matter what" posters on here

Now if I am not mistaken he still has one of the games top ruckman of the last 10 years playing in the same team, so the whole burden is not his shoulders....remember that.....let's see how he goes when Cox is not there

Edited June 14, 2012 by satyricon

[Sir Why You Little 37,128]

The journalists and commentators go apeshit and the sheep on here follow.....

he is a very good player but superstar NO

(we would be raving about our own young gun ruckman but unfortunately he injured his knee)

Nik Nat has put one good 4 quarter effor together FINALLY.......open door for the 'let's bag the Club no matter what" posters on here

Now if I am not mistaken he still has one of the games top ruckman of the last 10 years playing in the same team, so the whole burden is not his shoulders....remember that.....let's see how he goes when Cox is not there

Are you calling me a sheep for enjoying natural talent??

[Tony Tea 2,809]

If you thought "$cully to GWS" was a feisty rumpus, imagine the uproar caused by the "Nikanui back to Perth" saga.