WHO ARE WE?

[Demonland 71,613]

WHO ARE WE? by Whispering Jack

A lot of water has flowed under the bridge since Melbourne's NAB Cup win over Collingwood when we were all so excited about the direction the club was taking under new coach Mark Neeld. It might have been a Mickey Mouse NAB Cup game in which both teams were missing regular key players, but there were definite signs that the hard work of summer was about to pay some dividends.

It's hard to believe that only one month has elapsed since that time of unbridled optimism for the immediate future of the Melbourne Football Club.

Since then the club has lurched from one disaster after another starting with the Liam Jurrah crisis and reaching a crescendo with a disastrous situation created by Jason Mifsud, an AFL official talking out of school to media person Grant Thomas who promptly published untrue allegations against Demon coach Mark Neeld. What should be a major crisis for the AFL and it's leadership has been turned into an opportunity for diverse groups and individuals to dump on one of its clubs.

In the interim, Melbourne has barely raised a whimper on the field copping a couple of NAB Cup wallopings and a humiliating 41 point drubbing at home against the Brisbane Lions who finished in 15th place last year.

Moreover, the club has been subjected to a blaze of criticism from good judges of football and from the bad. David King claims that "Melbourne has been masquerading as a football club for years". Robert Shaw says "Jack Watts was hijacked by the Melbourne Football Club at 17 years of age ... straight into an institution." Others accuse the playing group of being mentally and physically fragile, lacking in talent and demonstrating a shortage of the pride, passion and interest necessary to achieve success. Some of the criticism is justified but some of it is muddled and without any depth of thought or insight.

The usual response when a team gets a lashing from the press is to return fire and prove the pundits wrong. Melbourne's problem is that it faces a the difficult task of rejuvenation in what has become it's "house of hell" - Paterson's Stadium - a cursed place where not a single current Melbourne player has seen victory. It last won there in Round 19, 2002.

A few years before that, the Demons did manage to produce a shock victory over the Eagles in Perth with an undermanned and depleted side. That was in round 14, 1998 when Melbourne 14.12.96 defeated West Coast 11.13.79 in Robbo's break out game. It would be an understatement to say that the club needs a repeat of the heroics the team produced on that day.

Demon coach Mark Neeld has ridden the waves of last week's disasters with class. He was impressive in handling the after match presser last Saturday and has been strong on the Mifsud issue correctly shunning the advice of AFL CEO Andrew Demetriou to take legal action over Thomas' comments. Neeld is resolute. He isn't interested in pursuing personal vendettas or engaging in witch hunts over who leaked the story to the AFL official who passed on the malicious gossip to someone who wasn't too particular about fact checking, a practice employed by most reputable journalists before going to print.

He knows he has to keep focussed on the main purpose of his job and that is to develop his list, to win games and ultimately, premierships. The greatest coach in the club's history was brought down in the midst of preoccupation with a defamation action, a situation from which it has never fully recovered.

The team Neeld takes across the Nullarbor must not be distracted by the off field events. The players need to show that they're prepared to have a dip as they did a month ago against one of the competition's flag favourites. Their performance this week against the Eagles could well define the direction they will take in the coming months and years.

It will prove who we are as a club.

The greatest glory in living lies not in never falling, but in rising every time we fall.

- Ralph Waldo Emerson (American author and poet)

THE GAME

West Coast Eagles v Melbourne at Paterson's Stadium - Saturday 7 April 2012 at 4:40pm (AEST).

HEAD TO HEAD

Overall West Coast 27 wins Melbourne 15 wins

At Patersons Stadium West Coast 13 wins Melbourne 5 wins

Since 2000 West Coast 11 wins Melbourne 7 wins

The Coaches Worsfold 0 wins Neeld 0 wins

MEDIA

Fox Footy Channel live at 4.30 pm (Victoria)

RADIO SEN ABC774

THE BETTING

West Coast to win $1.06 Melbourne to win $9.00

LAST TIME THEY MET

West Coast 16.14.110 defeated Melbourne 9.8.62 at Etihad Stadium Round 21, 2011

The Demons were two weeks into the post Dean Bailey era and after a competitive first twenty minutes or so, managed to sink into the standard insipid fare they produced at the time. Jeremy Howe was a stand out and Sam Blease showed some flashes but for the most part it was dross.

THE TEAMS

WEST COAST EAGLES

Backs Beau Waters Darren Glass Will Schofield

Half backs Adam Selwood

Eric Mackenzie Shannon Hurn

Centreline Andrew Gaff Matthew Priddis Matthew Rosa

Half forwards Ashton Hams Quinten Lynch Jack Darling

Forwards Josh Hill Josh Kennedy Chris Masten

Followers Dean Cox Luke Shuey Daniel Kerr

Interchange Andrew Embley Nic Naitanui Scott Selwood Ashley Smith

Emergencies Sam Butler Patrick McGinnity Gerrick Weedon

No change.

MELBOURNE

Backs Clint Bartram James Frawley Joel Macdonald

Half backs Colin Garland Jared Rivers Jamie Bennell

Centreline Nathan Jones Jack Grimes Jack Watts

Half forwards Jeremy Howe James Sellar Ricky Petterd

Forwards Brad Green Mitchell Clark Lynden Dunn

Followers Mark Jamar James Magner Jack Trengove

Interchange Rohan Bail Matthew Bate Tom McDonald Jordie McKenzie

Emergencies Aaron Davey Josh Tynan (Stef Martin)

In Jamie Bennell Lynden Dunn Tom McDonald Ricky Petterd James Sellar

Out Sam Blease Aaron Davey Stef Martin Brent Moloney (injured) Josh Tynan

New James Sellar (Adelaide)

Umpires L Farmer M Leppard G Fila

RAINY DAY WOMEN #12 & 35

"Well, they’ll stone ya when you’re trying to be so good

They’ll stone ya just a-like they said they would

They’ll stone ya when you’re tryin’ to go home

Then they’ll stone ya when you’re there all alone

But I would not feel so all alone

Everybody must get stoned"

- by Bob Dylan

I couldn't help thinking about this Dylan song every time I picked up a newspaper or switched on the radio or television set this week. And just so you don't get any wrong impressions, the writer has said of his work that the reference to stoning was in the biblical sense.

It seems no matter what happens, whether the truth is told about us or not, whether we do the honourable thing or not, we're going to get "stoned" and the critics are out there like vultures circling their prey particularly because we're vulnerable at the moment.

And perhaps it's because of that vulnerability that the West Coast Eagles are treating this game with a touch of caution. They happen to be almost the flavour of the month after coming into last season as the previous year's wooden spooner, rising to preliminary finalists and opening last week with a big away from home win against the Bulldogs (who should prepare themselves for a stoning if they fail in Adelaide on Saturday).

The Eagles don't have an A class midfield like the other premiership contenders but it's handy and has some emerging young contenders like Shuey, Gaff and Masten to go with experienced hands in Priddis, Kerr, Scott Selwood and Rosa. The Eagles also have what many would call the competition's predominant ruck division in Cox and Naitanui.

The comparison with Melbourne couldn't be starker if you go on last week's form where it got nothing from its ruck division or from its onballers at the stoppages. When you then consider that the Demons couldn't better the Eagles at home two years ago when they were wooden spooners, it suggests we're in for another one-sided contest again this weekend.

While the indications are that the team hasn't bottomed out after the disruptions of the past month and the process of adjusting to a new style of play, there are some glimmers of hope on the horizon.

The two young co-captains are in the starting midfield. Jack Grimes had about four minutes there in last year's Adelaide game before he was injured. There are many who believe he has the capacity to add some flair to the Demon on ball division. Likewise, Trengove who had an interrupted pre season and showed some early good signs last week is ready to take another step forward in the midfield. Nathan Jones is progressing well in his second year in a leadership role and James Magner was a revelation in his debut last week. With players like these stepping up to the plate, there is no reason why club could not improve quickly around the stoppages and reverse the disasters of the last half of last week's game.

It's a tough ask especially with Melbourne winning only 4 of its past 28 games on the road (and half of them were on neutral territory). On the other hand, the Demons have a strong defence when it gets its act together and it’s been augmented this week by the size of James Sellar. Similarly, the attack now has a tall key in Mitch Clark who took a while to get going last week. This week Ricky Petterd and Lynden Dunn come in to assist him and we’re all waiting for Jack Watts and Jeremy Howe to take the extra step forward.

I keep coming back to that 1998 game when the Demons won against all odds in the west. I think of how competent and composed the current squad looked against Collingwood a month ago and how the team dominated possession in the latter half of last week’s first term but failed to score goals to match their ascendency. These are all long shots but if they click, the score will be a lot closer than many of the experts who are stoning us right now would have us all think.

West Coast by 16 points.

[jabberwocky 2,301]

Ah footy...go dees.

Another game of football, another opportunity.

[Nasher 33,607]

I forgot there was a match on this weekend.

[GawnWithTheWind 604]

.......................... "and the two Melbourne captains appear from the ashes and become the leaders of men we desperately need"

Backs against the wall, side by side, 22 men to take a stand for the future of this club.

[Blistering 538]

We need to remember each and every person who was willing to sink the boots in when we were down and out and give them heaps on our way up.

It's us against the world so let's start making these b#^&st@*ds eat their words!

[McQueen 17,864]

I tell you what, when all of the shite does pass by and we start playing some good footy, I can't help but think that this playing group is going to become one of the most galvanised, hard-arsed bunch of players going around.

Talk about learning from experience! The emotions the whole club has gone/going through can't be simulated.

Last week is history and we learnt that making a stand is something more than the players assumed.

Stand up and be counted lads.

Go DEE'S

[drdrake 3,162]

There is a very good chance our players have been in a plane this morning, I wonder if they even know what has transpired over the past couple of hours. Selection is going to be interesting.

[hardtack 10,514]

There is a very good chance our players have been in a plane this morning, I wonder if they even know what has transpired over the past couple of hours. Selection is going to be interesting.

Considering that MelbourneFC tweeted the following about an hour ago, I think they are probably very aware:

"Players have taken it into their own hands to remove EW logos from their polos"

[Chook 15,012]

I tell you what, when all of the shite does pass by and we start playing some good footy, I can't help but think that this playing group is going to become one of the most galvanised, hard-arsed bunch of players going around.

Talk about learning from experience! The emotions the whole club has gone/going through can't be simulated.

Last week is history and we learnt that making a stand is something more than the players assumed.

Stand up and be counted lads.

Go DEE'S

Too true. Sh*t like this doesn't make you weak. It makes you tough.

[Whispering_Jack 29,795]

Too true. Sh*t like this doesn't make you weak. It makes you tough.

Chris Connolly: "Challenges like these only work to make us stronger and more united, as we focus on high performance with high integrity."

[888Dee 6]

Boys just arrived here in Perth. Didnt see Davey or Beamer.

[PJ_12345 1,098]

Apparently according to 9 news Davey has been dropped for this round...

In no relation to the Mifsud/Thomas incident - unfortunately just played like rubbish last week

[Harcourt 146]

In:Petterd, Sellar, Dunn, Bennell

Out: Moloney (inj), Tynan, Davey, Blease

[kryton101 395]

"Players have taken it into their own hands to remove EW logos from their polos"

Would love to see them come out with skin showing where they cut the offending logo off - what a great statement it make

[Jaded No More 68,867]

Oh yeah, football. Forgot about that.

LOL at Moloney's "injury". Soft. Wish they had just said "omitted for playing like garbage".

The sad thing is, our midfield just went from bad to worse!

[Nasher 33,607]

Black tape, rather than scissors apparently.

[Demonland 71,613]

Oh yeah, football. Forgot about that.

LOL at Moloney's "injury". Soft. Wish they had just said "omitted for playing like garbage".

The sad thing is, our midfield just went from bad to worse!

Also wins him the Mystery Injury of the Week!

[Guest Jackie]

I wonder if it's knee soreness for Moloney? Would have loved to see Couch in.

[Jaded No More 68,867]

I wonder if it's knee soreness for Moloney? Would have loved to see Couch in.

They said "groin", which is the new "general soreness", which the old "omitted",

[The Lobster Effect 887]

I wonder if it's knee soreness for Moloney? Would have loved to see Couch in.

yeh why didnt couch make it in as moloney's replacement?

[Sir Why You Little 36,981]

Us against Them..I think that is right...The Club has got to strengthen itself.

I am glad Mclardy spoke tonight...everyone is in...

Just make us proud tomorrow night Demons....We all need it, I am still getting over Jimmy not being with us....a solid hit out (win) even would help immensly.

[Lil_red_fire_engine 11,115]

In:Petterd, Sellar, Dunn, Bennell

Out: Moloney (inj), Tynan, Davey, Blease

Good changes, I wonder whether Moloney played sore last week saw the axe swinging and then mentioned groin soreness. Tynan stiff but the right move he had a dip but looked a little overawed. Couch stiff but the big ground would not suit him. Really wonder what T-Mac has to do to get a game.

Congratulations and best of luck to Sellar on his first game for the MFC.

[Nasher 33,607]

Oh yeah, football. Forgot about that.

LOL at Moloney's "injury". Soft. Wish they had just said "omitted for playing like garbage".

The sad thing is, our midfield just went from bad to worse!

It is possible he is actually injured. Presumably he won't line up for Casey where Blease, Davey and Tynan will be.

As for the selections - I'm happy with that. Bennell should get a crack at the role Blease and Davey failed to deliver on. Sellar has a role to play on Lynch, and Petterd is automatic best 22 at this stage. Dunn in by default - not much point in selecting another super-slow mid in Couch for Patterson. Tynan not ready.

[daisycutter 29,604]

In:Petterd, Sellar, Dunn, Bennell

Out: Moloney (inj), Tynan, Davey, Blease

general soreness?

[Deestroy All 14,262]

Can't say I'm happy with these selections.

We were murdered in the middle and haven't added anything to it.

We saw what Magner brought, Couch had a similar pre season and played well last week. Should've been in for Moloney.

Green should be out to fit Dunn in.

Glad Petterd is in.

I don't like Bennell, and despite my earlier thoughts, I would've let Davey have one more chance after this week, see what sort of ticker he has. But there was no turning back after making the "blind faith" comment.

In the end, ins and outs won't make any difference to this game. It's going to be a nightmare.