The Scullduggery Thread

[H_T 3,043]

Grant Thomas' take on precedings . Implicating the AFL re the $cully saga .

http://wwos.ninemsn....owcomments=true

Thomo taking particular aim at Sir Andrew.

[Range Rover 1,935]

Thomo taking particular aim at Sir Andrew.

Your link didn't work for me HT. This one did ... http://wwos.ninemsn....owcomments=true

Good on Thomo. Should be on the back pages of all newspapers that piece.

The most disturbing sentence from it ... It is alleged around footy circles that former Collingwood and Brisbane football guru Gubby Allen, has been sworn away from recruiting Collingwood players (specifically Pendlebury) at the request of Eddie McGuire.

Edited November 28, 2011 by Range Rover

[Macca 16,923]

Your link didn't work for me HT. This one did ... http://wwos.ninemsn....owcomments=true

Good on Thomo. Should be on the back pages of all newspapers that piece.

The most disturbing sentence from it ... It is alleged around footy circles that former Collingwood and Brisbane football guru Gubby Allen, has been sworn away from recruiting Collingwood players (specifically Pendlebury) at the request of Eddie McGuire.

Maybe Eddie has got some dirt on Gubby ! Wouldn't surprise me .

Well at least we've got Caro and Thommo on the case . The rest of the Melbourne media don't wanna bite the hand ..........

Patrick Smith might jump in but to read certain content in the Oz online now you need to subscribe ( free for 3 months and then what ? ) ( Herald Sun next ? )

Edited November 28, 2011 by Nuggets

[Mazer Rackham 14,971]

Maguire has done a deal with Grubby Allen to make Collingwood players exempt from being approached by GWS .

Reminds me of Sheedys promise to Hird that Essenedon players wouldn't be targeted either .

And you would trust Allen or Sheedy to uphold this? Or any agreement should it prove to be inconvenient?

[rolly 149]

thanks to GW$ taking the dodgy knee off our hands we get a compensation pick for next year. jack viney will force us to use our first round draft pick to claim him under the father son rule but thanks to the compo pick which can be activated after the first live pick we still get to pick up whoever we want anyway and we don't have half our salary cap going to the injured list... good luck to GW$ when they get 32 games out of there $6mil over the length of his contract

[Dr. Gonzo 24,192]

This comment by Demetriou once again gets to the heart of the problem of GWS and to a lesser extent Gold Coast. The ADMINISTRATOR of the competition is so compromised in their aim to ensure success for these two teams that they are openly willing to disadvantage the existing clubs in order to achieve their goal. They know that the Vic, WA & SA fans are so loyal to their clubs and the game that there is no risk in disenfranchising the heartland supporters for a decade or so in their reach for new markets and money. GWS & GC are not mere football clubs or franchises, they are new PRODUCTS created by the AFL to break into a market they previously could not penetrate.

[Whispering_Jack 29,805]

Those who say we should move on should be aware of the distinction between the need for our club to move on from the Scully scandal and the position of individual supporters.

I believe the club moved on from this immediately after the post Scully press conference which happened on the day of the defection. I also think the club did it brilliantly and with class and in direct contrast to the shameful way GWS, the AFL and Demetriou have handled themselves in the aftermath. That our club has distanced itself from the farce and so capably managed its coaching appointments, the trade week and even the draft is an incredible result in view of the disarray that was evident in July and August.

As for we supporters, given all that's transpired, surely nobody can stand in the way of us died-in-the-wool fans lapping it up as we watch the embarrassment of a shonky bunch of as they sink further and further in the mire?

And this ain't over yet.

[Sir Why You Little 36,985]

Those who say we should move on should be aware of the distinction between the need for our club to move on from the Scully scandal and the position of individual supporters.

I believe the club moved on from this immediately after the post Scully press conference which happened on the day of the defection. I also think the club did it brilliantly and with class and in direct contrast to the shameful way GWS, the AFL and Demetriou have handled themselves in the aftermath. That our club has distanced itself from the farce and so capably managed its coaching appointments, the trade week and even the draft is an incredible result in view of the disarray that was evident in July and August.

As for we supporters, given all that's transpired, surely nobody can stand in the way of us died-in-the-wool fans lapping it up as we watch the embarrassment of a shonky bunch of as they sink further and further in the mire?

And this ain't over yet.

Well said WJ...it is quite remarkable how quickly the Club stood up, after the Black Cloud had moved on...But we still deserve to know the truth to all this dirt...

[monoccular 17,413]

Those who say we should move on should be aware of the distinction between the need for our club to move on from the Scully scandal and the position of individual supporters.

I believe the club moved on from this immediately after the post Scully press conference which happened on the day of the defection. I also think the club did it brilliantly and with class and in direct contrast to the shameful way GWS, the AFL and Demetriou have handled themselves in the aftermath. That our club has distanced itself from the farce and so capably managed its coaching appointments, the trade week and even the draft is an incredible result in view of the disarray that was evident in July and August.

As for we supporters, given all that's transpired, surely nobody can stand in the way of us died-in-the-wool fans lapping it up as we watch the embarrassment of a shonky bunch of as they sink further and further in the mire?

And this ain't over yet.

Spot on WJ - we the fans have every right to [censored] about the rat, his father and Dimitrou. He has every right to choose his path in life, but he blatantly lied about it on several occasions, and even pledged undying loyalty and love!

And as regards the title of this thread - INTEGRITY - AFL - a new classic oxymoron.

Edited November 28, 2011 by monoccular

[Satan 2,870]

Greater Western Sydney wants rethink on Phil Scully money

[Jack Jack 415]

The AFL couldn't possibly go back on their ruling. They'd be opening up a huge can of worms.

Maybe they're just making noise for the benefit of Sssssssscully Snr, make him feel a bit more legitimate?

[Deestroy All 14,262]

[Macca 16,923]

Well , no surprise here , especially with Vlad's "Stroke of Genius" comment late last week . Another carefully orchestrated little plan to keep GW$ in the news . There's going to be lots more of this sort of stuff . It's all rather pathetic but what can we do about it ?

Also read that Sheedy reckons they have 12,500 members - what a load of rot ! The lies just keep coming and of course the AFL will back it up .

I only hope it fires up our Club as much as it's fired up the fans . Round 13 can't come around quick enough .

Edited November 28, 2011 by Nuggets

[Demon 16 209]

This whole sordid saga is making a mockery out of the AFL competition and its administration.

[Sir Why You Little 36,985]

This whole sordid saga is making a mockery out of the AFL competition and its administration.

that it is. At least it is all being reported, it will not be swept under the mat. It's only november!!

[Dee Landing 9]

To say Tommy the liar is courageous is a farce. Stuff him B)

[Tatu 416]

What an absolute joke all this has become! The AFL competition is a farce! If any other club hired a players family, to secure a players services. They be done for salary cap breaches... Salary cap fixing....Draft fixing......the Fixture....What a joke!!!

[Pink Freud 364]

I agree with Matthews.

Let's re-open the whole thing and have an independent panel look into the entire conduct of the AFL, GWS and the Scully clan and also investigate whether the compensation package offered by the AFL is adequate. Does pick 1 in the 2009 draft + two year's input into a player = two mid first rounders plus at least an extra twelve months before you can activate them.

Let's see some transparency, integrity and some justice at the AFL.

[Guest melbman]

GWS are also petitioning the AFL to be awarded the 2014 premiership cup now on the proviso that they perform the work later. This falls under the GWS clause "delayed workification"

The argument is that if they keep their current players and future concessions they are then a certainty for 2014 glory therefore if they receive the reward now, the players will stay and they will then have the capacity to perform the work required in 2014. "What could be fairer than that?" they say.

And in other news, Pendlebury Snr will be heading up the GWS raffle and Cadbury fund raising department at 150K per annum. He is currently an expert fund raiser across town on 5K per annum

[Good Times Grimes 2,396]

I wouldn't be at all surprised if his salary was removed from the cap. The AFL will bend over backwards to ensure GW$ is able to retain all its young players.

[daisycutter 29,604]

I wouldn't be at all surprised if his salary was removed from the cap. The AFL will bend over backwards to ensure GW$ is able to retain all its young players.

I think they are far better at bending over forwards when its in their grubby interests

[Range Rover 1,935]

The fish rots at the head. New blood is needed in the AFL high chair because the current bloke is sullying the brand with this mess.

[Range Rover 1,935]

And this from the AFL website ... http://www.afl.com.au/news/newsarticle/tabid/208/newsid/126642/default.aspx

I love this bit .... The tabloid reports that "Matthews has raised the issue with AFL football operations manager Adrian Anderson" but does not elaborate.

"Having walked away from the AFL to join the club, I will be doing everything in the best interests of this club," Matthews said.

Yeah right!

[rpfc 28,263]

And this from the AFL website ... http://www.afl.com.a...42/default.aspx

I love this bit .... The tabloid reports that "Matthews has raised the issue with AFL football operations manager Adrian Anderson" but does not elaborate.

"Having walked away from the AFL to join the club, I will be doing everything in the best interests of this club," Matthews said.

Yeah right!

I can certainly see Matthews living up to the italicised bit.

The AFL just wants everyone to move on, and he wants the best outcome for his club.

Ken Wood is the one who got them to put the money in the cap, and he would be one of the few I trust at the AFL to do what is right, and not what is right for the AFL.

I cannot see Wood changing his ruling or altering his findings.

But good on Matthews for annoying head office.

[Robbie57 2,020]

What is disturbing to me is the AFL appears to have lost its moral compass on this issue.

Their whatever it takes attitude to establish a beach head Western Sydney means that actions that would be significant breaches by other clubs become worthy of re-examination, players who take a $1M to become the best paid in the league are courageous, income splitting cap avoidance schemes are "strokes of genius" and anyone who questions the "vision" is victimising GWS and its players.

The reality is this the other clubs (including ours) are making sacrifices to help GWS get established and expect it and the AFL then to play by the spirit of the game and rules. My view: putting parents on a salary creates a distortion in the market for players, players are fully entitled to get the best reward for themselves but that’s exactly what it is hardly an act of courage and throwing money at a player beyond what the market would ordinarily bear is not an act of genius. In my view a CEO who applauds such nonsense and forgets the sacrifices being made by the whole football community is not acting in the best interests of the game.

Finally, GWS appear to have adopted a position of gloating and goading which has been a PR disaster. They deserve the bad press and supporters response.

What GWS should have done is thanked the Clubs (who by the way are the reason the AFL exists) for the sacrifices they are making in talent and financially.