MFC midfield 2012

[Curry & Beer 5,444]

1. bail
   
2. blease
   
3. gysberts
   
4. trengove
   
5. sylvia
   
6. moloney
   
7. mckenzie
   
8. jones
   

[Yoda 33]

Sylvia, Moloney and Trengove form a pretty solid front three and there are some gems to develop but we're still missing one quality, hard-nosed type with experience. The youngsters will fill that void in time but in the meanwhile I still can't see us competing in the guts over four quarters with top four sides.

I note Davey is no longer considered an option C & B.

[DemonWA 3,940]

what is this thread? is this the order in which you think they'll be selected?

Midfield will be the same as last year when scully was injured....Still think Blease will be plaed predominantly off the HBF, and Sylvia predominantly from the HFF.

[DeeSpencer 26,498]

Do the numbers mean something? Midfield is all about rotations and top end quality. We probably don't have the quality next year, especially if we have injuries. We need to replace Scully with another gun in addition to Viney to be what we want him to be. But in the meantime we need half forwards who can rotate in - Sylvia and Petterd for a start. A fit and firing Aaron Davey playing both deep forward and also in the midfield where he can break lines is also crucial.

C: Davey Moloney Jones

HF: Sylvia ********** Petterd

Foll: Jamar McKenzie Trengove

Int: Martin Gysberts Bail

[Fitz Fitzpatrick 886]

Blease off HB is potentially a real weapon. I would not be suprised if sylvia can be re invented as a real goer in the engine room as well. If so, him along with moloney and jones and eventually viney can inject some real muscle around the ball. Sylvia is a bit lazy around the ball at times but if neeld can give him a good kick up the **** the side has some real inside strength

[Fitz Fitzpatrick 886]

Grimes and blease off half back will be exciting stuff i reckon

[Roost It 1,434]

1. bail
   
2. blease
   
3. gysberts
   
4. trengove
   
5. sylvia
   
6. moloney
   
7. mckenzie
   
8. jones
   

Trengove

Grimes

Sylvia

Mckenzie

Gysberts

Jones

Moloney

Blease HB

Davey FP

[Curry & Beer 5,444]

sorry all for the incomplete thread.. something stuffed up and then I got distracted

Just wanted to hear everyone's thoughts on how we will fare this year in the midfield - it's fair to say we were pretty awful this year, even with Beamer having quite a fine year. To top it off we've lost Scully!

Unfortunately I can't see a lot of improvement in that list, Jones is capable of going up another cog and I already rate him.

And yeah, Davey is not an onballer, you have to get your hands dirty to be one. No disrespect to him but he has never been that type of player. We should continue to use him off HB, although everyone figured out long ago how to nullify him in this role.

Very interesting to see what effect having a (should have been) back-to-back premiership midfield coach at the helm will have

[Jesse Christ 2,884]

To top it off we've lost Scully!

Unfortunately I can't see a lot of improvement in that list, Jones is capable of going up another cog and I already rate him.

How many games did $ully play for us again? His loss can be easily negated. A full season out of Grimes or Gysberts should see to that.

And although it's not written in the wind, I can see a lot of improvement in that list- Full pre-seasons can do miraculous things for young players, at this age their scope of improvement is still significant. And any player is capable of stepping up a cog, could be Jones, could be anyone.

[PartyTimeJohnny 537]

Trengove

Jones

Moloney

Gysberts

Mckenzie

EVANS

Bail

and hey, maybe a cheeky bit of Blease-Grimes rotation, bit cheeky, i know, but OOOooOOooOO

[Matt Demon 1,579]

Nobody's even mentioned Tappy? He's an interesting prospect. When he played this year It was down back but was really recruited as a FWD/MID.

[Redleg 42,050]

How many games did $ully play for us again? .

Who?

[Fitz Fitzpatrick 886]

gee D.Martin would look good in that list of midfielders wouldnt he. that would be an elite group then

[Demon Disciple 12,494]

gee D.Martin would look good in that list of midfielders wouldnt he. that would be an elite group then

Overrated imo. How many times this year was he somewhat quiet or go missing in games only to rack up disposals when the result of a game was a forgone conclusion, whether the Tiges won or lossed? A fair few. Sure he played a fair few good games too, the occasional blinder, but that was no different than Sylvia, and no one raves about him anywhere near as much.

Plus we will have Viney and potentially another 2 mids to replace $cully with, who hopefully will blow Martin out of the water, in particular the former. He'll personally see to it that Martin is buried 6 feet into the turf at some stage during his career!!!

[Fitz Fitzpatrick 886]

Im looking forward to viney cleaning up Scully. nearly worth re drafting B.Pickett for a couple of games.

[monoccular 17,700]

1. bail
   
2. blease
   
3. gysberts
   
4. trengove
   
5. sylvia
   
6. moloney
   
7. mckenzie
   
8. jones
   

Since Bate now seems a "required player" and doesn't look a forward, maybe Mark sees his "role" as mid?

Throw in Tappy and maybe later Evans and Nicho

[Fitz Fitzpatrick 886]

Overrated imo. How many times this year was he somewhat quiet or go missing in games only to rack up disposals when the result of a game was a forgone conclusion, whether the Tiges won or lossed? A fair few. Sure he played a fair few good games too, the occasional blinder, but that was no different than Sylvia, and no one raves about him anywhere near as much.

Plus we will have Viney and potentially another 2 mids to replace $cully with, who hopefully will blow Martin out of the water, in particular the former. He'll personally see to it that Martin is buried 6 feet into the turf at some stage during his career!!!

I agree he did go missing on occasions but i get the feeling we'll look back to Dustin Martins 2nd year as a typical 2nd season for a young player. i have no doubt he will become an absolute gun.

Do you guys see Neeld looking at Bate as a potential midfielder?

[bandicoot 1,395]

1. bail
   
2. blease
   
3. gysberts
   
4. trengove
   
5. sylvia
   
6. moloney
   
7. mckenzie
   
8. jones
   

How do we compare to the best midfield in the comp - Carlton?

1. Judd

2. Murphy

3. Gibbs

4. Scotland

5. Carazzo

6. Garlett

7. Armfield

Judd is a big bodied player that can handle multiple tacklers - our next best is moloney

Murphy is a skilled mid with great running capacity - next best is trengove

Gibbs is a big bodied player that can kick goals - Sylvia

Scotland is an experienced hard body player - lacking at the dees

carrazzo is an outside player getting the loose ball - next best is bail

Garlett is a quick outside player that creates opportunities - don't really have this type of speedster in our side, maybe bleese/bennell

Armfield is more of a wingman come mid - gysberts

Looks like the only place we are lacking (except for a Judd) is an experienced 28yo and an outside speedster.

1. Maybe bennell could fill that role?

2. Any chance for green to play the Scotland role for parts of the game?

[Fitz Fitzpatrick 886]

Bennell could be an option. he has a lot of upside still and love his pace. hasnt really touched his potential yet. greens had his day in the midfield and i dont think its his spot. I prefer him up forward. when you compare those midfields our inexperience is glaring but i think the potential is very promising

[sylvinator 96]

How do we compare to the best midfield in the comp - Carlton?

1. Judd

2. Murphy

3. Gibbs

4. Scotland

5. Carazzo

6. Garlett

7. Armfield

We have one of, if not the worst midfields in the competition. We don't come close to Carlton, Geelong, Stkilda of Collingwood.

Our defence is strong, with Frawley and Garland 2 10-year stars to base a defence around. Our forward line has the makings to be great as well, with huge talent in Jurrah, Watts and Petterd, Clarke also makes a big difference.

However, until we get a great midfield we will not make the 8.

In my opinion, we need to add two bona fide stars (I'm talking Pendlebury & Thomas quality) IN ADDITION to our current crop to become a great midfield. Hopefully we trade our 2 Scully Compo picks for a midfield star + Viney could do to the trick nicely?

Sylvinator from The Netherlands!

[Fitz Fitzpatrick 886]

We have one of, if not the worst midfields in the competition. We don't come close to Carlton, Geelong, Stkilda of Collingwood.

Our defence is strong, with Frawley and Garland 2 10-year stars to base a defence around. Our forward line has the makings to be great as well, with huge talent in Jurrah, Watts and Petterd, Clarke also makes a big difference.

However, until we get a great midfield we will not make the 8.

In my opinion, we need to add two bona fide stars (I'm talking Pendlebury & Thomas quality) IN ADDITION to our current crop to become a great midfield. Hopefully we trade our 2 Scully Compo picks for a midfield star + Viney could do to the trick nicely?

Sylvinator from The Netherlands!

Our midfield is currently one of the worst for sure but we have the cattle. just need to get some games in to them. a star, strong bodied mid thrown in there will accelerate the process for sure. Blease will be a gun as will trengove.

[PaulRB 6,435]

I'd include Watts and Dunn in the midfield group to add size and grunt when appropriate. I'd even consider if he could get his engine right.

[Radar Detector 1,347]

I tend to agree with Sylvinator. We're one gun mid short at the moment, factoring Viney as an addition for 2013 and Trengove as a potential star. Hopefully we can address that next draft/trade period.

Our forward and backlines now have a great look about them with the most encouraging part being the depth. Cook, Fitzpatrick, McDonald and Davis are all KP prospects that may not get much air time next year but show plenty of promise. Our 2013 spine should be pretty impressive. When we have a midfield to match we will be a serious threat.

[Jesse Christ 2,884]

I tend to agree with Sylvinator. We're one gun mid short at the moment, factoring Viney as an addition for 2013 and Trengove as a potential star. Hopefully we can address that next draft/trade period.

Our forward and backlines now have a great look about them with the most encouraging part being the depth. Cook, Fitzpatrick, McDonald and Davis are all KP prospects that may not get much air time next year but show plenty of promise. Our 2013 spine should be pretty impressive. When we have a midfield to match we will be a serious threat.

Where is Davis at right now? I saw his highlight packages when we drafted him and he looked an incredible FB prospect. He could be our next star in the backline!

Also does anyone feel Evans can get more of a run this year? Looked good!

[Young Blood 2,639]

Evans was held back mainly by injury. I agree his work rate was great!

I think very very highly of Bail. I think his ability to run and break through the stoppages makes him a possible go to running midfielder. He is physically very solid and quick. Maybe just needs to improve his ball use.