I understand that Warnock has expressed a preference for the blues. I think that would be close to a straight swap. Very similar standard players. Both have dodgy kicking and decision making.

Getting O'failpin to Melbourne would be akin to asking Ben Holland to make a comeback; we'd probably get more value out of Ben.

Please let this only be a rumour started by some sadistic Carlton supporter paying us back for Brock. In fact I'd rather take Brock back.

Heard a rumour tonight from the guy 2 in front of me in the checkout queue at Belgrave Safeway, who told the checkout girl that he had heard from a cousin of an assistant coach at Melbourne that they were close to trading Brendon Goddard for Cale Morton and an early draft pick.

Said it was "win-win" because the Saints have salary cap issues and Goddard sees his future at the Dees now the window's closed at St Kilda. What d'you reckon... ?

ClarkyHeraldSun Dees could get Scully replament in 17 yo mini draft. Brad crouch is their man. Will cost one of two 1st rd compo picks. Dream result

Would cream me jocks over this deal, i would give both picks for Crouch

And who stole my avatar??

Heard a rumour tonight from the guy 2 in front of me in the checkout queue at Belgrave Safeway, who told the checkout girl that he had heard from a cousin of an assistant coach at Melbourne that they were close to trading Brendon Goddard for Cale Morton and an early draft pick.

Said it was "win-win" because the Saints have salary cap issues and Goddard sees his future at the Dees now the window's closed at St Kilda. What d'you reckon... ?

Lovely if it happens, but......there is no way in the world the Saints would ever do this deal.

Lovely if it happens, but......there is no way in the world the Saints would ever do this deal.

I think he was taking the p155

Heard a rumour tonight from the guy 2 in front of me in the checkout queue at Belgrave Safeway, who told the checkout girl that he had heard from a cousin of an assistant coach at Melbourne that they were close to trading Brendon Goddard for Cale Morton and an early draft pick.

Said it was "win-win" because the Saints have salary cap issues and Goddard sees his future at the Dees now the window's closed at St Kilda. What d'you reckon... ?

i work at belgrave safeway and i might no the person. now im transsferring to emerald

I think he was taking the p155

Nah, I heard it from Pelchens mistresses brothers mate earlier too.

Heard a rumour tonight from the guy 2 in front of me in the checkout queue at Belgrave Safeway, who told the checkout girl ...

Sounds like a pretty credible source.

Heard a rumour tonight from the guy 2 in front of me in the checkout queue at Belgrave Safeway, who told the checkout girl that he had heard from a cousin of an assistant coach at Melbourne that they were close to trading Brendon Goddard for Cale Morton and an early draft pick.

Said it was "win-win" because the Saints have salary cap issues and Goddard sees his future at the Dees now the window's closed at St Kilda. What d'you reckon... ?

What do I reckon ?

I reckon the checkout girl should involve herself in a trade to Coles, because prices there are going...down, down.

Heard a rumour tonight from the guy 2 in front of me in the checkout queue at Belgrave Safeway, who told the checkout girl that he had heard from a cousin of an assistant coach at Melbourne that they were close to trading Brendon Goddard for Cale Morton and an early draft pick.

Said it was "win-win" because the Saints have salary cap issues and Goddard sees his future at the Dees now the window's closed at St Kilda. What d'you reckon... ?

I'm thinking Stand UP Comedy is not your thing

Getting O'failpin to Melbourne would be akin to asking Ben Holland to make a comeback; we'd probably get more value out of Ben.

Please let this only be a rumour started by some sadistic Carlton supporter paying us back for Brock. In fact I'd rather take Brock back.

I can here the wheels ticking from princes park, here's where we can pay back the Dees for Brock & CJ.

C'mon Craigy, do your thing mate. Have the Crows got a spare tall forward or 2, & do they need a solid tall back?

Heard a rumour tonight from the guy 2 in front of me in the checkout queue at Belgrave Safeway, who told the checkout girl that he had heard from a cousin of an assistant coach at Melbourne that they were close to trading Brendon Goddard for Cale Morton and an early draft pick.

Said it was "win-win" because the Saints have salary cap issues and Goddard sees his future at the Dees now the window's closed at St Kilda. What d'you reckon... ?

I new I should have shopped @ Safeway today, instead of the lousy Indian run Coles I went to. When you ask them where the Weet Bix are, they show round the whole store before ending in the next aisle, and then wait for a Tip.

Goddard you say, No, not 2 comp picks! Morton + P12, or a comp pick next Year? Yes, I think so!

Heard a rumour tonight from the guy 2 in front of me in the checkout queue at Belgrave Safeway, who told the checkout girl that he had heard from a cousin of an assistant coach at Melbourne that they were close to trading Brendon Goddard for Cale Morton and an early draft pick.

Said it was "win-win" because the Saints have salary cap issues and Goddard sees his future at the Dees now the window's closed at St Kilda. What d'you reckon... ?

I didnt realise Belgrave Safeways was such a melbourne obsessed establishment. I was also in there earlier tonight but I herd no such rumours. I shall keep an my ear out in there from now on!!

Edited October 10, 201114 yr by Dan Fantastik

I new I should have shopped @ Safeway today, instead of the lousy Indian run Coles I went to. When you ask them where the Weet Bix are, they show round the whole store before ending in the next aisle, and then wait for a Tip.

You had to ask where the Weet Bix is in a Coles?

Either you made up the story because you don't like Indians, or you really aren't the sharpest tool in the shed.

You had to ask where the Weet Bix is in a Coles?

Either you made up the story because you don't like Indians, or you really aren't the sharpest tool in the shed.

No [censored] sherlock. I'm not too fussed about what they do.

I love trade week

When all is said and done, there will be more said than done

Why they extended it for two days totally escapes me\

Still it is great for those posters anxious to boost their post counts

Bring back zones and form fours I say

Bate to Western Bulldogs

Maric to North

Jordan Lisle to the Dees

mentioned here

http://www.heraldsun.com.au/sport/afl/saints-field-offers-for-gram/story-fn69a32t-1226163554972

Don't know much about Lisle other than all aussie u18 - anyone know much?

If Maric is going to North would entertain a straight swap for Campbell or Urquart.

Will be interesting to see what the cost is for Lisle. is he out of contract?

Don't know much about Lisle other than all aussie u18 - anyone know much?

I posed a similar question based on what I had found out here: http://demonland.com/forums/index.php?/topic/28697-trade-week-discussion/page__view__findpost__p__495426

If Maric is going to North would entertain a straight swap for Campbell or Urquart.

Will be interesting to see what the cost is for Lisle. is he out of contract?

I don't mind this at face value, but from a list management perspective Maric is a delistable and we don't have many of those. If we did this deal it becomes doubly important to re-home Bate and/or Dunn or we'll find ourselves having to delist contracted players. It would also significantly reduce Joel Macdonald's chances of a new contract.

Would be a shame to part ways with Maric. Has obviously run/running out of chances, but he was looking pretty impressive in the NAB cup... Don't feel as though we have gotten the best out of him.

Edited October 11, 201114 yr by Juicebox

I'm trying to imagine Maric playing like Stokes or Christensen in the GF - and struggling.

Would be a shame to part ways with Maric. Has obviously run/running out of chances, but he was looking pretty impressive in the NAB cup... Don't feel as though we have gotten the best out of him.

We have gotten what he can produce. There is nothing more to see with regards to Maric he has had ample opportunity the best thing for him would be a trade.

Hopefully for his sake someone will pick him up.

Would be a shame to part ways with Maric. Has obviously run/running out of chances, but he was looking pretty impressive in the NAB cup... Don't feel as though we have gotten the best out of him.

Which is exactly the point at which you need to make the call, while he still has some currency. He is highly unlikely to become a superstar and is highly likely not part of our best 21 going forward.

We have sat on Bate for too long, would have got significantly more if we had acted sooner.

Edited October 11, 201114 yr by mordja