my 3 word player analysis V The party boys

[joeboy 3,010]

Green - an improved game

Warnock - effective, occasionally cringeworthy

Jones - overestimating actual ability

Bartram - game to forget

Watts - our best player

Gysberts - prolific and effective

Bate - had no effect

Frawley - aggressive but beaten

Sylvia - trying to inspire

McKenzie - will be better

Petterd - no second effort

Maric - not enough tricks

Moloney - was well held

Jurrah - rarely appeared interested

Rivers - was rarely sighted

MacDonald - tough but limited

Martin - gave his all

Tapscott - was injured early

Davey - couldn't elude tagger

Jetta - little to enthuse

Newton - sublime and ridiculous

Evans - took game on

Edited May 21, 2011 by joeboy

[PeterJames 46]

Davey didn't elude tagger because it was to hard. He is soft down hill skier. His effort in the second quarter where he shirked it was disgusting. 3 times he handballed in front of himself resulting in turnovers. He is a soft disgrace get him out!

[Jaded No More 60,146]

Watts, Gysberts and my boy JMac are the only things keeping me from complete meltdown.

[Guest 36DD]

Harsh on Jetta, was the only one out of the indigenous boys who had a crack today.

[gOLLy 401]

Davey....What a squibb

[DaveyJones'sLocker 637]

Bartram did ok I thought after first qrt

[Guest 36DD]

Watts, Gysberts and my boy JMac are the only things keeping me from complete meltdown.

Yep mate, shining lights, all are rippers, Gysberts + 10kg = Champion.

[deeflog 679]

Harsh on Jetta i think, really has a go, more than we can say for some of his indeginous brothers

[The Chazz 4,077]

Green - an improved game

Warnock - effective, occasionally cringeworthy

Jones - overestimating actual ability

Bartram - game to forget

Watts - our best player

Gysberts - prolific and effective

Bate - had no effect

Frawley - aggressive but beaten

Sylvia - trying to inspire

McKenzie - will be better

Petterd - no second effort

Maric - not enough tricks

Moloney - was well held

Jurrah - rarely appeared interested

Rivers - was rarely sighted

MacDonald - tough but limited

Martin - gave his all

Tapscott - was injured early

Davey - couldn't elude tagger

Jetta - little to enthuse

Newton - sublime and ridiculous

Evans - took game on

You pick on a couple of times when Jones got caught trying to create. How about these 3 words for Jones, words that you couldn't give to too many others;

Shows Great Leadership

Has a go

Hold head up

Good 100th game

But yet, you choose to criticise him

[PeterJames 46]

I think with Jones it comes down to caching. He is top 3 in the B&F but Bailey really has little idea whats going on.

[Footynut 302]

Green - an improved game

Warnock - effective, occasionally cringeworthy

Jones - overestimating actual ability

Bartram - game to forget

Watts - our best player

Gysberts - prolific and effective

Bate - had no effect

Frawley - aggressive but beaten

Sylvia - trying to inspire

McKenzie - will be better

Petterd - no second effort

Maric - not enough tricks

Moloney - was well held

Jurrah - rarely appeared interested

Rivers - was rarely sighted

MacDonald - tough but limited

Martin - gave his all

Tapscott - was injured early

Davey - couldn't elude tagger

Jetta - little to enthuse

Newton - sublime and ridiculous

Evans - took game on

Green - better captains game

Warnock - a real trier

Jones - ran all day

Bartram - love his heart

Watts - another big step

Gysberts - im in love

Bate - good VFL player

Frawley - still off pace

Sylvia - more to give

McKenzie - great he's back

Petterd - very limited impact

Maric - shows some glimpses

Moloney - impact curbed again

Jurrah - easy outside game

Rivers - nothing too special

MacDonald - please read Warnock

Martin - continues his development

Tapscott - another one injured

Davey - G W S

Jetta - not quite there

Newton - how many chances?

Evans - excellent first up

[Adzman 2,086]

I thought Jetta was solid all game. Really made a contest and used the ball well. One of his best games.

Green - better not great

Warnock - did his job

Jones - created, worked hard

Bartram - tried, but beaten

Watts - Nik Nat who?

Gysberts - becoming very important

Bate - a vfl player

Frawley - beaten but solid

Sylvia - the junkyard dog!

McKenzie - okay in return

Petterd - invisible at times

Maric - good, still learning

Moloney - never gives up

Jurrah - dreamtime to forget

Rivers - better than Macdonald

MacDonald - okay, but errors....

Martin - gave his all

Tapscott - will be missed

Davey - soft as silk

Jetta - best game yet

Newton - little to like

Evans - impressive on debut

[Demon16 69]

Davey didn't elude tagger because it was to hard. He is soft down hill skier. His effort in the second quarter where he shirked it was disgusting. 3 times he handballed in front of himself resulting in turnovers. He is a soft disgrace get him out!

combine this with Bate's uncanny ability to hit an opposition target with every possession he gets, and we have 2 senior players who shouldn't be part of our current development.

[praha 10,575]

Warnock went from superb one minute, to terrible the next.

Defines this club.

[stuie 7,374]

Green - still not leading

Warnock - old school defender*

Jones - hardworker, has heart

Bartram - old school defender*

Watts - skilled, learning well

Gysberts - vision, needs support

Bate - plays too short

Frawley - faded, lacking fitness

Sylvia - liked his aggression

McKenzie - solidish start back

Petterd - didn't work hard

Maric - disposal needs work

Moloney - needs jamar back

Jurrah - disappeared when needed

Rivers - solid when needed

MacDonald - old school defender*

Martin - battled hard today

Tapscott - fingers crossed here

Davey - VERY disappointing, soft

Jetta - meh whatever huh

Newton - please get kidnapped

Evans - better when instinctual

Bailey - definitely in trouble

*= while these guys might have been ok as stoppers today, they are struggling a bit with the modern game where they are the starting point of attack

[stuie 7,374]

I thought Jetta was solid all game. Really made a contest and used the ball well. One of his best games.

Jetta - best game yet

WTF?! Jetta was solid all game... LOL jks I got drunk at Etihad

[jackaub 1,402]

combine this with Bate's uncanny ability to hit an opposition target with every possession he gets, and we have 2 senior players who shouldn't be part of our current development.

Davey weak as [censored]!

I hope we AREN"T paying this guy $500000 per year

Drop him and we will improve He is starting to Look like Jeff (show me the money )White

This game was winnable Davey cost us 3 goals on his own 2 goals last week

If Melbourne continue to kick across goal to lose the ball they deserve to lose every game

Dean Bailey is the worst game coach i have see in 35 years of watching footbalI

If i was Moloney or Evens i would have a quiet word in the rooms to Davey

" Hey Cuz "HAVE A BLOODY GO YOU WEAK [censored]"

IF HE ISNT DROPPED NEXT WEEK AND FINED FOR NON PERFORMANCE THEN BAILEY SHOULD BE SACKED!!!

Evans first game what a great debut Somebody should tell him that at Melbourne you dont have to try so hard

This Cub is soft its been soft for a long time they burnn good palyers with the culture

THEY ARE NOT SERIOUS

DEAN BAILEY HANG YOU HEAD IN SHAME

[Roost It 1,434]

Apparently the players lined up Morton at training and all ran through him. Davey's turn this week. When he failed to take a step back costing us a goal in the second quarter I almost cried.

[RalphiusMaximus 6,002]

WTF?! Jetta was solid all game... LOL jks I got drunk at Etihad

Jetta: 23 disposals, 8 marks, 6 tackles. Yeah, that's a shocking game.

Also, for the Jones baggers, he had 31 disposals and 8 marks. He was caught with the ball a couple of times, but apart from that was bloody good all day.

[stuie 7,374]

Jetta: 23 disposals, 8 marks, 6 tackles. Yeah, that's a shocking game.

Also, for the Jones baggers, he had 31 disposals and 8 marks. He was caught with the ball a couple of times, but apart from that was bloody good all day.

Not saying Jetta was terrible, but he wasn't good, unfortunately stats don't win games, there was 817 disposal in today's game so really how much do you think that stat is worth?

He just didn't add much, like a lot of players today.

[RalphiusMaximus 6,002]

Not saying Jetta was terrible, but he wasn't good, unfortunately stats don't win games, there was 817 disposal in today's game so really how much do you think that stat is worth?

He just didn't add much, like a lot of players today.

And I'm not saying he was a game-breaker like Chris Judd, but he was serviceable and certainly far from our worst. Why the attack on him in particular? Who would you have had in the side in his place?

[Deetective Sgt. Taggert 380]

Apparently the players lined up Morton at training and all ran through him

For real? Where did you hear this?

[RalphiusMaximus 6,002]

Apparently the players lined up Morton at training and all ran through him. Davey's turn this week. When he failed to take a step back costing us a goal in the second quarter I almost cried.

For real? Where did you hear this?

I like the sound of this if it's true. One of the hardest things to really learn to the point where you don't even flinch is that it doesn't really hurt that much. Your instincts scream out at you to protect yourself, and to retrain that part of your brain to accept that you are going to cop a hit and that you will still be able to function perfectly well takes work. This sounds like a very good step in that direction.

[Geddy Lee 582]

Joeboy, think you (and some others) need to watch the replay re: Rivers. Was good today amongst a sea of [censored].

[Arrow 1,257]

WTF?! Jetta was solid all game... LOL jks I got drunk at Etihad

Think you were drunker than you realised.