Scully Out for Another ... now ... back to Six Weeks

[nutbean 8,838]

GWS are strong on Martin, with his ethnicity, tough way about him and his tatts. The thinking is the locals would really relate to him. They've dangfled the carrott. If the Tiges were likely to lose Martin with AFL sanction, they would love to pickup Scully (a dyed in wool Tiges supporter) from the roundabout. GWS were into Viney in a big way and were looking at ways to get him, or ontrade him for another Deal with the Crows at one stage.

If that did happen, (Martin > Scully) then what would be the Dees payout?

Martin is contracted until the end of 2013 - happened late last year - takes him out the GWS window of opportunity. GWS can dangle anything they like - can only happen with Richmonds blessing - so the question remains - do you think that Richmond would trade out Martin for Scully ? I don't.

I also put on the record that it really mean squat who you barrack for growing up as a kid - The Ox was in the Hawthorn cheersquad and Judd was mad about the Demons. Means little

[Jaded No More 68,922]

Sorry. Just really felt the need to contribute to this thread.

[daisycutter 29,616]

I did see him outside of one of the membership tents on my way in. Could quite possibly just have been in the Presidents club function or in the coaches box learning different elements due to his injury...

or maybe he just went for a pizz when you looked?

[Felix 92]

http://www.melbournefc.com.au/news/newsarticle/tabid/7415/newsid/112063/default.aspx

by the 'tone' of the article it sounds as if Scully is.... Injured and needs further time to heal his troubled knee. OMG, who would have thought a knee injury would take so long to heal? This 'mysterious' knee injury he had surgery on pre draft is not a sign he is off to GWS.

PS if you read it backwards it tells you exactly when the world is going to end.. the Mayans were correct in their prediction.

[Curry & Beer 5,444]

http://www.melbournefc.com.au/news/newsarticle/tabid/7415/newsid/112063/default.aspx

by the 'tone' of the article it sounds as if Scully is.... Injured and needs further time to heal his troubled knee. OMG, who would have thought a knee injury would take so long to heal? This 'mysterious' knee injury he had surgery on pre draft is not a sign he is off to GWS.

PS if you read it backwards it tells you exactly when the world is going to end.. the Mayans were correct in their prediction.

I heard yourself and nutbean are in the middle of drafting a script for a sitcom on the comedy channel

another delay hey? if it wasn't for you humurous types cheering me up I'd be feeling a tad suspicious and worried

the mayans lol

[Felix 92]

anything at all, like sitting in the stands with his teammates watching us play, for example. That would be a nice indication that he is interested in being part of the club. I saw Jordie at the ground the other day, didn't see Tom there

yeah and because Scully is not siting where you can se him, it assures him of his departure of from the MFC.. wow, you should follow our comedy show with a conspiracy program...

I think channel 10 should pick up our shows for this coming winter.

[Curry & Beer 5,444]

yeah and because Scully is not siting where you can se him, it assures him of his departure of from the MFC.. wow, you should follow our comedy show with a conspiracy program...

I think channel 10 should pick up our shows for this coming winter.

and as yet nobody has been able to claim they have sighted him in the stands this season

[Felix 92]

and as yet nobody has been able to claim they have sighted him in the stands this season

so you have had confirmation from EVERY crowd member from each game? if your answer is no then your argument is no longer valid. Why dont you send the club an email asking whether he was in the crowd and if not where was he... oh yeah and where was the rest of the side not playing on the day or with Casey?? was robbie campbell there, troy davis maybe.. wait a minute, there all going to GWS based on your conspiracy theory.

[Curry & Beer 5,444]

so you have had confirmation from EVERY crowd member from each game? if your answer is no then your argument is no longer valid. Why dont you send the club an email asking whether he was in the crowd and if not where was he... oh yeah and where was the rest of the side not playing on the day or with Casey?? was robbie campbell there, troy davis maybe.. wait a minute, there all going to GWS based on your conspiracy theory.

sorry is Robbie Campbell potentially the player of the next generation, holding out on contract negotiations with the club? NO HE'S NOT, SO WHY SAY THAT? Why do people 'argue' like this around here? It makes zero sense. Who the hell cares about Robbie Campbell, we are tlaking about Tom Scully. Very annoying.

equally as dense is suggesting I have to speak to every crowd member in order to make a comment. Seriously, think that statement through. I would have thought a poster would have said by now that they saw at whatever game sitting with the group, but apparently not.

my point remains that the kid seems absent from the club right now and nobody has said shizen to convince me otherwise. all we have is another memo from the club buying some more time with a picture of him the last (and perhaps final) time he wore red and blue

[e25 5]

Because, what type of player Scully is likely to become has zero relevance when considering your inability to spot him in the crowd at an MFC match, nor in turn does that have any bearing on his likelihood to leave for GWS.

How do you not understand this??!?

Edited April 20, 2011 by The 3rd Winkelvoss Twin

[Felix 92]

sorry is Robbie Campbell potentially the player of the next generation, holding out on contract negotiations with the club? NO HE'S NOT, SO WHY SAY THAT? Why do people 'argue' like this around here? It makes zero sense. Who the hell cares about Robbie Campbell, we are tlaking about Tom Scully. Very annoying.

equally as dense is suggesting I have to speak to every crowd member in order to make a comment. Seriously, think that statement through. I would have thought a poster would have said by now that they saw at whatever game sitting with the group, but apparently not.

my point remains that the kid seems absent from the club right now and nobody has said shizen to convince me otherwise. all we have is another memo from the club buying some more time with a picture of him the last (and perhaps final) time he wore red and blue

it is as i quote "equally as dense is in suggesting" Scully is "absent from the club right now". Just because you or other fools do not see Scully around, it does not mean he is not around.

And your reliance on 'posters' to post fact over their usual "I have it from a reliable contact in the mix" it a void comment to make, you are clutching at anything at the moment. For example, Scully has signed with GWS, only for Scully to come out and make a statement saying he is yet to sign nor has he been approached (not to say his manager has probably been approached), or a poster posting that Scully is off to GWS when it was in Scullys tone (but maybe it wasnt Scully because he is never at the club).

99.9% of posters comments are chinese whispers.

Not a single person on here can definitely say he is going to be here in 2011 or at GWS.

[Curry & Beer 5,444]

Because, what type of player Scully is likely to become has zero relevance when considering your inability to spot him in the crowd at an MFC match, nor in turn does that have any bearing on his likelihood to leave for GWS.

How do you not understand this??!?

highly sought after talent +

contract negotiations stalled +

various media types making claims about him +

highly unusual injury keeping him out +

apparent/possible absense from club activity

do you really think there is nothing going on? what's the sand look like down there?

PS Does anyone have a clue what this business trip is all about, seems a bit odd to me

[Felix 92]

highly sought after talent +

contract negotiations stalled +

various media types making claims about him +

highly unusual injury keeping him out +

apparent/possible absense from club activity

do you really think there is nothing going on? what's the sand look like down there?

PS Does anyone have a clue what this business trip is all about, seems a bit odd to me

are you for real?

business trip with they boys are to get a cut of the 3m payout... i have it from someone inside the club.

[Curry & Beer 5,444]

are you for real?

business trip with they boys are to get a cut of the 3m payout... i have it from someone inside the club.

what 3m

[Felix 92]

what 3m

[wmth 69]

Apparently touring fox sports and channel 10.

Chips's twitter: Just in sydney for a few days to tour fox sports and channel 10 etc! Rooming with the big @JackWatts4 it's been a busy day!!

Chilax peoples...photos for further proof on Cale Morton's twitter.

[hardtack 10,537]

Apparently touring fox sports and channel 10.

Chips's twitter: Just in sydney for a few days to tour fox sports and channel 10 etc! Rooming with the big @JackWatts4 it's been a busy day!!

Chilax peoples...photos for further proof on Cale Morton's twitter.

Here's a link to the pics from Schwabbie's tweet: Virtual Valium for C&B

[loges 6,767]

highly sought after talent +

contract negotiations stalled +

various media types making claims about him +

highly unusual injury keeping him out +

apparent/possible absense from club activity

do you really think there is nothing going on? what's the sand look like down there?

PS Does anyone have a clue what this business trip is all about, seems a bit odd to me

Scully's interview he said neither himself, his management or his parents had been approached by GWS. He also said that if he was approached he would immediately forward the information onto the MFC. So he is either telling the truth or he is going to set himself up to be regarded as a blatant liar!

[Sir Why You Little 37,046]

Here's a link to the pics from Schwabbie's tweet: Virtual Valium for C&B

The boys look very sharp in there suits i think!!! Relax a little C & B.

[Felix 92]

So Curry & Beer what is your response to the Sydney trip now???

http://plixi.com/p/94068157

If you look at the pic closely you can see that Scully is not smiling and he is not close to his teammates, body language would dictate that he his leaving to GWS...

Edited April 20, 2011 by Sturmmann

[dee-luded 2,959]

Martin is contracted until the end of 2013 - happened late last year - takes him out the GWS window of opportunity. GWS can dangle anything they like - can only happen with Richmonds blessing - so the question remains - do you think that Richmond would trade out Martin for Scully ? I don't.

I also put on the record that it really mean squat who you barrack for growing up as a kid - The Ox was in the Hawthorn cheersquad and Judd was mad about the Demons. Means little

Yes, I noticed that last night, when i googled his info. He signed a contract after GWS were chasing hard.

That still doesn't quash the speculation that Scully hasn't seemed happy being drafted by Melbourne, not in the first pictures after the draft, the rumours that e,d swares by, and the fact that he's not playing still and looks OK at training The fact that Martin is now off market doesn't diminish the talk about Tom. And I'd say nothing will other than a signature on a MFC contract.

I know one thing, is that if Tom leaves, there will be compensation to us. And the other thing I know is this obsessive young man, Is an out and out Tiger at heart.

[Curry & Beer 5,444]

Scully's interview he said neither himself, his management or his parents had been approached by GWS. He also said that if he was approached he would immediately forward the information onto the MFC. So he is either telling the truth or he is going to set himself up to be regarded as a blatant liar!

that's not true

if later he signs with GWS he can always say that AT THE TIME HE WAS ASKED he hadn't YET been approached

Mike Sheahan certainly seemed to think he was full of S at that presser

[loges 6,767]

that's not true

if later he signs with GWS he can always say that AT THE TIME HE WAS ASKED he hadn't YET been approached

Mike Sheahan certainly seemed to think he was full of S at that presser

He can say that but people's perception will be different. Also he will have to notify the club at some stage of an "approach". And regarding his injury, easily confirmed by club doctors I would imagine

[Age 485]

I like to try and see positives (sometimes)

Should this injury make GWS not want Scully, then all good, he stays with us.

If Scully ends up injured for most of the season and then signs with GWS, at least we haven't had to watch him develop into a star during the year, making watching him leave hurt even more.

I know its not much to hang my hat on, but at least its something!

[Curry & Beer 5,444]

The boys look very sharp in there suits i think!!! Relax a little C & B.

this is a good thing. However, I still don't get what exactly the point is of their trip, why are they taking our best prospects on a tour to see how the media works? Part of our non-finacial/networking/future prospects/mentoring idea to try and keep players who are offered more elsewhere?