Luke Tapscott

[H_T 3,047]

Luke Ball went to Xavier and always puts his head over the ball. But I know where Jmac is coming from. They have different junior programs that don't always expose them to the right coaching.

Are you saying they may have inconsistent programs that may or may not expose them to the right coaching ? (ie. the quality of coaching available may vary year to year) Or are you referring to the quality coaching on offer from school to school ?

[jnrmac 20,065]

Judd and Goddard both went to Caulfield Grammar and they go alright.

Yeah,but Caulfield is not a 'real private school' to quote the Coodabeens

[Guest Yeats_08]

Judd- CGS

Ball - Xavs

Hannebury - Xavs

Jobe Watson - Xavs

Ted Richards - Xavs

Josh Gibson - Trinity

Andrew Leoncelli - Xavs

Goddard - CGS

Beaumont (Hawthorn/carlton) - Melbourne Grammar

Ryan O'Keefe - st kevs

No problem with the intensity of those blokes

Edit: Worth noting that Anthony McDonald is coaching Xavs 1's this year.

Edited August 18, 2010 by Yeats_08

[pitchfork 181]

Tom Hawkins - Melbourne Grammar

no correlation b/w school and effort, don't think the APS really breeds any particular footy type (except thrashing carey)...these days all U-18 draft hopefuls play TAC Cup anyway.

[agent_orange 0]

Tom Hawkins - Melbourne Grammar

no correlation b/w school and effort, don't think the APS really breeds any particular footy type (except thrashing carey)...these days all U-18 draft hopefuls play TAC Cup anyway.

Brad Green - Launceston Grammar

Now that blows the theory right out the water.

[WonnaJurah 5]

Aaron Davey-Dripstone High School

[Dee*ceiving 1,674]

Never seen such much drivel on Demonland. "Softness" what a load of old cobblers.

From where I sit no one who gets to be No.1 draft pick is soft.

For that matter I doubt there is anyone who plays AFl that is soft.

Some players are in and under types and others use their skill and finese.

Go to a AFL / VFL game and stand on the fence, see, hear, and feel the physical nature of the game close up.

Then tell me Watts or any one else is "SOFT".

I do not believe it.

Watts might be many things but SOFT! NO

What about Josh Fraser?

[mdemonski2 403]

I agree where Watts is concerned being a Brighton Grammar boy. The school is known for it's softness. Playing them in Amo's it's well known they are soft. But I think he should be judged after 3 or 4 preseasons with more bulk. It is taking time for him to adjust which is why i think he should be playing at Casey. He has the right tools to become a good player, he just needs to cope with pressure better which comes with experience.

Not sure about strauss. Has had injuries but may miss out on a spot in Casey's finals team (if its still the 12-10 rule! but again another preseason and we will know more!

Um fail...they are in A grade amateurs. Hardly 'soft' footy. do I detect a hint of jealousy or did one of their players beat you up or something?

[Dee Fan 3,247]

Yeah,but Caulfield is not a 'real private school' to quote the Coodabeens

Easy there my boys went to CGS, so did Maxwell and the Kellaways.

And my Grandson goes to Brighton so hold the soft talk until I see how he turns out.

[Fork 'em 6,983]

All silver spoon fed private schools boys are soft IMO.

[Brayshaw Self 847]

All silver spoon fed private schools boys are soft IMO.

Yeh, nice contribution there mate.

[PeterJames 46]

Um fail...they are in A grade amateurs. Hardly 'soft' footy. do I detect a hint of jealousy or did one of their players beat you up or something?

They will be B grade next year! When we play them and have beaten them the last 4 or 5 times we always know they don't like hard tough footy, maybe thats why we are in the top 2!

[Felix 92]

regardless of where the boy's studied. They will not be as physical as a seasoned AFL player, how many of the 75 odd draftee's that come into the game each season and show up a Moloney or Pavlich week in week out?

Give these boys a few seasons before you start calling them soft.

[Demonland 72,193]

Back on topic, Luke is back in the Casey team this week - Werribee Tigers v Casey Scorpions

[Felix 92]

Back on topic, Luke is back in the Casey team this week - Werribee Tigers v Casey Scorpions

in the back line, i thought he was more of a forward. meh, good to see him on the park regardless.

[Ned 156]

Jack Viney also goes to the same school that Tapscott & Trengove went to.

As did the Chappell brothers.

[Dappa Dan 2,188]

I saw Dean Bailey at a function recently and asked him to pass on my apologies to same ruckman!!!

I reckon if I meet TMR, 2 things will happen. The first is ring the nearest hospital to give them my details for when I wake up there in a few hours... the second is go up to him and apologise for writing him off a few years ago.

INteresting that two of our 'private school' recruits lack intensity - Strauss and Watts. Its a pet theory of mine.... Particularly when compared to a Dustin Martin type who plays as if his life depends on it (It probably does)

Interesting. But ultimately just plain wrong.

All silver spoon fed private schools boys are soft IMO.

Now, now, no need to be jealous because these kids concentrated when they were at school. You know what IS soft? Hiding behind a profile on an internet forum taking generalised pot-shots.

The last resort of the under-educated = try to bring down those smart enough to go out and GET an education.

[Dappa Dan 2,188]

he is a great kick outside 50

I know it was an old post, but I thought it was worth mentioning...

I have heard that one of the reasons Tappy's kick hasn't come back to look like it did in that video was some residual confidence issues related to his hip surgery. No reason to think it's permanent, but from what I hear he's had to adapt a bit.

This got me to thinking. We will either have the next Chappy on our hands, like all the glass half full people think. Or we might have another Moloney on our hands. Now Moloney's a very good player, but his looong looooooong kick hasn't often been used to the effect it should. Hopefully Tappy can find that prediction and vision that Davey has (or part of it).... if he does, he'd be the best kick in HISTORY!

:D

[Fork 'em 6,983]

Dappa Dan eh ,... Bet I know where your spoon is .

[Gorgoroth 12,954]

Dappa I hope it's Chappy like, I love Chappy, I watch Cats games to watch Chappy more than any other player outside the Dee's, I love the way he goes about it.

Would be a starting mid in nearly any other team.

[old dee 23,791]

What about Josh Fraser?

He is not soft just not in the top 10 ruckman in the league.

The only reason he is not playing is because they now have Jolly who is better by a fair margin.

[Dappa Dan 2,188]

Dappa Dan eh ,... Bet I know where your spoon is .

Yes. I went to a private school. Is that supposed to hurt my feelings?

Dappa I hope it's Chappy like, I love Chappy, I watch Cats games to watch Chappy more than any other player outside the Dee's, I love the way he goes about it.

Would be a starting mid in nearly any other team.

I reckon he'd be just about the best player in the league. If not, then very, very close to it.

I really hope, against hope, that Tappy gets a Grimes-like round 22 start. Blease too, though I'm not sure he has the confidence in his leg yet. Mostly I want to see Tappy get out there and show what kind of player he is. He seems to love the hard stuff, and I reckon he'd like to be in a side with Trengove, even if it is a dead rubber. Probably won't happen... But whatever.

[mdemonski2 403]

They will be B grade next year! When we play them and have beaten them the last 4 or 5 times we always know they don't like hard tough footy, maybe thats why we are in the top 2!

Ah so one of them didn't beat you up, he stole your girl mate? good for you champ but I still detect a personal chip on the shoulder I reckon. I bet you are the most non soft water boy ever to be involved in a grade a amateurs then.

[jnrmac 20,065]

I reckon if I meet TMR, 2 things will happen. The first is ring the nearest hospital to give them my details for when I wake up there in a few hours... the second is go up to him and apologise for writing him off a few years ago.

Interesting. But ultimately just plain wrong.

Now, now, no need to be jealous because these kids concentrated when they were at school. You know what IS soft? Hiding behind a profile on an internet forum taking generalised pot-shots.

The last resort of the under-educated = try to bring down those smart enough to go out and GET an education.

I reckon that the APS footy comp is nowhere near as physical as some of the suburban leagues. That might mean some of the APS boys take a little while longer to adujst to the physicality of AFL. Its only food for thought....

[Grandson of a gun 276]

Wow, this thread is entertaining reading. Love the old debate about private v public schools.

FWIW, i went to a private school and a state school, playing 1sts footy at both and also went through the TAC cup program. (And i was clearly not good enough at the highest junior level... )

I have played with many tough guys who are private school boys, and equally many who were not. The school they went to had absolutely no bearing on their appetite for the contest. Sorry to disappoint lads but the school debate is a dead one.