James McDonald

[DeeSpencer 25,671]

It's not for Junior to 'hand over' or the club to dictate.

The playing group votes on the captaincy (and leadership group). None of the coach, FD, Board, or anyone else has any say. It's not part of anybody's contract or something that is promised to any player by the club.

If that is the case I feel that Moloney will win a vote above Green.

[Guest watts04]

people shouldnt write junior off on one game or a few games

has made a brilliant career out of proving people wrong

will be cptain in 2011, we dont have great leadership at our club yet

[DaveyJones'sLocker 647]

"Deserves one more year"

These are the kind of acts that hav got us in trouble in the past.

Junior was pathetic last night, I know he's been out for 7 weeks and he's a champ but for player development sake he must not play next year!

[Hellaintabadplacetobe 4,294]

I find it ridiculous that people are asking for a blokes head after his first game of football from an 8 week injury. Talk about short memories. Do some reading through some threads from earlier in the year and some were believing he was in close to career best form.

Give the bloke a few weeks to get back on the horse FFS.

[Hiram Cowfreak 78]

The problem is we need to move on 4 players at the end of the season (3 draft picks + Jordie goes on the list).

Normally it would be great to have an experienced player like Junior around for another season, but I can only think of Miller and Bell as certain delistings. I'm sure it would be on Juniors mind that we have a dilemma coming up seasons end.

[Chook 15,012]

The problem is we need to move on 4 players at the end of the season (3 draft picks + Jordie goes on the list).

Normally it would be great to have an experienced player like Junior around for another season, but I can only think of Miller and Bell as certain delistings. I'm sure it would be on Juniors mind that we have a dilemma coming up seasons end.

Assuming we will delist four players, I would think that Miller, Bell, Newton and one other would go. I can't imagine that Paul Johnson would be shafted just yet, and if the rumours of Cameron Bruce going to the Suns is BS, then McDonald might be that last player. I doubt he'd go around again if he didn't think he'd make it. But we have seen Brett Kirk play for one year too many, so I guess it's possible that Junior may, too. Let's just see how he goes next week.

[stuie 7,374]

I find it ridiculous that people are asking for a blokes head after his first game of football from an 8 week injury. Talk about short memories. Do some reading through some threads from earlier in the year and some were believing he was in close to career best form.

Give the bloke a few weeks to get back on the horse FFS.

I think it's more the fact that he's starting to deteriorate half way through the season. Has happened a couple of years in a row now, you said it yourself, an 8 week injury, an one that would have been 3 weeks for a younger body.

Love the bloke as a Captain, you can never fault his endeavour or his willingness to put the club before himself, and sure he might have had good early season form, but the fact is his body is just not able to cope as well anymore and he would struggle badly next year.

In short, form is not the question, nor is heart, and I would love to be wrong, but Junior's body is struggling.

[jnrmac 20,058]

.

[agent_orange 0]

Don't think the question will be if James wants to play another year but rather if his body wants to play another year.

He has missed seven weeks - wasn't ready to return to senior footy this week.

[Grandson of a gun 276]

He and Bruce will both be given the option to play on depending on their bodies.

Junior was playing great footy prior to his injury which may see him go round once more (with a full pre-season under his belt).

[Inner Demon 1]

Assuming we will delist four players, I would think that Miller, Bell, Newton and one other would go. I can't imagine that Paul Johnson would be shafted just yet, and if the rumours of Cameron Bruce going to the Suns is BS, then McDonald might be that last player. I doubt he'd go around again if he didn't think he'd make it. But we have seen Brett Kirk play for one year too many, so I guess it's possible that Junior may, too. Let's just see how he goes next week.

Newton doesn't count as a delisting.

We need to delist 4-5 from the senior list. Rookie listed players are irrelevant.

[John Dee 445]

The problem is we need to move on 4 players at the end of the season (3 draft picks + Jordie goes on the list).

No, it is still only the mandatory three. Rookie upgrades now count as a pick. Having said that, I believe that we will move on at least four, not counting rookies.

[Hiram Cowfreak 78]

I guess the option is to delist Bell and Miller and upgrade our 3 compulsory draft picks by trading Warnock and Bate.

I can't see any other options, guys like Stef Martin have more development potential than either the above.

I think Junior will go around again and why shouldn't he?

[speed demon 804]

While McDonald and Bruce may both be capable of playing another season, and doing so at a high level, it's unlikely they'll be able to do so for another three seasons. So playing another year means keeping two developing players out of the team who will be there in three years when we're competing for the premiership.

In past years, the MFC has respectfully coordinated the early retirement of numerous Club greats e.g. Robertson, Whelan, White, Yze (granted perhaps none are the ilk of Junior and Bruce at their best), and the team has been better for it. With senior players like Green, Moloney, Sylvia and Jamar all stepping up this season the experience and leadership that McDonald and Bruce offer is now being covered by others. IMO time for another hard decision this year.

[old dee 23,787]

I guess the option is to delist Bell and Miller and upgrade our 3 compulsory draft picks by trading Warnock and Bate.

I can't see any other options, guys like Stef Martin have more development potential than either the above.

I think Junior will go around again and why shouldn't he?

Ravi I cannot believe you would trade Warnock!

one injury in the backline and then who do you go to?

He is cast in concrete for me

Before you jetison Bate and Warnock have you thought of delisting

Mcnamara, Martin, Cheney, Jetta or Maric.

none of the above can hold a candle to Warnock and Bate.

Edited August 2, 2010 by old dee

[Hiram Cowfreak 78]

Ravi I cannot believe you would trade Warnock!

one injury in the backline and then who do you go to?

He is cast in concrete for me

Before you jetison Bate and Warnock have you thought of delisting

Mcnamara, Martin, Cheney, Jetta or Maric.

none of the above can hold a candle to Warnock and Bate.

I know, old dee it hurts, but from what I can gather all the names you listed except for Mcnamara are contracted for 2011.

The reasons I nominated Warnock and Bater are;

Warnock is not in our best 22 and we have Martin and T.Mac as a back up

Bater has only got a left side and therefore is very predictable....and he is not in our best 22 at present either.

I would rather keep them both but the numbers just don't stack up

[Chook 15,012]

Newton doesn't count as a delisting.

We need to delist 4-5 from the senior list. Rookie listed players are irrelevant.

Oh, right. Good point.

[Hannabal 4]

Junior isnt holding back Trengove at all. Every game Junior has played so has JT. They also play different roles. On this years form Junior is good enough to claim a year. If he does there should no reason why he is not captain again.

He did last weekend. If it wasn't for McDonald being the captain Trengove would have (and should have) played.

I'd make this McDonald's last year. He's had a great year, but at 34 he shouldn't go on. Next year it's just going to get harder and harder to get games into Tapscott, Blease and Gysberts with McDonald demanding a game. The game can go past you pretty quickly and I don't want McDonald getting games at the expense of players that will be part of our next premiership. And I don't think that he'll be sorely missed.

[Deestroy All 14,262]

He did last weekend. If it wasn't for McDonald being the captain Trengove would have (and should have) played.

I'd make this McDonald's last year. He's had a great year, but at 34 he shouldn't go on. Next year it's just going to get harder and harder to get games into Tapscott, Blease and Gysberts with McDonald demanding a game. The game can go past you pretty quickly and I don't want McDonald getting games at the expense of players that will be part of our next premiership. And I don't think that he'll be sorely missed.

Could not agree more.

There are now some of the sharpest hands I've ever seen at the club, kids that just instinctively clear the ball into the best position. Jordie, Scully, Trengove Watts and Gysberts (I hear Tapscott does well too) are superb, whether it's been a glimpse, like Jizz, or game after game, Jordie.

The old firm don't compare.

Junior should step aside. He's had a great career.

[H_T 3,043]

He did last weekend. If it wasn't for McDonald being the captain Trengove would have (and should have) played.

I'd make this McDonald's last year. He's had a great year, but at 34 he shouldn't go on. Next year it's just going to get harder and harder to get games into Tapscott, Blease and Gysberts with McDonald demanding a game. The game can go past you pretty quickly and I don't want McDonald getting games at the expense of players that will be part of our next premiership. And I don't think that he'll be sorely missed.

Inclined to agree somewhat. The more I watch the likes of McKenzie, Bail and their improvement, the more I think he will not be sorely missed. I am all for getting games into those players mentioned. With another pre-season under their wings they'll be demanding games.

Early to mid year I was open to Junior going around again in 2011 based on his form. Outstanding form at that for a 33-34yo. Arguably AA squad form. However the recent injury to Junior is a timely reminder, that things can deteriorate rapidly at this level that is demanding.

[1858 285]

I have full confidence that JMac and the club will make the right decision for the club. Whilst I tend to think that keeping him on our list at 34 is probably not the way to go, I'll be happy with the club's decision either way and accept it as the right decision.

All I'll say about JMac personally is that leading up to his hammy he was definitely starting to slow up a bit. He had a 6 week break and his body had a chance to rejuvenate as did the mind and recently he has indicated that he'd like to go another year. Human nature is a funny thing, had he not had the hammy and continued to battle away I wonder if his mindset may have been a little different. They say a week is a long time in footy, so 6 weeks is an eon - defintiely needs to reasses at the end of the season IMO. Like I said, I'll accept what the club goes with though.

[Old Gregg 1]

Why are people suggesting to trade Bate???? He's in a form slump, sure...but he is still in our best 22. Probably one of the more recognised "young guns" of Melbourne for the footy media - no way is he trade bait.

[Hiram Cowfreak 78]

Why are people suggesting to trade Bate???? He's in a form slump, sure...but he is still in our best 22. Probably one of the more recognised "young guns" of Melbourne for the footy media - no way is he trade bait.

I think both Bate and Warnock have some trade value and I can't see either as key position premiership players.

If Bate wasn't so one-dimensional his name would never be raised.

Unless we have another rabbit up our sleeve, a la 2009 putting Meeson & Newton on the rookie list, 4 players min. have to go.

It was easier 6 weeks ago when Barts and PJ looked gone for all money, but with no ruck support for Jamar, and Bartram in great form, they both have to stay.

It's only my opinion but Stef Martin will be a better player than Warnock for our window, he is quick and agile. He also is contracted for 2011 and Warnock isn't.

Edited August 2, 2010 by ravi shanker

[old dee 23,787]

I know, old dee it hurts, but from what I can gather all the names you listed except for Mcnamara are contracted for 2011.

The reasons I nominated Warnock and Bater are;

Warnock is not in our best 22 and we have Martin and T.Mac as a back up

Bater has only got a left side and therefore is very predictable....and he is not in our best 22 at present either.

I would rather keep them both but the numbers just don't stack up

Well Ravi I am not going to let the truth / facts get in the way of a good story. Guess you have me there!

However simply because a player may not be in our best 22 does not mean you give them the flick,

There is rarely a time when you can put your best 22 on the park.

Your theory also assumes ever young guy on the list will be in the "best 22".

Doubt it! Some will prosper others won't.

It will be interesting to see the list come Jan 2011.

[DeeSpencer 25,671]

I think both Bate and Warnock have some trade value and I can't see either as key position premiership players.

If Bate wasn't so one-dimensional his name would never be raised.

Unless we have another rabbit up our sleeve, a la 2009 putting Meeson & Newton on the rookie list, 4 players min. have to go.

It was easier 6 weeks ago when Barts and PJ looked gone for all money, but with no ruck support for Jamar, and Bartram in great form, they both have to stay.

It's only my opinion but Stef Martin will be a better player than Warnock for our window, he is quick and agile. He also is contracted for 2011 and Warnock isn't.

What is this one dimension crap. Aaron Davey doesn't have a right foot either but you don't want to throw him out. If we trade Bate it must be because we got a very good offer (pick 20 or higher). He's not key position but he can turn games of footy. He has deficiencies in his game which is why he's currently at Casey.

And how is Martin better than Warnock. Warnock is an extremely honest full back who has shown he can compete and not be destroyed by the best forwards in the game. At AFL level he is a role player, at VFL level he is dominant. If we are trading him we better pick a young key defender as cover. Martin seems to be without a position, soft and struggling in the VFL 2's. If he's contracted for next year then I'd be rookie-ing him like Newton and Meesen were. He is behind 4 in line and slipping for a ruck spot and not viable in any other position on the ground.