Will we still get the Priority Pick?

[Rhino Richards 1,467]

I disagree...

The Blues have a top 4 spot to play for. They'll be relieved to be playing us, and have obviously been more inconsistent... But a loss will be FAR more detrimental to their year.

The same could have been said about Port Power some weeks ago.

Carlton are more likely to win.

But its not in the bag until ...its in the bag.

We just smashed the buggery out of the biggest joke of a midfield in the league. It was a great win, but let's not kid ourselves, there will be no such luxury next week. It would take our absolute best and their absolute worst for that to happen. I'm sure there's plenty of 'experimenting' that can be done should we be in any danger of winning next week.

Fair call

[e25 5]

I'd think Carlton having had a good win would be more in danger of underestimating us and slipping up.

St. Kilda after a recent loss would not be a side I'd want to go up against - whoever they have next week will likely get pulled apart like soft bread.

[Real Demon 232]

I love the way our rotations for the previous two weeks were around 50, yet today we were up around 100.

Tells me the coach has things well and truly in hand!

[Doggo 32]

A mixture of young bodies and experimentation will get us over the line in the last two weeks, but I, like others, have some concerns about Carlton and their flaky nature. Would be a sad, ironic twist if they robboed us of a PP again.

And who knows how St Kilda might react to dropping their bundle this week? They're far and away the best team this year, but it is St Kilda Football Club, with a (deeply ingrained) losing culture, anything could happen. They might just collapse and fold, like MFC did in 2004 from R18 onwards.

Call me paranoid, but I just want this year to be over already.

Barracking with all my heart for a win today felt good. Really good. I want to be able to do that every week again, so the sooner we bury '09 and bring on 2010, the better!

[dee-luded 2,959]

Look at the post I was quoting, he was talking about losing bottom place and the first pick (along with the priority) if we draw with Carlton next week. I was saying it's more than likely that Freo can win next week.

Yep, fair enough if Freo win, (which I doubt) that would solidify the first pick for us.

But if we draw or beat carlton, we lose the priority pick.

[Longsufferingnomore 1,604]

A mixture of young bodies and experimentation will get us over the line in the last two weeks, but I, like others, have some concerns about Carlton and their flaky nature. Would be a sad, ironic twist if they robboed us of a PP again.

And who knows how St Kilda might react to dropping their bundle this week? They're far and away the best team this year, but it is St Kilda Football Club, with a (deeply ingrained) losing culture, anything could happen. They might just collapse and fold, like MFC did in 2004 from R18 onwards.

Call me paranoid, but I just want this year to be over already.

Barracking with all my heart for a win today felt good. Really good. I want to be able to do that every week again, so the sooner we bury '09 and bring on 2010, the better!

Today was good so I can put up with two more losses then bring on Scully and others and then 2010. It was good for all those young boys out there to get the feeling of a win and all that brings. Hopefully next year more supporters will at least turn up. Absolutely pathetic supporters. It was embarassing.

[dee-luded 2,959]

We just smashed the buggery out of the biggest joke of a midfield in the league. It was a great win, but let's not kid ourselves, there will be no such luxury next week. It would take our absolute best and their absolute worst for that to happen. I'm sure there's plenty of 'experimenting' that can be done should we be in any danger of winning next week.

No point even discussing St. Kilda. There's a few pretty good reasons why they're first and we're last.

To be honest, I enjoyed putting the PP out of my mind and enjoying footy properly again today. I barracked hard for a win and we belted them; this meant far more to me than the hollow win against Port, which just left me feeling sick. I could've gone a few more days before anyone mentioned the PP again.

So did I, barracked for the boys & our win today, it feels good.

But I'm not gunna celebrate the priority pick untill it's in the bag, sorry, but for me your sensativity to this is a bit soft, in the scheme of the hardship the clubs longest term supporters have endured. your few more days are very trivial indeed.

[dimmy 1,282]

But : If we beat Carlton with all their priority picks and first round offers , plus the house that Dick bought (Judd), then why would we need PP.

Just somehow it would be well worth it!!!

Added boneses :

Kruser (PP) reported for striking Jetta( No 435 Draft Pick who will finish up as effective as him)

Fevola not getting a kick and doing his usual sulk.

Judd getting Towelled by Dunn

Jurrah taking Gibb to the cleaners

Moloney cleaning Murphy up at the opening bounce.

WHy do we need PP ???

[Jumping Jack Clennett 1,748]

I'm very worried about our P.P.

With St Kilda losing today, they have very little incentive in Round 22, other than to protect themselves for the first week of the finals. Had they won today, they probably would have been playing us in round 22 to win the all-time record of 22 straight.

[Sir Why You Little 36,587]

I'm very worried about our P.P.

With St Kilda losing today, they have very little incentive in Round 22, other than to protect themselves for the first week of the finals. Had they won today, they probably would have been playing us in round 22 to win the all-time record of 22 straight.

Round 22 St.kilda are playing their first game on the MCG for the year. They will want to play well before september i believe.

Relax Jack.

[dee-luded 2,959]

Round 22 St.kilda are playing their first game on the MCG for the year. They will want to play well before september i believe.

Relax Jack.

Thats a good point WYL. It's the carlton game I'm concerned about.

I'll be glad, in a way, when this season is done & dusted.

Bring on 2010.

[rpfc 28,045]

My god, the fans of this club go up and down with what they think of this team?!

A few days ago people were saying we were a chance to lose to Freo (?!) and now we are a chance to beat Carlton at Etihad (?!).

Be more consistent and try and tie down what you think we are capable of.

[Straight Sets Simon 23,113]

...

Nice avatar.

[inactive 0]

My god, the fans of this club go up and down with what they think of this team?!

A few days ago people were saying we were a chance to lose to Freo (?!) and now we are a chance to beat Carlton at Etihad (?!).

Be more consistent and try and tie down what you think we are capable of.

Completely agree!

We beat the 15th side and all of a sudden we can beat 1 & 5.

[Mondê 525]

We will get thumped by both Carlton and StKilda. The most important thing heading into a finals campaign is form...StKilda losing today is marvelous they will be desperate to not taper off heading into September, Carlton have top 4 at stake - enough said. Scully and (Insert name of draft pick # 2 here) are ours.

[dee-luded 2,959]

My god, the fans of this club go up and down with what they think of this team?!

A few days ago people were saying we were a chance to lose to Freo (?!) and now we are a chance to beat Carlton at Etihad (?!).

Be more consistent and try and tie down what you think we are capable of.

What we are capable of depends on the players that are selected for that particular game, X the opposition team, as you would know.

We are quite capable given a bit of a sniff, if carlton lower their guard, it could be game over.

[Rogue 585]

Some people really ride the wave week-to-week.

[Rhino Richards 1,467]

Dom McLardy spoke optimistically about the future saying we would have 3 picks in the top 20 this year.

I doubt we will trouble Carlton or St Kilda but we need to continue to experiment to make sure.

[pitmaster 3,442]

Dom McLardy spoke optimistically about the future saying we would have 3 picks in the top 20 this year.

I doubt we will trouble Carlton or St Kilda but we need to continue to experiment to make sure.

I don't rate Carlton highly and as much as I'd love to beat them we aren't there yet.

We're getting ahead of ourselves if we forget how lame Freo was - truly soft.

Bottom line - as encouraging as the win was with so many of the best 22 out, we didn't beat much.

[Rhino Richards 1,467]

I don't rate Carlton highly and as much as I'd love to beat them we aren't there yet.

We're getting ahead of ourselves if we forget how lame Freo was - truly soft.

Bottom line - as encouraging as the win was with so many of the best 22 out, we didn't beat much.

The issue is not so much about us......

[pitmaster 3,442]

The issue is not so much about us......

Strewth...what are you suggesting?

That the Blues would tank to avoid fourth spot and a first week of the finals meeting with the Saints?

[beelzebub 23,195]

lol... some peple are obviously incapable of seeing beyond the nose on their face. The MFC ( for a change ) know only too well exactly whatis required to go forward. They know we need these top picks to bolster our list and set us up. Theyalso know the club, supporters and indeed players need a win to remind themsleves of whatthis is all about. And so we took a win when we could. And by that I mean ..against an oppostion we were clearly able to best ,and more importanltly really at a time we could afford to. Now the rest of the year wil play itself out. Carlton are playing to for a top 4 spot. StKilda need to restore that momentum going in to september.

People ..do you really think we are going to win another two games... even if we really really try ?? I dont think so..not this year

[Jumping Jack Clennett 1,748]

[quote name='belzebub59'

"People ..do you really think we are going to win another two games"

The worry isn't over TWO games, it's ONE that we desperately MUSTN'T win.

It's quite a factor that StKilda has absolutely NO incentive to win round 22.

I wish I was as confident as you blokes about the determination of our footy dept. to get those picks.

How well I remember round 22, 2007. What were you worldly experts saying before that match?

[Nasher 33,607]

How well I remember round 22, 2007. What were you worldly experts saying before that match?

The scenario here is wildly different though. St. Kilda may not have any incentive to win (and that's extremely debatable), but Carlton that year had a very big incentive to lose.

To be honest, I can't see them wanting to do anything other than smash us in to oblivion in round 22, which they should rightfully do.

[beelzebub 23,195]

"People ..do you really think we are going to win another two games"

The worry isn't over TWO games, it's ONE that we desperately MUSTN'T win.

It's quite a factor that StKilda has absolutely NO incentive to win round 22.

I wish I was as confident as you blokes about the determination of our footy dept. to get those picks.

How well I remember round 22, 2007. What were you worldly experts saying before that match?

youd have to be kidding...their only outing on the G befoe the finals... the last game before finals... and you think they have no incentive