My 3 word player analysis V The Quaints

[joeboy 2,867]

Bartram - disposal was childlike

Bate - more was needed

Bell - becoming a nonentity

Bruce - provided no leadership

Buckley - promising but limited

Dunn - Jane not Tarzan

Frawley - devoid of presence

Garland - continued his renaissance

Green - needs more consistency

Johnson - some exciting moments

Jones - feeling the pressure

McDonald - just a shadow

McLean - more was required

Miller - tried but limited

Moloney - persistent but erratic

Robertson - insignificant before calamity

Sylvia - just a game

Warnock - a pleasing performance

Wheatley - easily our best

White - stagnant and ineffectual

Yze - some life yet

Wonaemirri - could not escape

[ucanchoose 1,804]

Did Robbo not play? or just not get a rating?

[Demons 32 235]

Bartram - playing above weight

Bate - our best player

Bell - what a dud

Bruce - poor game Brucey

Buckley - lets persist with

Dunn - not a tagger

Frawley - dropped for Rivers

Garland - worthy of spot

Green - has be captain (over the other two!)

Johnson - pretends he's a mid

Jones - poor decision making

McDonald - has really dropped

McLean - we need more

Miller - tried but limited

Moloney - not his best

Robbo - really struggled yesterday (before injury)

Sylvia - wasn't to bad

Warnock - just a game

Wheatley - another fine performance

White - time for Meesen?

Yze - shame he's old

Wonaemirri - felt the sting (of no marking forwards)

[titan_uranus 22,731]

Bell - time to go

[Gorgoroth 12,351]

I actually thought wheatley was average.

[Guest MFC4Life]

Bell-a real worry.

[Demon Tragic 0]

Garland - Silenced his critics

[Bring-Back-Powell 13,385]

Bartram - 1/10

Bate - 4/10

Bell - 2/10

Bruce - 4/10

Buckley - 2/10

Dunn - 1/10 (1 for his goal)

Frawley - 2/10

Garland - 6/10

Green - 4/10

Johnson - 5/10

Jones - 4/10

McDonald - 6/10

McLean - 5/10

Miller - 4/10

Moloney - 5/10

Sylvia - 5/10

Warnock - 6/10

Wheatley - 6/10

White - 2/10

Yze - 5/10

Wonaemirri -2/10

[beelzebub 22,282]

finding it hard to raise any enthusdiam on this one.

To be honest as so much occurred up the foggy end I found it hard to tell who was who at times..

I'll just chime in with an overview efoort.

Some of this disturbs me..lol.

Ooze did shine amongst that lot..that alone says it all really He was one of the few to actually manage any effect 6/10

I thought Johnson played a very honest game..he didnt get a lot of help did he. 7/10

Garland tried valiantly even if (again ) little support 6/10

what did come came from Matty W..who also seems to be improving..some of his decisions are well..hmm...could be better 5/10

again this irks me . If Im mentioning him, we're not going to well. Frosty actually does seem to be attempting to change his game 5/10 for effort. Stop looking to keep it half way backwards now , is this his new trade mark in stead of handball?? Get rid of it son.. otherwise..carry on with attempted transformation.

Aussie. tried hard all day I felt.Why wasnt he brought on the ball much earlier. He was wasted yesterday. 5/10

were any others really playing.. I couldnt tell..not until Brocky came on wearing his Jammies!!

Not Baters best day.

If most of them are going to play like that..stay home.. I could have !!

[demondomination 27]

Joeboy- Roth was sensational

[stranga 328]

Dunn- never have i seen someones career destroyed so badly by being played out of position. Im sure this guy has more to offer as a forward

[Pipefitter 2,029]

I have been guilty of bagging wheatley in the past, but i was happy with him yesterday. Only one who at least tried to play on at half back.

[Jerry Lundergard 390]

I am interested in everyone's assessment of Dunn. From what i can gather, he is being given a tagging role.

With Junior nearing the end, we have no midfield taggers, as Bartram tends to tag half backs/forwards, and is not physically up to tagging bigger midfielders. Every gun side in this competetion have at least a couple of stoppers on their team, and some of them early on in their careers never got much of the pill when they where applying themselves to this role(Kirk, Sewell, Rawlings, Cornes, etc).

Dunn tagged Hayes on Sunday, and i think you could mount an argument that out of all the Saints midfiedlers, Hayes had little influence. Although in the context of a 79 point drubbing in which we were smashed in the middle, it means little.

My point is though, no matter where we all think Dunn should be played, or how he should be played, if he has been given instructions from the coach to go out and try to stop an opposing influential midfielder, then he should be judged on that shouldn't he?

[Miracle 89]

Early on I noticed one of our players give a handball but not run on to shepherd.

I thought this a bit strange so I made a point of keeping my eyes on the person giving the handball.

I was shocked to see that this happened a number of times.

This is something very basic as it gives the ball carrier an extra few metres.

Did anyone else notice this

[ucanchoose 1,804]

Early on I noticed one of our players give a handball but not run on to shepherd.

I thought this a bit strange so I made a point of keeping my eyes on the person giving the handball.

I was shocked to see that this happened a number of times.

This is something very basic as it gives the ball carrier an extra few metres.

Did anyone else notice this

Been doing to the exact same thing all year. Nothing surprising there

[joeboy 2,867]

Joeboy- Roth was sensational

You played very well too .