Caro Wilson

[Dee1987 277]

On 3AW Caro strongly believes Judd is already at Collingwood but ...

Collingwood can't fit him in under the salary cap or they would have to trade the likes of Thomas and Pendlebury, which I can't see them doing!

[sylvinator 96]

i know its hard...but i think people should just wait for Judd to announce which club he picks.

its getting abit rediculous people guestimating which club he's already supposedly chosen.

hell prob announce it in the next few days...patience!

[Hannabal 4]

On 3AW Caro strongly believes Judd is already at Collingwood but ...

Collingwood can't fit him in under the salary cap or they would have to trade the likes of Thomas and Pendlebury, which I can't see them doing!

Her whole premise is based upon "I can't see Colligwood letting him go to another club" and Dwayne's "what Eddie wants he gets". They have no basis of fact. Their arguments are tenuous at best.

Although she did say it's Collingwood with the Dees as the smokey. And later on "Melbourne are the red herring".

Also "How did Stride Management not agree to interview Dean Bailey after his phone call?" This was in reference to the Essendon coaching job.

[Yze_Magic 3]

Caroline Wilson is solid evidence that there is no place for women in football

To think she is the chief sports writer for one of the biggest papers in Australia is absolutely sickening

[QueenC 74]

Caroline Wilson is solid evidence that there is no place for women in football

Really :angry: .......

[mo64 5,262]

Caroline Wilson is solid evidence that there is no place for women in football

And YM is solid evidence that 'the pill' is one of the greatest inventions in modern times.....

[Damo 3,026]

Do you mean that the exception proves the rule?

[deesrock 0]

And YM is solid evidence that 'the pill' is one of the greatest inventions in modern times.....

That is hilarious - but best I stop ready the footy forums and get back to the kitchen.

[mikeod 21]

Doesn't really work does it...

"He'll definitely go to Collingwood, but there's a chance Melbourne will get him..."

[diesel 420]

On 3AW Caro strongly believes Judd is already at Collingwood but ...

Collingwood can't fit him in under the salary cap or they would have to trade the likes of Thomas and Pendlebury, which I can't see them doing!

Caros' comments were prefaced with "I think". In that regard she is no different to anyone here thinking (hoping) Judd will come to the Dees. Of course my thoughts are based on a desire to see Juddy in Red & Blue, not Carolines perception of the attractivness of the Lexus Ed(die)fice and McChins sales pitch.

[Yze_Magic 3]

And YM is solid evidence that 'the pill' is one of the greatest inventions in modern times.....

Thats mature

[deesrock 0]

Thats mature

Oh come on Yze Magic - it WAS funny!

[Elwood 3184 1,268]

Caroline Wilson is solid evidence that there is no place for women in football

To think she is the chief sports writer for one of the biggest papers in Australia is absolutely sickening

Caroline Wilson's mail is usually pretty much spot on and she gets things right more often than some of her fellow journos of the male persuasion.

I'd take Caro over Patrick Smith any day of the week.

[Louie 39]

Her premise was she read between the lines that Judd wants to play at the MCG and play in the 'big games'. To her that meant it could only be the filth.

[grazman 6,652]

You have to remember that journalists bring their own unique preconceptions and bias to the table when they express their opinions - just like supporters. It'd be easier for a Jim Wilson (Carlton) to accept that Judd would want to go to Collingwood rather than Melbourne, or for Caro (Richmond) the same... it'd simply be inconceivable for someone like Grybas (Collingwood) to believe anything else. If Judd chooses Melbourne... it means they all have to go away and not only have to try and rationalise it (gee there won't be a story that doesn't mention he barracked for us as a kid) and admit that maybe that their preconceptions may have been wrong.

[Jaded No More 59,151]

So basically, nobody knows anything yet... surprise surprise!

[Brock 08 0]

i know its hard...but i think people should just wait for Judd to announce which club he picks.

its getting abit rediculous people guestimating which club he's already supposedly chosen.

hell prob announce it in the next few days...patience!

thats a bit harsh, we're just trying to tell ourselves that judd is coming home. if thats ur opinion why are u reading all of the posts about judd..."paitence!!"

[Real Demon 232]

I've listened to Caro on Footy Classified and on 3AW over the past few weeks, and she has been pretty forthright in saying she really doesn't know where he will go, and has continually said she thinks this and that.......nothing concrete.

She can't just sit there as a reporter and say nothing, but like many others in the media, can make a case for Judd going to the Pies.

I like Caro, and think she is one of the better footy journos going around, but it's pretty safe to say this whole Judd story has her stumped like the rest of them at the minute!

[WonnaJurah 5]

i thought caro was more nrl based then afl

[beelzebub 22,349]

seemed to remember recently Caro was pretty damn sure Connolly would never come to Melbourne..

spot on.........................NOT !!

[mick2007 0]

Maybe thats why Clement retired so they can squeeze Judd in the salary cap. I thought he would have played another year even though he had a few injuries, he is worth more on the field than Bucks

[beelzebub 22,349]

ive wondered elsewhere, but Clement going creates more problems for Collingwood for mine.. Some may think it opens the coffers more, but that was never going to be a problem for Collingwood.. Now they have positional priorities coming into play they'd rather not have right now... well thats my thinking

[beelzebub 22,349]

maybe this is just me.. but everyone in the press etc are all thinking the "logical' approach to all this. he oughta go here because...or he might go there because of this and that; and to me nothing about this is straightforward in that respect other than he wants to play in Melbourne mainly at the G.

[Diablo 1]

You have to remember that journalists bring their own unique preconceptions and bias to the table when they express their opinions - just like supporters. It'd be easier for a Jim Wilson (Carlton) to accept that Judd would want to go to Collingwood rather than Melbourne, or for Caro (Richmond) the same... it'd simply be inconceivable for someone like Grybas (Collingwood) to believe anything else. If Judd chooses Melbourne... it means they all have to go away and not only have to try and rationalise it (gee there won't be a story that doesn't mention he barracked for us as a kid) and admit that maybe that their preconceptions may have been wrong.

I think this is an excellent point. People will never say he's going to Melbourne because they simply cannot comprehend what appeals about us. Richmond, Melbourne and Carlton are all at about the same place right now, and Richmond and Carlton supporters will simply refuse to see what is better about us than about them. Same with the media. They cannot see what the appeal is about Melbourne. On top of that we have strongly opinionated numpties like Drain Russell talking us out of it.

[mick2007 0]

I think this is an excellent point. People will never say he's going to Melbourne because they simply cannot comprehend what appeals about us. Richmond, Melbourne and Carlton are all at about the same place right now, and Richmond and Carlton supporters will simply refuse to see what is better about us than about them. Same with the media. They cannot see what the appeal is about Melbourne. On top of that we have strongly opinionated numpties like Drain Russell talking us out of it.

People quickly forget we were the best Vic Club last season and would have been close to it again if it wasn't for injurys. We are the most underrated team in the comp. If we had a superstar in our team they would talk about us. Hearing about StKilda all the time shits me seens they are the most overrated team in the comp for the simple fact they have Nick Riewoldt. Because he is a superstar they expect special things to happen