Changes for next week

[Straight Sets Simon 23,113]

This is one week where winning should be the only priority.

In: McLean, Bizzell, P Johnson, Bate (if fit)

Out: Bode, Frawley (inj), Jamar, Ferguson

Key match-ups: Holland on Rocca, Carroll on Cloke, Bell on Didak

[gOLLy 401]

In : Mclean

Out : Frawley (inj)

[beelzebub 23,383]

or...in the now for something totally different.. we could put our team out there and let them worry about matching us !! lol.

Still probably need Clogs down back....shame when he's on "fire" !!!

[True Believer 1]

This is one week where winning should be the only priority.

In: McLean, Bizzell, P Johnson, Bate (if fit)

Out: Bode, Frawley (inj), Jamar, Ferguson

Key match-ups: Holland on Rocca, Carroll on Cloke, Bell on Didak

Why out Fergusson/Jamar...Both played a good part last night

[sylvinator 96]

This is one week where winning should be the only priority.

In: McLean, Bizzell, P Johnson, Bate (if fit)

Out: Bode, Frawley (inj), Jamar, Ferguson

Key match-ups: Holland on Rocca, Carroll on Cloke, Bell on Didak

In: Mclean, Buckley

Out: Bode, Frawley (inj)

Keep playing the youth!

id consider putting in Garland...

holland vs rocca

Carrol vs cloke

bell vs Didak

Brown vs leon davis

forwards:

Sylvia Newton Green

Davey Neitz Robbo

[Jaded No More 68,973]

Thought Bode played well last night given it was his first match. His tackling is great.

In: McLean, Buckley

Out: Frawley (inj.), Brown (was good in patches last night, but his kicking is killing me!).

[Lamberto Bava 6]

Just McLean in for Chip IMO.

It's pretty tough to drop anyone after you beat a team trying to get into the finals by 7 goals.

[Yze_Magic 3]

In - McLean, Bate

Out - Frawley (inj), Moloney (for god sake put him on ice before his groin is ruined for life. He is nowhere near fit and is having no impact)

B - Bell Carroll Holland

HB - Wheatley Ferguson Pickett

C - Johnstone Jones Dunn

HF - Green Newton Bate

F - Robertson Neitz Davey

R - White McLean McDonald

I/C - Bode Sylvia Brown Jamar

[The Fergburger 0]

it says on injuryupdate.com.au that brock will miss 1-2 matches with a groin.

With the way the boys played against the bulldogs last night i would leave the team as it is and keep playing the youngstars, however if frawley doesn't pull up then bring Bate in for him (if fit)

[deestroy08 0]

Not so sure Bate will pull up if he didn't play for Sandy this weekend.

And before he was injured he was very average. There'd be a few others I'd put before him to play a part in such a huge game.

I'd even prefer to see Yze in playing alongside his longtime friend and teammate but if we're going for a win, then my choices would be:

In: McLean (if not fit, then Buckley), Garland (from all accounts seems to be deserving of a spot, and we are all about 'playing the youngsters' )

Out: Moloney (only because I agree with YMs sentiments - he should be rested for the remainder of the season or he will do some serious damage), Frawley (injured)

I really wouldn't like to see too many more changes made than that as Saturday night's performance really was a group effort and it was difficult to isolate top performances, with the exception of Jones.

[Lord Travis 10,763]

No need for any big changes.

Bring in Mclean or Bate if fit. Out goes Frawley injured, replaced by one of those 2.

[Rhino Richards 1,467]

Thought Bode played well last night given it was his first match. His tackling is great.

In: McLean, Buckley

Out: Frawley (inj.), Brown (was good in patches last night, but his kicking is killing me!).

Brown was close to BOG. Its a harsh call. While Bode just went.

Why out Fergusson/Jamar...Both played a good part last night

If you want to win against the Pies, you drop them. On the other hand if you want to lose........

[Bring-Back-Powell 14,939]

Brown (was good in patches last night, but his kicking is killing me!).

When you get 5 votes in the Herald Sun and BOG, its highly unlikely you'll be dropped.

Brown we'll be there for the big occasion.

[Nasher 33,617]

Yes Bode just went, but he'd been in the best for Sandy for weeks on end. I'd give him more of an opportunity to rise to the pace of the game before dropping him back. By the same token, Buckley had been ordinary for weeks in the firsts, but went back to Sandy and looked a class above. You could argue a case either way; reward him for some very good form, or leave him at Sandy to consolidate it.

After Saturday night we have as much chance of seeing Brown dropped as we do of seeing Nathan Jones dropped. His game was as good as they come. He stays in.

I have no preference for Jamar over PJ. IMO Jamar was okay on Saturday night and Collingwood's second string rucks are average. PJ at this point looks like he may be the superior player, however like old55 I've not completely written Jamar off.

In the absense of Rivers and now Frawley we have a key back position available for one of the NQRs to fill. Bizzell is my preference over Ferguson. Both are "tall backs" who can "play forward" (i.e. they're ordinary backmen and worse forwards), but to me Bizzell is the lesser of two evils.

Are we expecting Bate back?

[Jaded No More 68,973]

In the absense of Rivers and now Frawley we have a key back position available for one of the NQRs to fill. Bizzell is my preference over Ferguson. Both are "tall backs" who can "play forward" (i.e. they're ordinary backmen and worse forwards), but to me Bizzell is the lesser of two evils.

Are we expecting Bate back?

Why not Garland?

I know we desperately want to win this match, but we still shouldn't lose sight of the bigger picture.

Garland was named in the bests for Sandy, Bizzell wasn't.

And I know Brown won't get dropped, I'm just hoping.

His low kicks send me into a fit of rage. Just kick the ball a bit higher Browny, PLEASE!!!

We also need to look at how Collingwood will line-up.

I'm worried about Cloke. Do we play Carroll on him?

Dutchy on Rocca and Bell to give Didak a spanking again.

I think Miller might be back this week, especially if Frawley doesn't come up.

[Demons 32 235]

In: Mclean, Buckley, Bizzel

Out: Frawley (inj), Bode, Ferguson.

Its not about playing youngsters when its big Neita's 300th.

[Nasher 33,617]

Why not Garland?

I know we desperately want to win this match, but we still shouldn't lose sight of the bigger picture.

Garland was named in the bests for Sandy, Bizzell wasn't.

I actually forgot about Garland. That said I don't think there's much to be gained by playing him again at this point. Let him slowly build his confidence and skill set at Sandringham, that's why we have the alignment.

Playing kids who aren't ready yet is like trying to start a car in 4th gear. Sure, you eventually reach top speed, but it takes a lot longer and it's a pretty bumpy ride along the way.

[sylvinator 96]

I actually forgot about Garland. That said I don't think there's much to be gained by playing him again at this point. Let him slowly build his confidence and skill set at Sandringham, that's why we have the alignment.

Playing kids who aren't ready yet is like trying to start a car in 4th gear. Sure, you eventually reach top speed, but it takes a lot longer and it's a pretty bumpy ride along the way.

I disagree completely.

Playing youngsters before they are ready fast-tracks their development significantly. They might struggle for a few games, but in the long-run a player who gets runs with the seniors will develop quicker than a player that rots away at sandy.

people do not realize what a massive skill level and pace difference their is between vfl and afl. it's like playing 2 different sports afl is that much better standard. young players gain alot from senior experience and it really bugs me when people outrightly declare that theyd prefer to see pickett and brown in the team ahead of Buckley, Dunn and Garland when our season was over 8 weeks ago and have openly declared we are playing for 2008 and beyond.

[Guest bWell]

I disagree completely.

Playing youngsters before they are ready fast-tracks their development significantly. They might struggle for a few games, but in the long-run a player who gets runs with the seniors will develop quicker than a player that rots away at sandy.

All in all, I want our best side in against the Pies. I want to destroy them!

They have a young team & it's proving costly now at seasons end. We need our strongest, most reliable team for Friday night.

B: Brown Carroll Bell

HB: Wheatley Holland Green

C: Johnstone McDonald Moloney

HF: Pickett Newton Davey

F: Bate Neitz Robertson

RR: White McLean Jones

Int: Jamar, Bizzell, Sylvia, Miller

Emg (from): Buckley, P. Johnson, C. Johnson, Garland

I believe with this side in, we should get over the line.

[DemonTux 97]

All in all, I want our best side in against the Pies. I want to destroy them!

They have a young team & it's proving costly now at seasons end. We need our strongest, most reliable team for Friday night.

B: Brown Carroll Bell

HB: Wheatley Holland Green

C: Johnstone McDonald Moloney

HF: Pickett Newton Davey

F: Bate Neitz Robertson

RR: White McLean Jones

Int: Jamar, Bizzell, Sylvia, Miller

Emg (from): Buckley, P. Johnson, C. Johnson, Garland

I believe with this side in, we should get over the line.

No Dunn!?!?!??!?!?!!?!

[Demons 32 235]

No Dunn!?!?!??!?!?!!?!

Yeah drop Miller for Dunn.

Or if Bate doesn't pull up, Dunn.

Def need Dunn.

[Guest bWell]

Apologies!

Massive apologies!

Miller out of my side for Dunn no question.

But a pretty good side none the less.

[Bobby McKenzie 2,385]

Thought Bode played well last night given it was his first match. His tackling is great.

In: McLean, Buckley

Out: Frawley (inj.), Brown (was good in patches last night, but his kicking is killing me!).

Worn out record! Jaded, did you watch Brown closely on Sat night? I took particular note of his kicking and there were very few times he didn't hit his target. Give him a break, and focus on his guts and determination. You could never contemplate dropping him after last week.

[Lord Travis 10,763]

Brown wont be dropped. He played well on the weekend, and has been giving his all in this bleak season. He will definately be there for his good friend Neita's 300th, and likely play every game left this season, then probably retire at the end of the year.

[Yze_Magic 3]

Brown was sensational on the weekend, no way in the world does he get dropped

He will be there on Friday night vs the Filth, giving his all for the skipper and for the Red and Blue