May - better after first

Gawn - no votes today

Chandler. - strong running game

Rivers - often an observer

Petracca - important but limited

Fritsch - seemingly without passion

Salem - just a plodder

Oliver - couldn’t handle tag

Lindsay - needed more involvement

Johnson - replace with Roo

Pickett - unfortunately well held

Melksham - little drive today

Turner - a solid game

McVee - not his best

Langford - looking very tired

Windsor - poor under pressure

Langdon - untypically quiet game

Sharp - Viney obviously replaces

Sparrow - little involvement again

Bowey - little defensive drive

Petty - limited contesting effect

Lever - liability in defense

Laurie - made no difference

Bye Bye Chocco

Everyone - [censored] goal kickers

Melbourne - Go To Specsavers

MFC....can't kick ...

Kozzie - lost the plot

14 minutes ago, joeboy said:

May - better after first

Gawn - no votes today

Chandler. - strong running game

Rivers - often an observer

Petracca - important but limited

Fritsch - seemingly without passion

Salem - just a plodder

Oliver - couldn’t handle tag

Lindsay - needed more involvement

Johnson - replace with Roo

Pickett - unfortunately well held

Melksham - little drive today

Turner - a solid game

McVee - not his best

Langford - looking very tired

Windsor - poor under pressure

Langdon - untypically quiet game

Sharp - Viney obviously replaces

Sparrow - little involvement again

Bowey - little defensive drive

Petty - limited contesting effect

Lever - liability in defense

Laurie - made no difference

You are far too kind to nearly everyone, Joeboy.

Petty Soft as butter.

Lever Lost sheep anyone?

Lindsay Left foot shocker.

Windsor Backman my rse.

Dees - always outpoint opposition

Every! Friggin! Time!

Lindsay, I’m not convinced

Laurie, just as predicted

Lever, what about McDonald

Kozzie, in another headspace

Johnson, Victoria Football League

Oliver, not top 100

MFC: heartbreaking to follow

Langford: Needs a rest

Windsor: Not a backman

Pressure: 8th worst ever

Forward line: Tall mark needed (ability to kick straight an advantage)

Coaching: Lyon wins again

Goal kicking: Words fail me

Backline: : Missing Tom McDonald

Laurie: Too the answer (

Edited June 1Jun 1 by Older demon
Additional info

Melbourne Football Club - Richo’s barn door

Petty - an irrelevant footballer

Lever - limited contemporary skills

May - Looked better today

Rivers - plays for frees

XL - Skilful ball user

AJ - Limited but effortful

Windsor - Continues to decline

Edited June 1Jun 1 by BLWNBA

5 minutes ago, 48 Year Now said:

Lindsay, I’m not convinced

Laurie, just as predicted

Lever, what about McDonald

Kozzie, in another headspace

Johnson, Victoria Football League

Oliver, not top 100

Really, not convinced about Lindsay??

He is the least of our problems. Will be a very good player.

May - very good defence 👍🏻

Gawn - battled hard and was one of our best great contest v Marshall 👍🏻

Turner - yes played well as a 3rd tall defender 👍🏻

McVee - good rebound and run 20 disposals 👍🏻

Bowey - well held in 1st half Good in 2nd half to be ok 👍🏻

Petracca - played in bursts but nothing like last week was okay 👍🏻

Chandler. - contests and runs hard all day 👍🏻

Ummmm the rest …

Fritsch - seemingly played half forward connector and stayed wide and kicked wide too ineffective overall

Salem - likes the boring 15 metre pass defensively caught out too often and looked slow

Oliver - Zac jones tagged him and did a good job Clarry battled on

Lindsay - uncharacteristically is missing goals He nailed them in under 18s Had ok game and excuse as he’s just 1st year

Johnson - big bustling bumbling performance love his heart but limited again

Pickett - simply poor today Windhager tag was too good and frustrated kozzzy

(Why didn’t Goodwin put him forward to one in one in square??)

Melksham - seemed injured and bravely went on yet nothing today

Rivers - he tried and tried and tried but it didn’t happen today

Langford - yes agree he might need a spell as he battles but is looking very tired

Petty - good contest and tackle to goal was good but …

The rest need to go to house of mirrors

Windsor - poor under pressure, turnovers and missed tackles (please please please put him back to the wing, end his defense role now)

Langdon - wow that was a shocker. Had to ask if he was playing. Ed will bounce back

Sharp - so inconsistent- works hard then lets himself down - disappointing!!

Sparrow - where is he at? Defensive forward?? Slow and lacks skill had 3 goal chances for zero goals not good enough

Lever -very disappointing , yes he was a liability in defense & imv physically is not right

Laurie - some might excuse as only had a quarter but looked slow again and I’m still saying he’s not up to it. Maybe give him a few games so we can finally see that he’s not going to make it. Fair enough. He is a good VFL player.

2 minutes ago, Left Foot Snap said:

Really, not convinced about Lindsay??

He is the least of our problems. Will be a very good player.

Agree he’s not a problem, just not convinced he’s as good as commentators talk. Think Windsor better but destroying him at half back.

[censored] that up

Windsor - not a defender.

If they keep persisting with this, they are going to Melbourne him

Edited June 1Jun 1 by deegirl

MFC- Desperately need Worpel …

30 minutes ago, 48 Year Now said:

Agree he’s not a problem, just not convinced he’s as good as commentators talk. Think Windsor better but destroying him at half back.

He has won me over. I didn't like him to start with as he looked like someone I don't like, so he has done well to turn me around.

Windsor will be a very good player as well and while he isn't tearing up half back like I thought he would, he will develop into a well rounded player.

1 hour ago, joeboy said:

Pickett - unfortunately well held

So why wasn't interference run for him. Windhager did a great job on Kozzie, but there needed to be a "screen" for Kozzie. The other thing is again, we give up so much possession from a point kick in. So often, St.Kilda went coast to coast, without a Melbourne player touching the footy. We looked flat today. No spark.

Red Centre Rabble

LYON

---

GOODWIN

First time Saints have beaten us since 2019 and we had to kick 21 points for them to beat us. Kicking is deplorable.!!!

2 hours ago, spirit of norm smith said:

Lindsay - uncharacteristically is missing goals He nailed them in under 18s Had ok game and excuse as he’s just 1st year

He's an absolute ripper 'Norm', will kick one then the monkey will be off his back.

2 hours ago, 48 Year Now said:

Agree he’s not a problem, just not convinced he’s as good as commentators talk. Think Windsor better but destroying him at half back.

I think Lindsay is the better player, I'm more concerned with Langford on a wing & in general. fumbles too much below his knees and gets caught out in 2 way running, would rather Windsor or Langdon back on one wing.

Lindsay is good on the other...

Laurie Not the problem

and

Laurie Not the answer

#19 looking very tired