On 16/02/2025 at 18:53, BC_1718_DC said:

Turns out that hasn’t stopped Melbourne from asking Hendersons management about his situation over the weekend. One to watch. 

https://www.afl.com.au/news/1269731 👀

Edited February 17Feb 17 by BC_1718_DC

Get the best small forward not currently on the list that is AFL ready. If that's Henderson great.

We essentially need a small forward for a 3 game contract given Kozzie is suspended and Spargo's only just got going and might not be ready for the opening rounds.

3 minutes ago, Bring-Back-Powell said:

Get the best small forward not currently on the list that is AFL ready. If that's Henderson great.

We essentially need a small forward for a 3 game contract given Kozzie is suspended and Spargo's only just got going and might not be ready for the opening rounds.

I think a high pressure small forward could lock in a spot in the best 23 in my mind. One of the most important roles in modern footy given the extreme team defences now deployed by the best sides.

16 minutes ago, DistrACTION Jackson said:

I think a high pressure small forward could lock in a spot in the best 23 in my mind. One of the most important roles in modern footy given the extreme team defences now deployed by the best sides.

as it stands we have one - chandler - available for rd 1, given pickett's suspension, spargo's lack of match play, and pup brown's role as a wing

it would make sense if henderson was the chap we were chasing

4 minutes ago, Bring-Back-Powell said:

Get the best small forward not currently on the list that is AFL ready. If that's Henderson great.

We essentially need a small forward for a 3 game contract given Kozzie is suspended and Spargo's only just got going and might not be ready for the opening rounds.

We should be looking at the future not just 3 games.There are ways of overcoming a loss for that small period.

You have written these 3 games off in previous posts for months as if we will be losing all 3 and our finals chances are ruined.

Thank goodness Clubs gave a better way of approaching this situation in both mind and body than you.Sure Kossie is a loss but AMW Pup or Henderson or Spargo ( won’t be fit enough I don’t think ) or Langford or Trac can all win us the game/s.

A little more faith would be appreciated in the 23 selected to start the season in style.

It’s also asking say Henderson to play his first game being only with the club 2/3 weeks and play a match winning role.

I am happy if it is Henderson or Culley or George. JT and the Footy Dept and TL will make a decision considering all options. 

Very fortunate to have this opportunity and let’s hope Shane can recover to play again. 

If he can play that ANB role (run hard both ways, be accountable for Tracs man when CP sneaks forward) then perfect.

It sounds like Henderson has the traits to play that role while being pretty good with ball in hand. Chocco should have some good insight.

Free Kynan Brown

22 minutes ago, adonski said:

Free Kynan Brown

Why not both….

2 hours ago, Bring-Back-Powell said:

Get the best small forward not currently on the list that is AFL ready. If that's Henderson great.

We essentially need a small forward for a 3 game contract given Kozzie is suspended and Spargo's only just got going and might not be ready for the opening rounds.

I think that's exactly right, and is what we have now done.

 

 Let's hope he is AFL ready. 

On 16/02/2025 at 08:21, Lil_red_fire_engine said:

We are going into season with Oliver, Trac and Viney to play the main roles as normal. Plus we have a want to give Rivers and Langdon significant minutes in there. Plus we want to rotate Sparrow, Pickett and Langford through there. Unless we get hit with serious injuries again (which is not the current case) how do we think. Culley gets a game. Culley by all reports should be on an AFL list but is it ours?

We have lost McAdam and Tholstrup for significant stretches of the year. Spargo is coming from a long way back. Pickett is out for the first 3 and we want him spinning through the middle. We have a gaping hole for a small forward (or two) on the list. I can see that George does some good things but I doubt he is ready for 4 quarter AFL intensity. I would be offering the spot to Jack Henderson before West Coast pounce. He may not have the upside of George but is proven at VFL and more match hardened in my opinion. We looked at him closely with the pick we took AJ with so would not surprise.

Welcome Jack. 

On 16/02/2025 at 18:53, BC_1718_DC said:

Turns out that hasn’t stopped Melbourne from asking Hendersons management about his situation over the weekend. One to watch. 

Escalated quickly. Hopefully we see him suit up against North on Saturday. 

3 hours ago, 58er said:

You have written these 3 games off in previous posts for months as if we will be losing all 3 and our finals chances are ruined.

Thank goodness Clubs gave a better way of approaching this situation in both mind and body than you.Sure Kossie is a loss but AMW Pup or Henderson or Spargo ( won’t be fit enough I don’t think ) or Langford or Trac can all win us the game/s.

A little more faith would be appreciated in the 23 selected to start the season in style.

It’s also asking say Henderson to play his first game being only with the club 2/3 weeks and play a match winning role.

I am happy if it is Henderson or Culley or George. JT and the Footy Dept and TL will make a decision considering all options. 

Very fortunate to have this opportunity and let’s hope Shane can recover to play again. 

I will happily eat massive humble pie if we're 3-0 after round 3 and the loss of Kozzie has no impact on our W/L record.

We lack serious X-factor, class and potency when he doesn't play. Think of the early season Sydney and Brisbane losses last year when we were actually up and about as a side, but his absence stuck out like a sore thumb.

We were an impotent forward line and overall team last year even with him in the side, I can't imagine it being any better without him.

Culley must still be a chance, if Kentfield goes on LTI list, to keep the pressure off him and still maybe allow him late in the season to play some footy with Casey, or in a lower competition.

45 minutes ago, Redleg said:

Culley must still be a chance, if Kentfield goes on LTI list, to keep the pressure off him and still maybe allow him late in the season to play some footy with Casey, or in a lower competition.

Don’t even think the LTI exists anymore. The inactive list is the mechanism which rules out whoever you put on there for the whole season. 

Why are people so concerned about a small forward? We have plenty; I'd be more interested in someone who can play midfield and could move forward in a pinch running midfield will be the key to this year if, by all accounts, there is a change to how the ball is delivered into the forward line.

8 minutes ago, demon3165 said:

Why are people so concerned about a small forward? We have plenty; I'd be more interested in someone who can play midfield and could move forward in a pinch running midfield will be the key to this year if, by all accounts, there is a change to how the ball is delivered into the forward line.

Plenty of small forwards? Where? 

 

Other than Kozzy there isn’t a lot. Chandler doesn’t hit the scoreboard enough. Spargo is always injured and was never a big goal kicker. 
 

We drafted Langford to do the mid/forward role you’re talking about. 

31 minutes ago, demon3165 said:

Why are people so concerned about a small forward? We have plenty; I'd be more interested in someone who can play midfield and could move forward in a pinch running midfield will be the key to this year if, by all accounts, there is a change to how the ball is delivered into the forward line.

‘Plenty of small forwards’ 

Are these small forwards in the room with us right now?

48 minutes ago, BC_1718_DC said:

Plenty of small forwards? Where? 

 

Other than Kozzy there isn’t a lot. Chandler doesn’t hit the scoreboard enough. Spargo is always injured and was never a big goal kicker. 
 

We drafted Langford to do the mid/forward role you’re talking about. 

Laurie and Brown could play the role. Also like the idea of Bowey eventually playing as a small forward. 

18 minutes ago, SPC said:

Laurie and Brown could play the role. Also like the idea of Bowey eventually playing as a small forward. 

I wouldn’t be opposed to any of those 3 and in previous posts I have mentioned all 3 as options I would love to see considered or given a go. However the club seem to be persisting with Laurie as a midfielder, Bowey as a half back/small defender and Brown as a wing/half forward. (Which doesn’t make a lot of sense to me given our lack of options).  

2 hours ago, SPC said:

Laurie and Brown could play the role. Also like the idea of Bowey eventually playing as a small forward. 

Laurie has no pace, you can’t pressure if you can never catch anyone.

Bowey is so well suited to half back. Can’t say he’d be terrible forward but we’re hardly flush for half backs either.

Kynan Brown is second year rookie who’s fumbly and has a lot of work to do with his skills and decision making. This place is way too high on him.

AMW is the one I’m shocked who hasn’t been moved forward again but historically he’s had a poor tank which makes him unsuitable for the role. I assume they’re 

17 hours ago, Bring-Back-Powell said:

I will happily eat massive humble pie if we're 3-0 after round 3 and the loss of Kozzie has no impact on our W/L record.

We lack serious X-factor, class and potency when he doesn't play. Think of the early season Sydney and Brisbane losses last year when we were actually up and about as a side, but his absence stuck out like a sore thumb.

We were an impotent forward line and overall team last year even with him in the side, I can't imagine it being any better without him.

Well you have maintained your stays quo. You don’t think about 15 of our players might be better performed this season? 
Oh and a far quicker game plan as well. 
I could give 15 reasons why we could/should be better this year but you aren’t even coming up with ONE??? 

21 hours ago, 58er said:

Thank goodness Clubs gave a better way of approaching this situation in both mind and body than you.Sure Kossie is a loss but AMW Pup or Henderson or Spargo ( won’t be fit enough I don’t think ) or Langford or Trac can all win us the game/s.

That's a very big call to make on a bunch of players that have played 6 games (AMW). 2 games (KB), and zero games (Langford), or have never won us a game via individual performance and likely won't even be playing (Spargo). The only one there I'd give credence to is Trac. 

I am still in favour of moving Kentfield to the inactive list and taking Jai or Roy, probably Jai.

Kentfield will not play for quite a while and certainly not at AFL level this year.

Take the pressure off him and let him train and be with the boys, knowing while he is not ready, he isn’t keeping another player off the list.

When ready, he can play at Casey or a lower competition, for the few games left in the season.

I think we will lose Jai in the msd, if we don’t take him now.

Edited February 19Feb 19 by Redleg

SSP UPDATE

With two days left for eligible clubs to sign players under the SSP rules, this is the update of signings - 

Carlton: Matt Carroll (Carlton AFL)

Essendon: Jaxon Prior (Brisbane Lions AFL), Tom Edwards (Swan Districts WAFL)

Fremantle: Isaiah Dudley (Central District SANFL)

Gold Coast Suns: Ben Jepson (Southport VFL)

Melbourne: Jack Henderson (Werribee VFL)

Port Adelaide: Quinton Narkle (Geelong AFL) Josh Lai (Cheltenham SFNL)

St Kilda: Harry Boyd (Norwood SANFL)

West Coast Eagles: Sandy Brock (Gold Coast AFL)

The following players have trained as prospective recruits during the SSP period but have not yet been signed

Adelaide: Lachlan McAndrew

Carlton: Sam Durdin, Liam McMahon, Denver Grainger-Barras

Essendon: Kaine Baldwin, Will Hoare

Fremantle: Baynen Lowe

Gold Coast: Paul Hewago Oea

Melbourne: Jai Culley, Roy George

Port Adelaide: Jack Watkins

West Coast: James Van Es

Western Bulldogs: Dom Brew, Brayden
Crossley

NOTES: in the case of Culley and George, there are no SSP list spots available at present.

According to Paul Amy, Crossley has been told he won’t be listed by the Bulldogs. Back to the VFL. Brew has also missed out.

1 hour ago, Whispering_Jack said:

SSP UPDATE

With two days left for eligible clubs to sign players under the SSP rules, this is the update of signings - 

Carlton: Matt Carroll (Carlton AFL)

Essendon: Jaxon Prior (Brisbane Lions AFL), Tom Edwards (Swan Districts WAFL)

Fremantle: Isaiah Dudley (Central District SANFL)

Gold Coast Suns: Ben Jepson (Southport VFL)

Melbourne: Jack Henderson (Werribee VFL)

Port Adelaide: Quinton Narkle (Geelong AFL) Josh Lai (Cheltenham SFNL)

St Kilda: Harry Boyd (Norwood SANFL)

West Coast Eagles: Sandy Brock (Gold Coast AFL)

The following players have trained as prospective recruits during the SSP period but have not yet been signed

Adelaide: Lachlan McAndrew

Carlton: Sam Durdin, Liam McMahon, Denver Grainger-Barras

Essendon: Kaine Baldwin, Will Hoare

Fremantle: Baynen Lowe

Gold Coast: Paul Hewago Oea

Melbourne: Jai Culley, Roy George

Port Adelaide: Jack Watkins

West Coast: James Van Es

Western Bulldogs: Dom Brew, Brayden
Crossley

NOTE: in the case of Culley and George, there are no SSP list spots available at present.

What would have happened if McAdam had done his achilles on Saturday?...