Christian Petracca

[Gawndy the Great 9,008]

4 minutes ago, Ethan Tremblay said:

I think it’s time Petracca puts his big boy pants on and provides a response. 

It would help for sure. The reasons why he hasn’t yet as far as I can speculate are:

1. He is waging up his future. Including whether he can facilitate a trade and request one when it becomes a possibility.

2. Similar to above, but is considering the grievance process and doesnt want to make any public statement that may be used against him in a court of law.

3. Using the silence to drive rabid speculation to drive up his clicks and follows

4. Doesn’t think he needs to say anything as he is contracted for 5 more years.

5. Using the silence to scare the [censored] out of the club to make real change.
 

 

[gs77 3,912]

4 hours ago, adonski said:

Trac has withdrawn from the event, to be replaced by May and Oliver as per Tom Morris

One would think pulling out of events you are headlining might be damaging to your brand.

[Dee*ceiving 1,625]

Kate was more bad than good I'm afraid. 

Spent a lot of time trying to convince people she's happy to speak to the media any time and that lots of people are doing lots of work. Very little specifics in terms of the actions that need/are being taken. 

Admitted she hadn't spoken to Christian or his family for several months. Our best player, who was somewhere between critically injured and close to dying after playing a game of football in our colours!! Please...!

She just had to have done more than that, herself. Kate should have been able to recount the time and date of the last coversation she had with Christian and when she expects to speak with him again.

Not being able to convince the supporters that she is all over this situation, hands on, is simply not good enough. 

[Kent 2,850]

Meanwhile other well run clubs are

Focussing on footy and trades and preparing for next season

Mfc are a complete shambles at least the fan club will have an excuse next year for the club  underperforming once again

[Dee*ceiving 1,625]

45 minutes ago, Travy14 said:

Roffey literally said she has barely spoken to Trac or his family since his injury because they havnt been at the footy.

Disgraceful

36 minutes ago, Ungarieboy said:

How many presidents (of organisations/companies) or CEO's contact general staff for injury, trauma, we'll being etc.  I've gone through a traumatic ordeal in the last couple of years far far greater than what he's been through and only my boss reached out to provide support.  

And by boss I mean direct manager, and their boss; not the top tier executive!

Your situaton is unfortunate Ungarie. I hope you are ok. 

When my dad passed the CEO where I work rang me within 4 hours to offer support and all the time I needed. It was much appreciated and in the scheme of things little effort for him. This is in a company of 3500 employees, admittedly we are known to eachother.  

Footy clubs aren't giant organisations and Superstar football players are not office managers. 

Kate has completely failed in her duties here. I have become more firm in my view in the 4 hours since the interview.

She must go, ideally stepping down real soon (very sad to say).

[Engorged Onion 10,099]

looking forward to dozens of these 'when' he plays us again...

[FearTheBeard 1,195]

Cannot believe anyone thought that Roffey was anything other than appalling and derelict in her duty as the president of our club.

She along with Pert, Richardson and the board need to be given their marching orders. Problems are bigger than Petracca.

[Oxdee 242]

22 minutes ago, Dee*ceiving said:

Kate was more bad than good I'm afraid. 

Spent a lot of time trying to convince people she's happy to speak to the media any time and that lots of people are doing lots of work. Very little specifics in terms of the actions that need/are being taken. 

Admitted she hadn't spoken to Christian or his family for several months. Our best player, who was somewhere between critically injured and close to dying after playing a game of football in our colours!! Please...!

She just had to have done more than that, herself. Kate should have been able to recount the time and date of the last coversation she had with Christian and when she expects to speak with him again.

Not being able to convince the supporters that she is all over this situation, hands on, is simply not good enough. 

She is completely useless.. get rid of her. How on earth hasn’t she checked in with petracca for a few months???? He is your number 1 player who is on the sidelines for an extended time. Schedule a call with him every few weeks to make sure he is ok. Complete incompetence.

HEADS NEED TO ROLE!!!!

[YearOfTheDees 3,262]

49 minutes ago, Macca said:

And of course the big ticket in town this Sunday is the good old Ringwood RSL (3.30pm)  where what's his name is gonna speak

But will he speak?  Will the words be leaked to the proprietor and then said? 

All will possibly be revealed Sunday.  Stay tuned

Told he has cancelled and been replaced with Oliver and May.

[Macca 16,565]

1 minute ago, YearOfTheDees said:

Told he has cancelled and been replaced with Oliver and May.

Well there you go, I'm not at all surprised

Do the right thing, be loud and proud about it

Do the wrong thing, eerie silence

The plan has been stuck to, by my reckoning.  And stayed on script

[DeesignerAU 309]

27 minutes ago, FearTheBeard said:

Cannot believe anyone thought that Roffey was anything other than appalling and derelict in her duty as the president of our club.

She along with Pert, Richardson and the board need to be given their marching orders. Problems are bigger than Petracca.

It's all very well calling for the heads of everyone (and don't get me wrong... I agree), but who is going to step up? Who has the profile, personality and skills to take on those roles.

Judging by the feedback in other discussions, Demonland members already have issues with Peter Lawrence and what has happened. So who's next ? Who's willing to put their hand up? 

[Willmoy1947 3,953]

And while everyone is looking at another player of ours being incessantly attacked by the Media, the same group are, behind the scenes  making sure that our equal best player, who they well know to be easy to deceive, is conned into thinking that he  hasn't been looked after. There is so much more to this that has to come out. I would include Taylor in this along with the muppets and don't ever forget Moore.

[Jaded No More 67,469]

1 minute ago, Willmoy1947 said:

And while everyone is looking at another player of ours being incessantly attacked by the Media, the same group are, behind the scenes  making sure that our equal best player, who they well know to be easy to deceive, is conned into thinking that he  hasn't been looked after. There is so much more to this that has to come out. I would include Taylor in this along with the muppets and don't ever forget Moore.

 

[Gorgoroth 12,667]

I think Roffey said she hadn't spoken to Traccs parents for a few months, not Trac.

And seriously, they guys nearly 30, you don't need to keep in contact with his parents if you are the president. 

And just maybe if they watched the team and not their son she would have and then the crowd would also be bigger and Trac would have his bigger crowds.😂

[Supreme_Demon 3,212]

Pretty damning if Kate Roffey hasn't spoken to Christian Petracca and/or his family in months.

Simply not good enough as President of the Melbourne Football Club.

It may be unpleasant to bring up but do you think Eddie McGuire would do this when he was President of Collingwood?! If Nathan Buckley was injured Eddie would be at his bedside in the hospital!

People can joke about Eddie (and I am not a fan of his) but there is no doubt he cared about his players (at least most of them).

Edited August 29 by Supreme_Demon

[Lucifers Hero 38,841]

I had mixed feelings to this part of the interview.

From The Age:

Did you do enough during the two weeks following his horrific injury? 

'.........So I’m not sure, again, as I say in the media, a lot of this rhetoric around not enough was done, we need to actually sit down and go, ‘What wasn’t done? What would you have liked to have been done? If we didn’t do enough, you know, we can work through that and apologise’. But I’m not entirely sure what the, I don’t believe it relates to medical care, is probably all I can comment on."

• The Good:  She used the word apologise.
• The Bad:   Suggests there is a bit of rhetoric happening. 
• The Ugly:  Says 'we need to sit down and ...". 

This drama has been on for several weeks and whoever is 'we' hasn't yet sat down and asked those questions!. 

Its like Nero fiddles while Rome burns! 

She needs to put a rocket under whoever 'we' is to sit down with Trac and get answer to the questions she poses and if necessary apologise.  At least get the story from the horses mouth which apparently she doesn't have or isn't telling.

[forever demons 2,206]

On 28/08/2024 at 10:46, binman said:

They well might be.

But tracc is a 29 year old adult, not some naive draftee fresh out of high school.

Let's not infantalise him.

If he acts on bad advice that's on him, not the people giving him the advice.

I am 72 and I know for sure maturity is not gauged by age I didnt grow up until i was 45 think Tracc might be in my boat

[Gawndy the Great 9,008]

18 minutes ago, DeesignerAU said:

It's all very well calling for the heads of everyone (and don't get me wrong... I agree), but who is going to step up? Who has the profile, personality and skills to take on those roles.

Judging by the feedback in other discussions, Demonland members already have issues with Peter Lawrence and what has happened. So who's next ? Who's willing to put their hand up? 

That was going to be my question. Im not close to the club in this sense, but i suppose it doesn't have to be a club person. Do we have a go at luring Graham Wright as a club CEO from the Pies - has massive wraps. 

No idea for President though. Do they usually go to "Melbourne" people or anyone that has great board credentials. 

[DeeZee 7,296]

Damned if you do and damned if you don't.

The media is determined to bring Melbourne down , no matter what is said or inferred.

They will create their own spin based on their own pre judgement.

We are on a hiding to nothing and sometimes the less said the better.

Kate fronted the media, probably because of the multitude of calls to end the silence, but it looks like it has backfired on her.

I don’t think she will be doing it again anytime soon.

Keep them guessing and don’t honour them with a response.

The only one who should be making their position clear in all this is Trac himself.

[Jaded No More 67,469]

7 minutes ago, Lucifers Hero said:

 

She needs to put a rocket under whoever 'we' is to sit down with Trac and get answer to the questions she poses and if necessary apologise.  At least get the story from the horses mouth which apparently she doesn't have or isn't telling.

These conversations have absolutely taken place, but it sounds like she was neither involved nor informed of them.

Or perhaps she was, and doesn't want to speak about what was said, which if that is the case, she has no idea how to speak publicly.

Very easy to say "we have had conversations around this, we apologized to Christian and anyone in his life who felt they were not looked after properly, and put measures in place to ensure it does not happen again. However I will not be divulging the rest of the conversation as I am mindful of its private nature". End. 

As I keep saying over and over again, it's not what you say but how you say it. 
This PR disaster speaks to so many people who just have no understanding of how you manage a brand! 

[SFebes 4,856]

Can someone confirm whether she said:

"She hadn't talked to Trac's family"

or

"She hadn't spoken to Trac"

Big difference.....

[Deelectable 1,043]

5 minutes ago, DeeZee said:

Damned if you do and damned if you don't.

The media is determined to bring Melbourne down , no matter what is said or inferred.

They will create their own spin based on their own pre judgement.

We are on a hiding to nothing and sometimes the less said the better.

Kate fronted the media, probably because of the multitude of calls to end the silence, but it looks like it has backfired on her.

I don’t think she will be doing it again anytime soon.

Keep them guessing and don’t honour them with a response.

The only one who should be making their position clear in all this is Trac himself.

Well spoken.  Wow,are there some drama queens on here!

[Lucifers Hero 38,841]

16 minutes ago, Jaded No More said:

These conversations have absolutely taken place, but it sounds like she was neither involved nor informed of them.

Or perhaps she was, and doesn't want to speak about what was said, which if that is the case, she has no idea how to speak publicly.

Very easy to say "we have had conversations around this, we apologized to Christian and anyone in his life who felt they were not looked after properly, and put measures in place to ensure it does not happen again. However I will not be divulging the rest of the conversation as I am mindful of its private nature". End. 

As I keep saying over and over again, it's not what you say but how you say it. 
This PR disaster speaks to so many people who just have no understanding of how you manage a brand! 

She isn't doing the club any favours saying conversations have yet to be had when they have.  

If she hasn't been informed is appalling.  If she has and isn't telling fine say so, and your suggested words are excellent.

Edited August 29 by Lucifers Hero

[forever demons 2,206]

1 hour ago, Ethan Tremblay said:

I think it’s time Petracca puts his big boy pants on and provides a response. 

Dont think he owns any big boy pants yet Ethan

[DeesignerAU 309]

1 minute ago, Gawndy the Great said:

That was going to be my question. Im not close to the club in this sense, but i suppose it doesn't have to be a club person. Do we have a go at luring Graham Wright as a club CEO from the Pies - has massive wraps. 

No idea for President though. Do they usually go to "Melbourne" people or anyone that has great board credentials. 

President should be a Melbourne person, and not one of those "I'll join as a way to get on the board" like the last couple.

But above all, they need to a strong leader and lead by example. Someone who has the guts to call out behaviour that is not acceptable, someone who will keep the CEO accountable, someone who will protect all stakeholders including members, players, staff etc and someone who will protect the brand of the football club.

Someone like Steven Smith would be perfect if he was available.