PREGAME: Rd 07 vs Richmond

[Longsufferingnomore 1,647]

2 hours ago, monoccular said:

... or premature, which could explain any extended absence ?

Baby was always due in April.

[DeeSpencer 26,083]

1 hour ago, M_9 said:

It's not a bad example because almost every game Max plays he dominates the hitouts but we lose the clearances or they're close to even. That was the case in the two games we lost to Carlton last year.

I wasn't suggesting Max rest forward. He appears to be resting on the bench or spending very short stints across half back whilst JvR rucks forward of centre.

JvR is listed as 96kg. Witts, Briggs and Pittonet are listed as 107, 108 and 110kg respectively.

JvR can't be expected to alternate, albeit for short periods, between CHF and ruck where he's competing against men 10, 11 or 12kg heavier (and taller, and stronger).

Yes, I know he may be up against the opposition's second string ruckman, but not always.
And if Max goes down, then what?

I'd prefer to blood Fullerton this week rather than against strong and experienced opposition.

The alternative is to wait until the Eagles game (and that match might be tougher than we thought 2 weeks ago).

From what I’ve seen of Fullarton he isn’t any good in the ruck at all. 

In fact, I’d be fairly confident if they wanted the best result JVR would still be the second ruck. A position he does well in. He can get beaten by height and movement but he has no issues with weight/strength.

Fullarton’s best attribute is he’s slippery on a lead. He’d give us another lead up option to go with Petty. Whether a 200cm lead up tall is worth picking I’m not so sure. That is kind of most of what BBB is, but BBB can occasionally reach the big mitts up and mark or bring it to ground.

JVR hasn’t really worked out how to set up his leads at half forward. He gets stuck in between. He’s great on the charge out of the square but our coaches are reluctant to take Fritsch away from that role.

[Demon Dynasty 17,109]

40 minutes ago, Dee Boys said:

 

...repeat post

Edited April 22 by Demon Dynasty
P

[Demon Dynasty 17,109]

42 minutes ago, Dee Boys said:

Fullarton a key forward type? He’s kicked 6 goals from 19 games.

I’m struggling to understand the clamour for his inclusion. He’s never shown anything at AFL level to suggest he should be anything more than a backup. 

As @binman said, we only need someone to take about 10% of ruck contests. JVR is that man and is also a dangerous forward. Fullarton could also take 10% of ruck contests but is not a dangerous forward.
 

Where is this 'dangerous' KF view and coming in to replace Roo coming from?

Merely suggesting he replace BBB for the Tiger's match at this point.

He went pretty well vs Port up forward and as chop out ruck for Verral.

BBBs done a great job to assist early but has dropped off the last few weeks from early season efforts for obvious reasons.

Thats not to say BBB doesnt come back.  But you need to trial / manage for alternatives if or when the opp arises.  Now is a great time for that to occur.

Also on 'dangerous' KFs i would argue we presently don't have one in a form sense.   BBB, Roo & Petty have all been significantly off their best in this regard so far other than the odd cameo from BBB & Roo.

Missed the point entirely

Edited April 22 by Demon Dynasty

[layzie 34,014]

1 hour ago, Dee Boys said:

Fullarton a key forward type? He’s kicked 6 goals from 19 games.

I’m struggling to understand the clamour for his inclusion. He’s never shown anything at AFL level to suggest he should be anything more than a backup. 

As @binman said, we only need someone to take about 10% of ruck contests. JVR is that man and is also a dangerous forward. Fullarton could also take 10% of ruck contests but is not a dangerous forward.
 

He's that man right now but will he be that man come finals?

Now is the time to try these guys and see what they can do. God forbid we get to the end of the season with someone injured and all we have is an untested Fullarton to throw in there. 

[M_9 2,091]

We have shown we can cover most positions on the ground when we lose a soldier - Clarry, Gus, May, Fritsch, Kosi etc.

The only time we lost Max we had Grundy to step in. 
Currently we have not one player to step up as first ruck. It just needs to be someone big and strong who can compete.

Who knows, our mids may win more clearances playing with a losing ruckman.

if it comes down to Schache or an untried Fullerton I’m voting for the latter.

[DubDee 26,124]

Oliver, Hore and McAdam all available to play this week

[Roost it far 8,634]

McAdam available!!!

[DistrACTION Jackson 9,247]

17 minutes ago, Roost it far said:

McAdam available!!!

Will be playing the VFL game earlier that day! Hope he goes well but may need a couple games at VFL

[Demon Dynasty 17,109]

17 minutes ago, Roost it far said:

McAdam available!!!

Playing for Casey on Weds... positive news

[dee-tox 4,835]

McAdam available. Great. Wonder what they will do with him 

I think he'll make a big difference to the forward line. Like a more mercurial Bruce Lindner!

[Young Blood 2,634]

There were whispers McAdam would be available for Anzac eve going back a month ago or so. Was spot on!

 

[dazzledavey36 55,361]

2 hours ago, Dee Boys said:

Fullarton a key forward type? He’s kicked 6 goals from 19 games.

I’m struggling to understand the clamour for his inclusion. He’s never shown anything at AFL level to suggest he should be anything more than a backup. 

As @binman said, we only need someone to take about 10% of ruck contests. JVR is that man and is also a dangerous forward. Fullarton could also take 10% of ruck contests but is not a dangerous forward.
 

If people think Schache is soft who lacks physical presence then they're going to get a rude shock watching Fullarton play..

[leave it to deever 17,521]

I don't think this will be a cake walk. I know Richmond have been poor but it's a finals like atmosphere at these games and sometimes lowly opposition teams get the jump on the favourite. I hope we can make a big statement and totally obliterate them. Would love to see several of our forwards kick big bags. Especially Petts like last time.

[Roost it far 8,634]

Please everyone stay fit ffs

[Neil Crompton 5,666]

I’d prefer to blood Verrall rather than Fullarton as I believe he has a far greater upside. I also believe he has been more consistent at Casey than Fullarton. 

[Neil Crompton 5,666]

I also think that Sestan is now very close to being selected. I have a good feeling about him. 

[Clayton van Oliver 1,823]

9 minutes ago, Neil Crompton said:

I also think that Sestan is now very close to being selected. I have a good feeling about him. 

This is the sort of whisper I've been waiting for since we picked him up. Same here ie feeling. Allen Jakovich vibes

[Tarax Club 3,960]

4 minutes ago, Neil Crompton said:

I also think that Sestan is now very close to being selected. I have a good feeling about him. 

Was part of the quartet that blew Port aside in the last quarter at Frankston before the bye. An impressive cameo 🤞on more to come consistently.

[Roost it far 8,634]

1 hour ago, dazzledavey36 said:

If people think Schache is soft who lacks physical presence then they're going to get a rude shock watching Fullarton play..

I watched him play and kept hoping it wasn’t so. I say play him in the big league and see what occurs.

[loges 6,767]

1 hour ago, dazzledavey36 said:

If people think Schache is soft who lacks physical presence then they're going to get a rude shock watching Fullarton play..

Not possible that there's anyone softer, never seen anyone in 60 years watching football.

[dazzledavey36 55,361]

1 hour ago, Neil Crompton said:

I’d prefer to blood Verrall rather than Fullarton as I believe he has a far greater upside. I also believe he has been more consistent at Casey than Fullarton. 

So would I and as you say, has been for more consistent then Verrall as per the VFL player by player confirms.

[M_9 2,091]

25 minutes ago, loges said:

Not possible that there's anyone softer [than Schache], never seen anyone in 60 years watching football.

Four games* for us, 14 disposals, 4 tackles, 2 hit outs, 1 goal. We've played a man short in those four games.

Unused sub in one game.

Edited April 22 by M_9

[Dee Zephyr 19,269]

4 minutes ago, M_9 said:

Four games for us, 14 disposals, 4 tackles, 2 hit outs, 1 goal. We've played a man short in those four games.

In fairness, two of those games he’s played a total of 20 mins (sub)

[Fat Tony 5,273]

I would bring in Kossie, Hunter & Turner for Tholstrup, Salem & Brown.

Windsor to shift to half back in place of Salem and Hunter to come in on the left wing.

Kossie for Tholstrup is straight forward.

Turner could play at either end. If he plays back, Rivers would play in the midfield, and we have a taller defence. (Sparrow and Petracca play more minutes forward.) If Turner play forwards, it is straight forward in place of Brown.

Woewodin the poor old sub again.