14 minutes ago, Dee Zephyr said:

Is this show on the road yet?

go to fox footy

seems mfc has gone to adrian anderson to advocate - g-d only knows why. can't we get a better advocate?

14 minutes ago, Dee Zephyr said:

Is this show on the road yet?

Rolling live blog here:
https://www.foxsports.com.au/afl/teams/melbourne-demons/afl-2024-kysaiah-pickett-tribunal-live-updates-blog-kozzie-pickett-bump-on-jake-soligo-in-melbourne-vs-adelaide-video/news-story/6c6dcfd72100dc3a736379137bfb30ef

Most recent three updates...
 

Quote

I will try break this down as best I can.

 

The Dees are arguing this is rough conduct but not a bump.

 

Basically, they argue impact should not have been upgraded based on potential to cause injury because it does not qualify as a bump in their view.

 

Quote

We have spent the last 40 minutes debating whether we allow evidence from a Professor Cole. The Tribunal finds it will not have a meaningful impact on the crux of this case.

 

Effectively, these first 40 minutes have been a prelude.

 

Quote

Lisa Hannon (AFL): The act of jumping to smother ... carried not only the inherent risk of head high contact, but real potential to cause injury.

 

 

Not going well is my between the lines read

Why do we keep using Lionel Hutz (Adrian Anderson)? He is useless.

3 minutes ago, daisycutter said:

go to fox footy

seems mfc has gone to adrian anderson to advocate - g-d only knows why. can't we get a better advocate?

I assume Anderson got JVR and/or Fritta off as i couldn’t imagine why they’d go back to him otherwise.

Not how I would have gone about it. 

We have totally PAAAARKEED THIS UP! For caaaryst sake, go for LOW IMPACT!! Sheeeit how are we so bloody dense!!

Kozzy’s bump is medium impact and Toby Greene‘s dangerous tackle on Mac Andrew is absolutely fine? Given the player who Kozzy tackled wasn’t injured and played on, I assume Kozzy’s tackle was deemed medium impact due to the potential to cause injury. Based on this, then surely Greene’s tackle on Mac Andrew also has the potential to cause serious injury and he should have been suspended? 

Edited April 9, 20241 yr by Ethan Tremblay

Just now, picket fence said:

We have totally PAAAARKEED THIS UP! For caaaryst sake, go for LOW IMPACT!! Sheeeit how are we so bloody dense!!

they know any head contact will automatically be medium

so giving this a crack. [censored] all chance but

LOW IMPACT 

LOW IMPACT 

SOLIGO GETS UP 

LOW IMPACT 

LOW IMPACT 

that’s the song… its a simple chorus 

ffs 

who’s our advocate? Crusty the clown 

2 minutes ago, DubDee said:

they know any head contact will automatically be medium

so giving this a crack. [censored] all chance but

Yep

Maynard strikes again

Ironic doesn't cut it

1 minute ago, DubDee said:

they know any head contact will automatically be medium

so giving this a crack. [censored] all chance but

Question. Head contact. Why no HIA by the Crows on Soligo ?? Isn’t that mandatory.  Why not? Because it was farknnnn low impact !!!!  

5 minutes ago, DubDee said:

they know any head contact will automatically be medium

so giving this a crack. [censored] all chance but

Are you saying that IN EVERY INSTANCE, Any impact to the head is now graded as Medium??? Seriously, the game is turning into Pickelball, or Dueling Crotchet needles, what a FARCE! it also means ANY head contact is now reportable even flicking a mosquito of an opponents brow.

HOW PAARKING AFL! 

Edited April 9, 20241 yr by picket fence

2 minutes ago, spirit of norm smith said:

Question. Head contact. Why no HIA by the Crows on Soligo ?? Isn’t that mandatory.  Why not? Because it was farknnnn low impact !!!!  

Can we quickly zoom you in ? Let’s give AA the boot.

24 minutes ago, daisycutter said:

go to fox footy

seems mfc has gone to adrian anderson to advocate - g-d only knows why. can't we get a better advocate?

I would have gone for Groucho Marx!

8 minutes ago, picket fence said:

Are you saying that IN EVERY INSTANCE, Any impact to the head is now graded as Medium??? Seriously, the game is turning into Pickelball, or Dueling Crotchet needles, what a FARCE! it also means ANY head contact is now reportable even flicking a mosquito of an opponents brow.

HOW PAARKING AFL! 

any reportable instance yes

not that i agree at all

I know I know. It was Soligo's fault!!!

Kozzy gets off :)

 

For those not following...
 

Quote

Lisa Hannon (AFL): The act of jumping to smother ... carried not only the inherent risk of head high contact, but real potential to cause injury.

Hannon (AFL) says a combination of force, body positioning of Pickett at moment of impact and genuine potential to cause injury should see this graded 'medium' impact.

Anderson (Dees) says Pickett decelerates as he jumps for the ball and it is "a much less significant impact as a result."

Anderson (Dees) notes Pickett's fist wasn't clenched at the moment of impact, which is not consistent with a decision to bump.

Lachie Fogarty has in fact appeared at tonight's Tribunal, via vision of Jack Viney's bump on him from the 2023 Semi-Final.

The Tribunal is now deliberating.

 

 

Edited April 9, 20241 yr by JTR
nvm - DL beat me to it

Not a chance he is getting off 

If Kosi gets off I’ll eat my hat 

 

3 minutes ago, JTR said:

For those not following...
 

 

 

So you are now not allowed to leave the ground to attempt to smother a handball or kick ? Wtf  this getting ridiculous 

1 minute ago, Sydee said:

So you are now not allowed to leave the ground to attempt to smother a handball or kick ? Wtf  this getting ridiculous 

You can do what you want but if you make contact to the head you are [censored]