PREGAME: Rd 09 vs Hawthorn

[bing181 8,258]

Petty down back. Apart from anything else, May seems to play better when he’s down there, and frees up Lever to be an interceptor. Turner will get his chance. 

[drysdale demon 4,227]

2 hours ago, deejammin' said:

He did, against the Saints. He then waited the better part of a year and a half for his next game though. I like Turner but if we’re playing him as a key he’s not ready yet and undersized, he plays better as a second or third KPD, even in the VFL Tomlinson takes the largest forward . Especially when we have a premiership KPD to play there in Petty., it’s not Turner’s time yet. 

I agree that  Turner will be better playing a flanker role and could be a chance to take Hibberd's spot, I also think he will get more oppurtunities this year.

Petty made his debut in round 15 2018, got dropped and then played 10 games in 2019, forward and back, he also won the Harold Ball Memorial Trophy in that year, didn't play at all in 2000 so I am assuming he was injured.

[Roost it far 6,250]

16 hours ago, Glorious Day said:

I was a massive fan of getting Hunter in. Thought he’d be pivotal on the ‘other’ wing. Aside from a few moments here and there this season, he’s looked slow, cannot get enough penetration on his kicks and makes poor decisions too often putting team members under unnecessary pressure. I hope this doesn’t become the norm - that we are dealing with a very limited player, rather than one I expected would make a tangible difference.

As I’ve said repeatedly, we need to use our squad rather than playing the same blokes week in and week out. If any of our guns need a rest, next week is the week to do it. It’s a very long season. 

I’d love them to play Spargo on the wing for a few weeks and see if he can’t run all day. His kicking is excellent 

[At the break of Gawn 3,723]

In: BB

Out: Turner

Spargo to be the sub.

Edited May 7, 2023 by At the break of Gawn

[Slartibartfast 16,041]

4 hours ago, drysdale demon said:

, didn't play at all in 2000 so I am assuming he was injured.

Or perhaps not born. 😀

[JimmyGadson 3,455]

Three things I'd like to see from three different individuals. 

May to either play with condifence and keep his [censored] feet. 

Clarry to take a couple of seconds to realise he has time to dispose of the ball with more care. It's killing. 

Lever to stop turning the ball over out of D-50 as he does it multiple times a game. 

No injuries, bring the same level of intensity and we'll win by 50+

[Binmans PA 26,564]

The way Fritsch plays annoys me (I think) as much as @DeeSpencer, but the way he plays is what it is. He's a star and he's never going to be dropped, because he'll usually hit the scoreboard and is a game breaker.

However, your suggestion for Joel Smith, who I'm not a fan of, has merit this particular week and possibly the following week.

Providing the FD believe he has enough kms in the legs, I'd bring him in for JVR and send Petty behind the ball. I'd then use Smith as a defensive forward on Aliir Aliir the following week.

So Smith for JVR and I wonder if we can get Spargo in for one of our smalls that needs a rest? Otherwise, Spargo for Turner.

[Binmans PA 26,564]

5 hours ago, Roost it far said:

I’d love them to play Spargo on the wing for a few weeks and see if he can’t run all day. His kicking is excellent 

Spargo filled in on the wing quite a bit last year. I'm a big Charlie fan, but I reckon he needs to play forward of centre. The wing is too high and then occasionally too defensive for his height. It could well be exploited going back the other way.

I'd prefer we go Gus to the other wing if Hunter's spot is in jeopardy, but Lingers has struggled the last few weeks IMV, so the wing is a hard call this year.

[demosaw 879]

6 hours ago, drysdale demon said:

 

Petty ….didn't play at all in 2000 so I am assuming he was injured.

Petty would have played a fair bit in 2000 when it wasn’t naptime.

[DeeSpencer 23,510]

32 minutes ago, A F said:

The way Fritsch plays annoys me (I think) as much as @DeeSpencer, but the way he plays is what it is. He's a star and he's never going to be dropped, because he'll usually hit the scoreboard and is a game breaker.

 

Dropping him is radical, but I really think Ross Lyon would do it as he did Milne and Dal Santo one year at the Saints. 

Otherwise I think Fritsch should be constantly encouraged by whichever methods Goodwin, Stafford, Choco and co have to become a more rounded player. He was late to the AFL system and is only 26, there's no reason why he shouldn't be still improving. And to be fair to him I think he has made some ground this year. Disposals and tackles are both marginally up, goal assists are improving. I just think he can be so much more than what he already is which is clearly a very good player.

[drysdale demon 4,227]

7 hours ago, demosaw said:

Petty would have played a fair bit in 2000 when it wasn’t naptime.

Yeah, 2020 sounds better.

[drysdale demon 4,227]

9 hours ago, Slartibartfast said:

Or perhaps not born. 😀

He may have been swimming around in his Dad's sack then but.

[Jaded No More 59,362]

7 hours ago, DeeSpencer said:

Dropping him is radical, but I really think Ross Lyon would do it as he did Milne and Dal Santo one year at the Saints. 

Otherwise I think Fritsch should be constantly encouraged by whichever methods Goodwin, Stafford, Choco and co have to become a more rounded player. He was late to the AFL system and is only 26, there's no reason why he shouldn't be still improving. And to be fair to him I think he has made some ground this year. Disposals and tackles are both marginally up, goal assists are improving. I just think he can be so much more than what he already is which is clearly a very good player.

Ross Lyon is who we are taking advice from now? 

Fritta is not getting dropped ffs. 

[rpfc 27,646]

If we didn’t drop Fritsch in the last few years with his tepid defensive efforts we certainly aren’t going to do it now he is in our top 10 players. 

I think he has been a lot better in that regard FWIW.

[Lampers 563]

17 hours ago, leave it to deever said:

I don't think it is and I don't think the rules have changed. If you feign a handball it should still be ok and not play on. 

One thing that irked me was twice I think the umps seem to force us to take the advantage which wasn't there.

I heard an interview with Ray Chamberlain the other day where he explained this rule.

It should be play on as soon as a step is taken that isn’t forward or backwards on the line of the mark (i.e. a side step).

So shaping to handpass isn’t play on if the feet don’t go to the side.

The change this year is no 50 metre penalty for failing to stand if the man on the mark is momentarily fooled and moves a little due to the feigning actions of the player with the ball.

I also noticed the umpires deciding there was advantage when the Melbourne players clearly didn’t want it due to being hemmed in on the boundary with no open forward options. In some other sports the umpire or referee can wait for a few seconds to see if there actually was an advantage, and if not then blow the whistle and pay the prior penalty.

[Roost it far 6,250]

The thing with Fritsch is he’s actually a really good tackler, has really good technique. However his ability to chase, harass, bump and apply said tackle is still poor. It’s why you can’t have a 70% BBB and he in the same forward line. It’s why JVR, despite his low numbers is a better option. Still time…..

[John Demonic 4,918]

8 hours ago, DeeSpencer said:

Dropping him is radical, but I really think Ross Lyon would do it as he did Milne and Dal Santo one year at the Saints. 

Otherwise I think Fritsch should be constantly encouraged by whichever methods Goodwin, Stafford, Choco and co have to become a more rounded player. He was late to the AFL system and is only 26, there's no reason why he shouldn't be still improving. And to be fair to him I think he has made some ground this year. Disposals and tackles are both marginally up, goal assists are improving. I just think he can be so much more than what he already is which is clearly a very good player.

Yeah but would Clarko have dropped Gunston for Billy Hartung to add some forward pressure?

[layzie 29,943]

10 minutes ago, Roost it far said:

The thing with Fritsch is he’s actually a really good tackler, has really good technique. However his ability to chase, harass, bump and apply said tackle is still poor. It’s why you can’t have a 70% BBB and he in the same forward line. It’s why JVR, despite his low numbers is a better option. Still time…..

The JVR incident is actually the perfect example of why he's there. It's otherwise a routine defensive mark for the opposition and here comes the kid out of no-where making something happen out of nothing. It's been so good to have. 

[DemonWA 3,550]

15 hours ago, Roost it far said:

I’d love them to play Spargo on the wing for a few weeks and see if he can’t run all day. His kicking is excellent 

Does he have a long enough dump kick though? 

 

I feel like people are very quick to turn on Hunter. Hs having a good season, with aspects of his game to work on like the majority of the 22. 

[layzie 29,943]

34 minutes ago, DemonWA said:

Does he have a long enough dump kick though? 

 

I feel like people are very quick to turn on Hunter. Hs having a good season, with aspects of his game to work on like the majority of the 22. 

Yeah little surprised with the Hunter bashing at the moment. 

[Bring-Back-Powell 13,477]

In - BBB, Hibberd

Out - JVR, Turner

Thought Turner settled well after a shaky start and was a bit stiff to be subbed. However I assume he was warming the seat for Hibberd.

Spargo would have to be extremely close but you couldn't drop Chandler off one quiet game.

Maybe JJ goes out for Spargo, with the former being on the edge of selection all year.

Glad we have Hawthorn this week rather than Port (which will be a early-mid season litmus test/audit for us). The weekend was a taxing game and 4 interstate trips in 8 weeks is a lot for a VIC side. Compare that to St Kilda who have travelled just once, and that one game was at a neutral venue against Collingwood.

 

[mauriesy 6,863]

3 hours ago, drysdale demon said:

He may have been swimming around in his Dad's sack then but.

He was 5 months old at the start of the 2000 season.

[sisso 2,412]

1 hour ago, layzie said:

Yeah little surprised with the Hunter bashing at the moment. 

Me too, there's a small article in the paper about how much his run is contributing to our winning last quarters - he may not have pace but he has great endurance and doesn't stop running

[Docs Demons 1,676]

10 minutes ago, sisso said:

Me too, there's a small article in the paper about how much his run is contributing to our winning last quarters - he may not have pace but he has great endurance and doesn't stop running

And his kicking is top notch. Was at the game Saturday and thought he played OK. His pass in front of us to JVR was perfect only for JVR to spill the chess mark. Thought Hunter was better than Langers and IMV will stay in the side. 

[Orion 332]

IN:  Brown, Spargo

OUT:  Turner, JVR

Petty back and we play a smaller more dynamic forward line

Edited May 8, 2023 by Orion