Trade Rumours 2023

[dl4e 5,642]

This McKay situation is beyond a joke.

[DeeSpencer 23,380]

12 minutes ago, spirit of norm smith said:

Yes they will have around 14 1st round picks if they add/hold the current selections (11 currently after removing Cunnington and Ziebell). That’s a huge group of talent to develop over the next 2-3 years.  AFL might have to say sorry to other clubs in a few years. They’re good at apologizing 🤯🤯🤯

With GC having:

18: Luko, King (Rankine)
19: Rowell, Anderson, Flanders
20: (Hollands?), *Davies, Jeffrey*
21: Andrew
22: Humphrey
23: Walter, Read, Rogers
24: Likely at least 3 more 

Its going to be fun watching North and GC grand finals in 5 years time. 

[binman 39,016]

3 hours ago, Sydee said:

Welcome to the NMFC Harley Reid 

All part of the plan.

The conspiracy theorist in me thinks back to the remarkable scenario with both the Roos and Eagles WINNING late season games that no-one would have begrudged them losing to secure pick one. In fact they both received some heat for WINNING and risking losing access to pick one and Harley Reid.

At the time felt like a back room deal between headquarters and both clubs to avoid the inevitable tanking fugazi.

Something like 'play games out, win if you can and we'll sort out a draft pick scenario, most likely involving pick three for McKay, where both clubs are happy. Roos you will get pick one and Harley Reid if you want him, but you will need to sweeten the Eagles draft hand so they can get who they want' 

Nothing that has happened since suggests the above scenario is fanciful.

Edited October 10, 2023 by binman

[Roy Boy 340]

Not a rumour, but would you look at Ginnivan?

With Schultz coming into Pies, could be offloaded.

I think he is a dangerous player, a bit divisive, but…..

I wouldn’t object if price was right.

[Nascent 7,406]

Trade radio stating Melbourne had "mild" interest in Billings.

Doesn't sound significant and was played down

[Gawndy the Great 7,667]

9 minutes ago, Roy Boy said:

Not a rumour, but would you look at Ginnivan?

With Schultz coming into Pies, could be offloaded.

I think he is a dangerous player, a bit divisive, but…..

I wouldn’t object if price was right.

If he is on the outer with CFC and their culture, then no. He is overrated anyway and played up by the media given the association with Collingwood. He's probably on par with Chandler.

[Demon Dynasty 15,869]

4 hours ago, Lucifers Hero said:

As an aside, for those that think all AFL players are highly paid take note of the offer to Koschitzke!!

I'd gladly hire a make up artist and put a torso muscle suit on for a year LH if someone offered me that sorta coin!

I limit it to a year as i'd probably end up spending most of it in hospital recovering from various things or being conpletely rebuilt a la Steve Austin (actor not wrestler)

[Garbo 1,347]

12 minutes ago, Roy Boy said:

Not a rumour, but would you look at Ginnivan?

With Schultz coming into Pies, could be offloaded.

I think he is a dangerous player, a bit divisive, but…..

I wouldn’t object if price was right.

Nope he has the talent but not the commitment to be a professional sports person. We already have Spargo and Chandler who I much prefer over him

[DubDee 21,230]

4 hours ago, Mach5 said:

Once more in english?

oh man. too late to edit. can only blame autocorrect for so much!

player good. i like

[Demon Dynasty 15,869]

2 hours ago, Jaded No More said:

Tell me the AFL would bend over backwards for North in this matter if Clarkson wasn’t their coach. Laughable. 

 

2 hours ago, DeeSpencer said:

Look at the excuses they gave for turning us down in 13 and 14.

In fact in 14 we were right in line with North, and the afl said, you’re getting free agent compo, you’ve got young talent (we had stuff all), you’ve traded for veterans (which actually hurt our future) and you’ve got Roos and Goodwin coming.

Would be so easy for the afl to say ‘you’ve got Clarko, deal with it’.

The response is - ‘you’ve got Clarko…let’s help him so he doesn’t quit mid season again’

Exactly what i was thinking this morning.

Amazing what a diff a name (with connections/cred) can do

[Garbo 1,347]

10 minutes ago, Nascent said:

Trade radio stating Melbourne had "mild" interest in Billings.

Doesn't sound significant and was played down

Billings is the definition of an almost player, almost kicked the goal, almost won the game. If things clicked he would be a great pickup but would anything change if he played for us.

[Demon Dynasty 15,869]

2 hours ago, BangBnagBang said:

id have the following in front of Mckay as a KPD.

Moore

Weitering

SDK

Taylor

Andrews

Aliir

Wilkie

May

McGoverm

Barrass

Pearce

Cox

Collins

McCartin

Petty

Lever

Balata

Jones

Doedee

Payne

 

 

Bah!  Where's Frosty!??

[david_neitz_is_my_dad 3,945]

21 minutes ago, Roy Boy said:

Not a rumour, but would you look at Ginnivan?

I wouldn't clap his goals

[Demon Dynasty 15,869]

2 hours ago, DeeSpencer said:

It’s either incompetence or deliberate. With the afl it’s hard to know which

I know which one i'm choosing

[adonski 9,265]

2 hours ago, DistrACTION Jackson said:

Given the amount of talent the Roos are bringing in, especially in the midfield I hope we are getting in the ear of someone like Will Phillips.

Hasn't quite come on early in his career and if they have so many high draft picks trying to get a game he may look to move.

Good mates with Bailey Laurie as well I think.

It's a good idea in theory but unfortunately he doesn't look very good

[dazzledavey36 49,168]

24 minutes ago, Nascent said:

Trade radio stating Melbourne had "mild" interest in Billings.

Doesn't sound significant and was played down

Did they stay further whether there was still interest?

[ChaserJ 3,994]

Sam Edmund & Morris saying Harmes is a good chance to be at the Dogs by the end of the day.

[dazzledavey36 49,168]

3 minutes ago, ChaserJ said:

Sam Edmund & Morris saying Harmes is a good chance to be at the Dogs by the end of the day.

Picks?

[dazzledavey36 49,168]

 

[Demon Jack 6,386]

3 minutes ago, dazzledavey36 said:

Did they stay further whether there was still interest?

Think I read that they mentioned that the interest was there last week, but they're unsure if we're still keen.

 

[ChaserJ 3,994]

3 minutes ago, dazzledavey36 said:

Picks?

Not speculated on at this stage.

[spirit of norm smith 13,283]

Harmesy. 😭😭😭we still love you. Best wishes. 
 

Billings. F&))& No.  
Ginnivan. Absolutely F&)&?!&n No. 

IMV they are not the type of players that we need.  

Ps. The famous Jack Ginnivan “No” gif will reappear if this type of mild interest in such players continues. 

[mo64 5,233]

1 hour ago, DeeSpencer said:

With GC having:

18: Luko, King (Rankine)
19: Rowell, Anderson, Flanders
20: (Hollands?), *Davies, Jeffrey*
21: Andrew
22: Humphrey
23: Walter, Read, Rogers
24: Likely at least 3 more 

Its going to be fun watching North and GC grand finals in 5 years time. 

For balance, how about naming all the 1st round draftees that GC have lost over the years? Off the top of my head Lynch, Prestia, Caddy, May, Wright, Brodie, and I'm sure there's others. 

[Nascent 7,406]

12 minutes ago, dazzledavey36 said:

Did they stay further whether there was still interest?

They described our interest as both mild and bland. Bland referring to level of "spice" for a reference scale. Seem to downplay it as unlikely from my interpretation.

However when listening it did sort of give me Lachie Hunter vibes when his name first popped up last year. I'd still keep a watch for it.

 

[mo64 5,233]

I like Harmesy, and I hope he has as distinguished career at the Dogs as Mitch Hannan.