Why do we need to replace JVR with a tall? Smith and McDonald are the talls, get smith to play on Weitering and Petracca spends 50% forward. Jordan replaces Brayshaw, and spargo comes in.. god knows we need his ball use

Edited September 9, 20232 yr by watchtheeyes

2 minutes ago, watchtheeyes said:

Why do we need to replace JVR with a tall? ...

We need a second ruck. TMac is useless (IMO) as a second ruck. Smith has never rucked to my knowledge.

Grundy's stats not all that bad. Same number of goals as Max (10).

	GM	K	HB	D	M	G	GA	B	T	HO	FF	FA	CL	CG	I50	R50	AF	SC
Total	17	100	143	243	46	10	3	4	49	349	29	29	50	59	46	12	1,275	1,466
Average	17	5.9	8.4	14.3	2.7	0.6	0.2	0.2	2.9	20.5	1.7	1.7	2.9	3.5	2.7	0.7	75.0	86.2

24 minutes ago, watchtheeyes said:

Why do we need to replace JVR with a tall? Smith and McDonald are the talls, get smith to play on Weitering and Petracca spends 50% forward. Jordan replaces Brayshaw, and spargo comes in.. god knows we need his ball use

Spargo to ruck?

3 minutes ago, Jaded No More said:

Spargo to ruck?

Fair point.. hadn’t thought about the ruck. Can smith go in there and effectively play as an extra midfielder?

4 minutes ago, watchtheeyes said:

Fair point.. hadn’t thought about the ruck. Can smith go in there and effectively play as an extra midfielder?

No. Also, he isn’t a midfielder. 

Just spitballing solutions at this point.. Grundy just isn’t the answer, and putting Disco forward is just panicking 

The Gawn/Grundy combo actually worked brilliantly in the pre season game at Casey and round 1 v Dogs  if anyone remembers that long back 

5 minutes ago, watchtheeyes said:

Fair point.. hadn’t thought about the ruck. Can smith go in there and effectively play as an extra midfielder?

I wouldn't be using a finals game to find out if Joel Smith has any knowledge of ruck play!

We're yet to decide if he's best as a forward or back.

Grundy plays as a ruck rover, not unlike an older version of Luke Jackson. I reckon he'd be champing at the bit to play against the Pies on the big stage. He'd wipe Pittonet and De Konning and Oscar (if we go to Brisbane).

He had 45 hitouts in his one game v the Lions.

Sydney the new front runner.

 

Play Grundy in the ruck as he’s great as an extra mid when the ball hits the deck ala Luke Jackson. Let him and Max share the ground. He has to come in, there’s no one else

11 minutes ago, dazzledavey36 said:

Sydney the new front runner.

 

and we get ???????

Just now, beelzebub said:

and we get ???????

Either pick 21 or pick 29

1 minute ago, dazzledavey36 said:

Either pick 21 or pick 29

I want steak knives too.

Port and Swans can do better ;)

3 minutes ago, dazzledavey36 said:

Either pick 21 or pick 29

I would be ok with pick 21. 

On 9/1/2023 at 7:12 PM, Supreme_Demon said:

Saw that on TV as well.

Let's possibly entertain this idea.

The problem for Port Adelaide is what do they have to offer? They have no draft picks worth offering. What players could they even offer?

Brodie Grundy has a 4 year contract with the Demons.

We would be asking for Josh Sinn, Miles Bergman, Ollie Lord or someone of decent quality and talent.

I just hope that the Demons drive a very hard bargain.....IF....a trade does possibly happen (which I hope it doesn't).

 

Dees should demand Josh Sinn in return and pick swaps.  If they are serious about desperately wanting Grundy, they should be prepared to deal.  

We have nearly broken this guy but now we all need to build him up to play the game of his life for the team and his own esteem. Time to worry about 2024 later. Go Grundy

33 minutes ago, beelzebub said:

and we get ???????

Straight swap for Dyl Stephens?

1 hour ago, beelzebub said:

and we get ???????

Our sizeable share of his contract off our books?

I for one hope like hell Grundy comes in, just don't make Max change his game, Grundy does what Jackson used to do and you know what, he's a quality footballer too and can still move well enough and he should be in there.  Makes sense, second ruck, can still kind of play like a big mid fielder, c'mon stop the haters Grundy is great he's just had a bunch of crappy games but did we lose those games because of the ruck?  Or because we just played a bit [censored] and couldn't kick goals hmmm? 

We are going to need Brodie Grundy this week against the Blues.

Fingers crossed we can finally make the duo ruck combination work! 🤞

11 hours ago, rpfc said:

Grundy should come in and share ruck duties.
Gawn was immense in the ruck. But now he has to sacrifice for the team to get the most out of someone else possibly at the (hopefully minor) expense of his own game.

Can he do it? From his rhetoric, he will ask Goodwin for Grundy to play - I just hope he knows that what that means for him. 

Those that want the Grundy Experiment to continue into next year - this is it, and it is on Max to make it work.

Bridge

Water ->

3 minutes ago, Supreme_Demon said:

We are going to need Brodie Grundy this week against the Blues.

Fingers crossed we can finally make the duo ruck combination work! 🤞

I think we need to stop framing it as a "ruck combo", Grundy is just a decent player and I want him on the team.

11 minutes ago, old55 said:

Bridge

Water ->

The rest of that water is coming fast…

2 minutes ago, rpfc said:

The rest of that water is coming fast…

We are paddling upstream now

2 hours ago, Roost it far said:

Play Grundy in the ruck as he’s great as an extra mid when the ball hits the deck ala Luke Jackson. Let him and Max share the ground. He has to come in, there’s no one else

About time someone started making sense around here. The solution lies in plain sight. And if sonething did click, it could be the catalyst that we so absolutely need at this moment.