53 minutes ago, stinga said:

Is there a rule that says the players listed in the published positions on the field must be part of the final squad?   In other words can say Oliver be left out of the final squad and 5 of the so called interchange are then included instead of 4.

i think teams playing on sunday who are forced to nominate a team on thursday have a bit more leeway for changes

our team tonight would have more stringent conditions

45 minutes ago, Dannyz said:

Dunstan is in

Had 32 and a goal plus got the 3 brownlow votes against them last year for the saints, so if he can have that impact he's welcome! 

2 hours ago, Brownie said:

Melksham was really quiet in the VFL last week.

Bedford ran and went in really hard last week. He should come in if needed.

He's been quiet in all the VFL games he's played this year.

It's a joke that he's even under consideration. 

2 hours ago, Brownie said:

Melksham was really quiet in the VFL last week.

Bedford ran and went in really hard last week. He should come in if needed.

Melksham had a pretty good game actually. These were his numbers (thanks KC):

• Jake Melksham: 1 behind 12 kicks 9 handballs 21 disposals 8 marks 4 tackles 80 dream team points

They are pretty good numbers, and the coaching staff would be rapt with 4 tackles as the defensive stuff is his big weakness. 

For comparison purposes here are Dunstan's numbers:

• Luke Dunstan 1 goal 11 kicks 10 handballs 21 disposals 3 marks 3 tackles 81 dream team points

I only really watched the first quarter (and bits an pieces of other qs) and thought he played really well in that quarter. He was our leading possession winner at the end of it, with 8 possessions, his intensity was pretty good, he was very team orientated, and his skills in super windy conditions were sublime. he looked a class above VFL level. 

It's why i predicted, accurately as it turns out, he would be on the extended interchange list this week - though i very much doubt he will be selected.

The fact he has been selected on on the extended interchange list this week should be read as affirmation by Goody that he is well and truly on the right track. I think there is a pretty good chance, if he keeps on that track, he'll get call up to the seniors at some point.  

Edited April 22, 20223 yr by binman

4 hours ago, D4Life said:

We need a vote from all Demonlanders on whether we should auction or go to private sale for the Weridee Mansion!

Proceeds to Demonland to spend on new servers, then acquire a venue for Demonland social club, that can be loaned to MFC!

TMac obviously picked to play Pickett fast running elusive forward flank role, can just see him zipping in and under picking up all Weids  crumbs, and kicking 8!

Can we hold of coz I now can put four Green Townhouses on it., Wait... no I got enough money to plonk a Red Hotel on it straight away and charge anyone who lands on it TOP DOLLAR. Just one question Werridee, what color street should I designate your house on the DEMONOPOLY BOARD?? I can reveal that Uncle Bitter thinks his Manor the Equivalent of Mayfair, but I remain just a tad skeptical! I am Uh also interested in selling a Magnificent parcel of land right on Casey Feilds. In fact it is the same spot behind the fence that I do my training reports from. It would be designated as Old Kent Rd on the DEEMONOPOLY board but I'll take an offer!?

Edited April 22, 20223 yr by picket fence

1 hour ago, Dannyz said:

Dunstan is in

Great. He has to give 100% 

Opportunities in the middle are limited. 
 

26 minutes ago, dazzledavey36 said:

He's been quiet in all the VFL games he's played this year.

It's a joke that he's even under consideration. 

Maybe he is playing a defined role that he will replicate in the seniors?

1 hour ago, WERRIDEE said:

Brown should they wont

No he shouldn’t. He is an established senior player who was a performer in a premiership 6 games ago. I don’t know why you are so obtuse and naive with Brown. 

19 hours ago, picket fence said:

Correct so the inters will be Harmes, Jacko, Sparrow and JJ with DUNSTAN to be medi sub!

If the 18 selected are locks for a game and if Dunstan is in as iterated then this bench plus Sub is viable, although I would have thought that Kossy who was brilliant last week stays, Jacko is a given, J.J Played a blinder game before last and Sparrow solid. I now think that if Dunstan is in Sparrow might revert to super medi Sub!

21 minutes ago, rpfc said:

No he shouldn’t. He is an established senior player who was a performer in a premiership 6 games ago. I don’t know why you are so obtuse and naive with Brown. 

BBB plays. I have a reliable source.

And so he should. He is an incredibly talented player who North lost their minds and let go.

He has also added contested marking to his game and no longer needs to always lead into space to mark. 

Last year we saw him come close to what made him top the H and A goal scoring 3 years in a row in a bottom team.

I also think he will get better and we may get another six years out of him and perhaps with our great midfield he will win a Coleman in the not too distant future.

Edited April 22, 20223 yr by leave it to deever

7 pages in, different starting 18 on the AFL website and MFC website, and we won't really know till 5PM.

Much as all basketball matches should start at 90 all and 2 minutes to go, I'm starting to think selections threads should start on the day the real team is released with only hours to go.

1 hour ago, rpfc said:

Maybe he is playing a defined role that he will replicate in the seniors?

Having watched those VFL games he's played he's cooked mate.

Fumbles, got caught with the ball at times and lazy with his defensive ability. 

The likes of Chandler, Bedford, Laurie are ahead of him in terms of forms from the VFL games I've seen.

2 hours ago, Dannyz said:

Dunstan is in

I'm excited.

3 minutes ago, dazzledavey36 said:

I'm excited.

Tx Big Kev.

As long as our lucky charm in  Bowey plays,  then so am I.

20 minutes ago, dazzledavey36 said:

I'm excited.

Well if ever he has a chance with Viney out it is NOW. No pressure to perform, much.😬

If Dunstan is playing another player is out of the side the bloke said he is playing he will be in the 22 I doubt he will be the sub as most subs don’t play like Bedford who has played 1 out of 5

56 minutes ago, dazzledavey36 said:

 

The likes of Chandler, Bedford, Laurie are ahead of him in terms of forms from the VFL games I've seen.

 

Agree Bedford is ahead of him, as evidenced by the fact he is the go to medi sub.

But you'd have to think he is ahead of Laurie and Chandler as evidenced by the fact he was in the emergencies two weeks ago and will also be an emergency this week.

As far as I recall neither Laurie or Chandler have been emergencies.

No way goody names him on the extended bench this week if he has been playing as badly as you make out.

18 minutes ago, WERRIDEE said:

If Dunstan is playing another player is out of the side the bloke said he is playing he will be in the 22 I doubt he will be the sub as most subs don’t play like Bedford who has played 1 out of 5

Dunstan, BB & Smith in 

2 hours ago, picket fence said:

Can we hold of coz I now can put four Green Townhouses on it., Wait... no I got enough money to plonk a Red Hotel on it straight away and charge anyone who lands on it TOP DOLLAR. Just one question Werridee, what color street should I designate your house on the DEMONOPOLY BOARD?? I can reveal that Uncle Bitter thinks his Manor the Equivalent of Mayfair, but I remain just a tad skeptical! I am Uh also interested in selling a Magnificent parcel of land right on Casey Feilds. In fact it is the same spot behind the fence that I do my training reports from. It would be designated as Old Kent Rd on the DEEMONOPOLY board but I'll take an offer!?

DO NOT PASS GO picket ! ........ you know the rest of it.

Sportsbet

have Viney.   Lever

and K. Pickett.  Out

Pickett from tigers out as well 

Dunstan debuts and T Mac axed..

Edited April 22, 20223 yr by Bring-Back-Powell

McDonald dropped!

3 hours ago, daisycutter said:

i think teams playing on sunday who are forced to nominate a team on thursday have a bit more leeway for changes

our team tonight would have more stringent conditions

Thanks.

Finally the M E T A Melbourne forward line combo get a gig together