Every Heart Beats True Documentary

[Sydney_Demon 1,175]

The documentary was OK IMV but not brilliant. I guess they were hamstrung by the 75 minute length. You'd probably need a 4-parter to do justice to the last 57 years of history.

I liked the idea but personally would have preferred say 3 episodes of history with the  last episode focusing on 2021. They clearly had a narrative in mind and selected the bits to feature to fit the narrative. Haven't we all seen enough of the Norm Smith Curse and Jimmy running over the mark in 1987? They should be included in the back story but shouldn't be the entirety (along with the non-merger). If they're going to include Michael Hibberd's personal tragedy at least do it a bit of justice rather than just throwing it in for 30 seconds on the assumption that everybody already knows about it. I would have thought Troy Broadbridge's death was at least as worthy of inclusion.

What I liked:
- inclusion of some key events
- Robbie Flower & Jim Stynes' prominence
- some balance to the merger coverage (especially liked the fact that Ian Ridley was portrayed as being the great club man he actually was)
- the Vineys

What I didn't like:
- simplistic portrayal of history. You'd think that the entire 23 years on non-finals between 1964 & 1987 was due to Norm Smith being sacked. In reality it was largely due to zoning favouring the bigger clubs
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Zoning_(Australian_rules_football)
- where was the just-missed finals year of 1976? 
- nothing about all the great players of the era (except Jim Stynes, Robbie Flower)
- as mentioned by others, no coverage of the earlier finals massacres of North & Sydney in 1987
- no coverage of the good years post-1988 to 2006, other than 2000 (Melbourne made Finals 12 out of 20 years). We beat Adelaide, the eventual premiers, first round of finals in 1998. 1994 Finals. The amazing Semi Final against Adelaide in 2002.
- a focus on the record losses against Fitzroy & Geelong but no nuance. Yes, we were horrible defensively when Dean Bailey was coach but we had some great wins. IMV he shouldn't have been sacked largely because of one record loss (we were 6 points outside the 8 even after that loss, and then lost 4 of our last 5 under Todd Viney) 
- 2018. We had 2 great finals wins against Geelong & Hawthorn but apparently the only think that counts is the 1st half against West Coast in the Prelim
- Garry Lyon. I love Garry but is is actually possible to watch some Melbourne history without him being the expert? Like the  Premiminary Final. Apparently we can't just enjoy the game. The camera has to show Garry Lyons' reactions like they're in some way meaningful

In summary it annoys me that there is this false story of 57 years of misery between 1964 & 2021. In reality we had 23 years pre-1987 and then another 8 post-2006 (by 2015 we were clearly on the improve). We were wildly inconsistent within seasons and from one season to the next but with a bit of luck could definitely have won a premiership. Naturally none of this was communicated in the documentary. 

[rpfc 28,263]

Garry was a vessel for the fans that couldn’t make it and I will always remember vicariously living through him and him continuously sharing his experiences in those few weeks. 

He is also so well spoken and understands big moments and can eloquently relay them in layman’s terms.

 

[Lord Nev 13,512]

7 minutes ago, Sydney_Demon said:

The documentary was OK IMV but not brilliant....

Mate. It was a short sharp production about our premiership with a bit of context to how much it meant, not a 2 hour episodes, 10 season epic on every single aspect of our history...

[praha 11,236]

9 hours ago, FlashInThePan said:

Get rid of Foxtel and spend that money on Kayo. That show (and every other show and game) available live or from the start. I still resent the money but at least with Kayo I am getting exactly what I would have wanted out of Foxtel.

I enjoy Foxtel mostly for HBO shows.

[Sydney_Demon 1,175]

18 minutes ago, Lord Nev said:

Mate. It was a short sharp production about our premiership with a bit of context to how much it meant, not a 2 hour episodes, 10 season epic on every single aspect of our history...

As I said they were constrained by the 75 minutes. Just saying the way it could have been in a perfect world. They still had time to go though that old Norm Smith curse BS and Jim Stynes 15 metre penalty for the 1,000th time, including Garry Lyon running through a non-existent countdown for dramatic effect. 

23 minutes ago, rpfc said:

Garry was a vessel for the fans that couldn’t make it and I will always remember vicariously living through him and him continuously sharing his experiences in those few weeks. 

He is also so well spoken and understands big moments and can eloquently relay them in layman’s terms.

 

I said I love Garry. And he works for Fox Footy so I understand. I just don't think he has to be the sole focus just because he was once a great Melbourne player and is well-spoken. All I'm saying is just share it around a little.

[Sir Why You Little 36,985]

Pity Darren Burgess wasn’t interviewed 

Pity Adem Yze wasn’t interviewed 

Pity Mark Williams wasn’t interviewed 

Pity Peter Jackson wasn’t interviewed 

Pity Paul Roos wasn’t interviewed 

They were the people who changed the Clubs direction last year. 
The first 30 minutes was wasted in my opinion, the last 40 minutes was very good 

 

[Sydney_Demon 1,175]

9 hours ago, FlashInThePan said:

Get rid of Foxtel and spend that money on Kayo. That show (and every other show and game) available live or from the start. I still resent the money but at least with Kayo I am getting exactly what I would have wanted out of Foxtel.

I agree with you that it's great being able to watch everything live or from the start (although I wish they's leave the scores off the top of the screen. Sometimes you accidentally get a peek). I also like the Kayo minis for when you're time-constrained or only mildly-intetested. However, it does annoy me the lack of historical content. e.g. I was goin to watch the 2 or 3 Casey games on there from 2021 to refresh myself on a couple of our developing players only to find they'd deleted that content to include a new tab for current peactice games. Plenty of room for both surely. You can go into the AFL website and get video of every match going back to 2013 if you're interested which is the way it should be with Kayo. 

[dee-tox 4,835]

Pretty stock standard docu to be fair.

Did we learn anything that regular Demon fanatics wouldn't be aware of? Probably not. Ben Brown's legs shook on the bus before the big game and Daniher told Todd Viney he had to get running fit!

I don't know why the producers didn't interview some die hard fans. I reckon Demonland's pre and post grand final threads contain some pretty amazing insights into the psyche of a Melbourne supporter. That's where the real emotional connection for a video like this would be.

[Clintosaurus 7,838]

Watching again. Just spotted Angelo in the front row during the Jimma as President part.

[Chook 15,012]

17 minutes ago, dee-tox said:

Pretty stock standard docu to be fair.

Did we learn anything that regular Demon fanatics wouldn't be aware of? Probably not. Ben Brown's legs shook on the bus before the big game and Daniher told Todd Viney he had to get running fit!

I don't know why the producers didn't interview some die hard fans. I reckon Demonland's pre and post grand final threads contain some pretty amazing insights into the psyche of a Melbourne supporter. That's where the real emotional connection for a video like this would be.

I learned that Trac is aware of the unearthly expression of steely resolve that was etched across his brow was after kicking that goal. Never seen a bloke more determined in my life.

[Fork 'em 6,983]

11 hours ago, Jaded No More said:

1000% winning a flag is way better than birthing some life sucking monster. 

Yep ... Recently I had to answer a question for some future online ID.
I couldn't find a question I liked liked until I saw "What was the best moment of your life?"

Ah easy ... "Melbourne flag" I wrote with my oldest monster peering over my shoulder.
"What? .... Not the birth of your children?" she asked horrified.

As I explained to her.
I've been waiting/hoping to see a Melbourne premiership my whole life.
Having kids was never real high on my priority list.

She knows what I'm like, has watched me roaring at games and the TV her whole life and handled it well 😅

 

Edited March 9, 2022 by Fork 'em

[DeeZone 9,690]

I loved every minute of it, can’t get enough of our club we have plumbed the depths lived in everyone else’s shadows But we have arisen from those depths. Now it is our time to shine and enjoy the sunshine take time to smell the flowers but never forget our past because that is what makes it so bloody wonderful.!!

[Dr. Gonzo 24,193]

5 hours ago, tiers said:

I heard from a good authority (ie close family member) that Norm Smith's disgust at the committee resulted from their failure to support him in legal action brought by an umpire.

Norm obviously felt that the club should support their coach in any football and match related issues and was naturally disappointed that the then committee would not. The committee failed Norm and all the supporters.

It was never the Norm Smith curse, it was always the curse of the faceless men that doomed us to 57 years of misery.

I think that was the culmination of it but the tension between Norm and the board had been brewing for a while. This issue just brought it to a head.

[Lord Nev 13,512]

This is only short (and trigger warning for the posters that need it - It quickly covers a couple of those famous losses), but really well done and has a few new insights.

https://www.afl.com.au/ondemand/stories/491019/season-final-story?episode=9&fbclid=IwAR1-44biAI8uOmjGELIxDvt48RQjerk_EgydgILoiKcGWkXKKNeb6vfGozg#season-1

Edited March 9, 2022 by Lord Nev

[Dr. Gonzo 24,193]

3 hours ago, Sydney_Demon said:

The documentary was OK IMV but not brilliant. I guess they were hamstrung by the 75 minute length. You'd probably need a 4-parter to do justice to the last 57 years of history.

I liked the idea but personally would have preferred say 3 episodes of history with the  last episode focusing on 2021. They clearly had a narrative in mind and selected the bits to feature to fit the narrative. Haven't we all seen enough of the Norm Smith Curse and Jimmy running over the mark in 1987? They should be included in the back story but shouldn't be the entirety (along with the non-merger). If they're going to include Michael Hibberd's personal tragedy at least do it a bit of justice rather than just throwing it in for 30 seconds on the assumption that everybody already knows about it. I would have thought Troy Broadbridge's death was at least as worthy of inclusion.

What I liked:
- inclusion of some key events
- Robbie Flower & Jim Stynes' prominence
- some balance to the merger coverage (especially liked the fact that Ian Ridley was portrayed as being the great club man he actually was)
- the Vineys

What I didn't like:
- simplistic portrayal of history. You'd think that the entire 23 years on non-finals between 1964 & 1987 was due to Norm Smith being sacked. In reality it was largely due to zoning favouring the bigger clubs
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Zoning_(Australian_rules_football)
- where was the just-missed finals year of 1976? 
- nothing about all the great players of the era (except Jim Stynes, Robbie Flower)
- as mentioned by others, no coverage of the earlier finals massacres of North & Sydney in 1987
- no coverage of the good years post-1988 to 2006, other than 2000 (Melbourne made Finals 12 out of 20 years). We beat Adelaide, the eventual premiers, first round of finals in 1998. 1994 Finals. The amazing Semi Final against Adelaide in 2002.
- a focus on the record losses against Fitzroy & Geelong but no nuance. Yes, we were horrible defensively when Dean Bailey was coach but we had some great wins. IMV he shouldn't have been sacked largely because of one record loss (we were 6 points outside the 8 even after that loss, and then lost 4 of our last 5 under Todd Viney) 
- 2018. We had 2 great finals wins against Geelong & Hawthorn but apparently the only think that counts is the 1st half against West Coast in the Prelim
- Garry Lyon. I love Garry but is is actually possible to watch some Melbourne history without him being the expert? Like the  Premiminary Final. Apparently we can't just enjoy the game. The camera has to show Garry Lyons' reactions like they're in some way meaningful

In summary it annoys me that there is this false story of 57 years of misery between 1964 & 2021. In reality we had 23 years pre-1987 and then another 8 post-2006 (by 2015 we were clearly on the improve). We were wildly inconsistent within seasons and from one season to the next but with a bit of luck could definitely have won a premiership. Naturally none of this was communicated in the documentary. 

It was a Fox doco not an MFC doco though. It's made for the casual footy fans not the MFC diehards.

[Dr. Gonzo 24,193]

2 hours ago, praha said:

I enjoy Foxtel mostly for HBO shows.

Get Binge and Kayo

[Colm 2,090]

25 minutes ago, Lord Nev said:

This is only short (and trigger warning for the posters that need it - It quickly covers a couple of those famous losses), but really well done and has a few new insights.

https://www.afl.com.au/ondemand/stories/491019/season-final-story?episode=9&fbclid=IwAR1-44biAI8uOmjGELIxDvt48RQjerk_EgydgILoiKcGWkXKKNeb6vfGozg#season-1

Absolutley loved that. Probably as much as last nights show and hope it fills in the gaps that others thought last nights show had. Awesome

[dazzledavey36 54,285]

28 minutes ago, Lord Nev said:

This is only short (and trigger warning for the posters that need it - It quickly covers a couple of those famous losses), but really well done and has a few new insights.

https://www.afl.com.au/ondemand/stories/491019/season-final-story?episode=9&fbclid=IwAR1-44biAI8uOmjGELIxDvt48RQjerk_EgydgILoiKcGWkXKKNeb6vfGozg#season-1

Ahh [censored].. I thought last night was good but I reckon this one is better. Wish it went longer.

The small snippets of Goody talking during the game is gold. Wish there was more of that. 

I reckon that's Gus choking back tears at the end.

[Jaded No More 68,867]

6 minutes ago, dazzledavey36 said:

Ahh [censored].. I thought last night was good but I reckon this one is better. Wish it went longer.

The small snippets of Goody talking during the game is gold. Wish there was more of that. 

I reckon that's Gus choking back tears at the end.

100% this is better. 
Viney saying to Goody “I’m so glad you came to this club. I love you”. Oh man that was emotional. 
And Kate saying to Goody “I thought”… I love her. She’s great! 

[dazzledavey36 54,285]

7 minutes ago, Jaded No More said:

100% this is better. 
Viney saying to Goody “I’m so glad you came to this club. I love you”. Oh man that was emotional. 
And Kate saying to Goody “I thought”… I love her. She’s great! 

Yep.

It's those little inside access that are seriously amazing. Goody's 3rd quarter time speech in calming the boys down with breathing exercise is priceless.

[Guest]

48 minutes ago, Lord Nev said:

This is only short (and trigger warning for the posters that need it - It quickly covers a couple of those famous losses), but really well done and has a few new insights.

https://www.afl.com.au/ondemand/stories/491019/season-final-story?episode=9&fbclid=IwAR1-44biAI8uOmjGELIxDvt48RQjerk_EgydgILoiKcGWkXKKNeb6vfGozg#season-1

Thank you sooooo much for posting this, LN!!!
I loved hearing Goody at the 3/4 time huddle, and what he was saying as he hugged JV and Kate straight after the match. (Yeah, coz I needed another reason to cry 🙃). Also interesting to hear that Tracc was told beforehand that he’d won the Norm Smith, which makes sense coz he seemed super confident it was gonna be him and almost headed for the dais before his name was even called. 😁

[Delusional demon 82 1,197]

20 minutes ago, Jaded No More said:

100% this is better. 
Viney saying to Goody “I’m so glad you came to this club. I love you”. Oh man that was emotional. 
And Kate saying to Goody “I thought”… I love her. She’s great! 

https://afl.app.link/JEbqMA0Ofob

From tonight’s season launch

What a quality leader we have at the MFC in Kate Roffey. So well spoken , it’s amazing how professional our club now collectively presents itself. 

Also the flag is now officially with us for next Wednesday night ! 

[Jibroni 4,987]

I enjoyed it, can only cover so much in an 80 minute doco.

[Guest]

28 minutes ago, Delusional demon 82 said:

https://afl.app.link/JEbqMA0Ofob

From tonight’s season launch

What a quality leader we have at the MFC in Kate Roffey. So well spoken , it’s amazing how professional our club now collectively presents itself. 

Also the flag is now officially with us for next Wednesday night ! 

… and no pre-written speech! All off the top of her head (and from the bottom of her heart). She’s the best. ❤️💙

[Rivers Run Red 187]

2 hours ago, Lord Nev said:

This is only short (and trigger warning for the posters that need it - It quickly covers a couple of those famous losses), but really well done and has a few new insights.

https://www.afl.com.au/ondemand/stories/491019/season-final-story?episode=9&fbclid=IwAR1-44biAI8uOmjGELIxDvt48RQjerk_EgydgILoiKcGWkXKKNeb6vfGozg#season-1

when you click start watching from ep 1 it brings up the 2017 GF

 

Edit: Watch Now works fine. 😬

Edited March 9, 2022 by Rivers Run Red
edit