VOTES: AFLW Rd 1 vs Western Bulldogs

[Ungarieboy 443]

Birch

Zanker

Sheriff

Pearce

Lampard

Fitzsimmons

[Timothy Reddan-A'Blew 5,307]

In a 16 a side comp, can we do 3,2,1?

I'm not so good at this but

3. Birch

2. Zanker

1. L.Pearce

[FarNorthernD 5,861]

3 Zanker

2 Birch

1 Hanks

[dl4e 5,851]

21 minutes ago, Timothy Reddan-A'Blew said:

In a 16 a side comp, can we do 3,2,1?

I'm not so good at this but

3. Birch

2. Zanker

1. L.Pearce

Agreed.

[John Dee 445]

Zanker

Birch

L Pierce 

[Deestar9 1,649]

Zanker

Birch

L.Pierce

[Ungarieboy 443]

There's still 21 plus players; we should recognise recognise their effort as much as the men (actually more so as they give up more for less); but if having 2 less players reduce votes: let's make it 5.

 

[Nicko 1,382]

Hanks

zanker

gay

and if we’re doing 5

birch

mithen 

[WERRIDEE 5,517]

5 Zanker

4 Hanks

3 Birch

2 L.Pearce

1 D.Pearce

Edited January 8, 2022 by WERRIDEE

[Timothy Reddan-A'Blew 5,307]

1 hour ago, Ungarieboy said:

There's still 21 plus players; we should recognise recognise their effort as much as the men (actually more so as they give up more for less); but if having 2 less players reduce votes: let's make it 5.

 

Can't argue with the maths!

I'd then be

5. Birch

4. Zanker

3. L.Pearce

2. Hanks

1. Lampard

[Go the Biff 3,442]

5 -  Zanker

4 - L. Pearce

3 - Hanks

2 - Lampard

1 - Sherriff

Edited January 8, 2022 by Go the Biff

[Paulo 285]

5   zanker 

4    Birch 

3    hanks

2     sherriff

1     gay

[Tolstoys Nudge 1,734]

Hanks 

L.Pearce

Sherriff

Zanker 

Paxman 

  

[Deeoldfart 8,065]

3.  E. Zanker

2.  L. Pearce

1.  T. Hanks

[Lil_red_fire_engine 11,234]

3. Zanker

2. Hanks

1. L Pearce

[BDA 22,891]

5. Zanker

4. Birch

3. Hanks

2. Sherriff

1. Lampard

[bananas 428]

5. Zanker -- a real difference maker in the midfield. Saved the game when it looked like the doggies were going to overrun us.

4. L. Pearce -- doing the Max-style kick behind play thing, and doing it very very well.

3. Birch -- had a great game, but occasionally a bit panicky/unclean with her disposal. Fix that up and she'd have been BOG.

2. Hanks -- as always, a smooth mover and good user through the middle.

1. Sherriff -- both tough at the contest and skillful when the ball was on the outside, a key link-up piece in most of our best passages of play.

Apologies: Lampard, Tarrant, Hore, Heath, Gay, Harris (the difference from Cunningham last season to Harris last night was like night and day -- I don't think Tayla will ever quite be the player that her media profile demands, but she'll be a very important structural piece for us).

 

Edited January 9, 2022 by bananas
Forgot a couple in my apologies

[Dees_In_October 3,495]

Thanks for getting this going.

May as well chip in mine from the match report...although on reflection I've switched Birch and Zanker; perhaps I over-compensated in trying to avoid over-rewarding my favourite player.

5. Zanker - As mentioned I've been on board the Zanker train since it departed the station. Especially glad to see her hit the scoreboard.

4. Birch - Saved some goals (and nearly cost a shocker!) but clearly had a big impact in a somewhat depleted backline.

3. Hanks - I always feel like I gloss over her performances, but she's that consistent I feel like I'm just repeating myself. So good in traffic, so balanced. Hope we're saying T.Hanks on W Award night.

2. Sherriff - Glad to see some love for Sherriff above too. She's come a long way. Desperate and courageous.

1. Hore - Wasn't a prolific lead-up game by any means, but when her shots were there, she took them. Which as we know, is kinda important!

[BDA 22,891]

AFLCA Votes are in

9 Eden Zanker (MELB)

8 Tyla Hanks (MELB)

7 Ellie Blackburn (WB)

3 Kate Hore (MELB)

3 Libby Birch (MELB)

[spirit of norm smith 16,589]

5 Zanker

4 Birch

3 Hore

2 Hanks 

1 L. Pearce 

Daisy gets honourable mention. She missed an easy goal in the 3rd but otherwise was smart and clean with the footy.  Classy to watch. 

[george_on_the_outer 7,708]

5. Zanker.  What can you say? 183cm runs like the wind, natural footballer and can kick 40m+.  Stood up when the side needed it with Karen and Lily off the ground for long periods

4. Hanks.  Also took up the reins when needed.  Just tough and skilled.  Look at her tackling and run from the back pocket in the 1st which eventually created the goal.

3. Birch.  Saved the bacon time and time again.  Had to do it all on her own at times. 

2. L. Pearce.  Clean out of the ruck, and then follows up and then some more.  A nightmare for opposition

1. Kate Hore.  Did what she needed to do when needed.  Just keeps bobbing up at the right time.