Farewell Luke Jackson

[ChaserJ 5,088]

3 hours ago, Stiff Arm said:

Freo are trying to force us to take 13 and a future 1st for Jackson.

Wouldn't surprise me if they trade out or try to trade out 13 and screw us even further

I trust that Lamb and Taylor are speaking with some of Freo's more fancied players to put the heat on Bell

Many watchers are saying this draft tapers off significantly after the first 5-6 picks. Hope we can work back into that range

Yeah, I’m of the view that if we can’t get a pick inside 5 (accounting for Ashcroft bid) you can almost throw a blanket over the next 25. If Freo can’t do a deal that gives us a chance of getting that very high pick, then take 13 & two futures.

Losing overall draft value to end up selecting with pick in the 6-10 range isn’t worth it this year in my opinion.

[drysdale demon 4,832]

1 hour ago, DeeSpencer said:

We’ve targeted no one so far so I doubt that’s the case.

You wouldn't if we have or not.

[DeeSpencer 25,680]

2 minutes ago, A F said:

How do you know that?

Maybe targeted is the wrong word because clearly we would’ve reached out to a bunch of players but ‘arranged’ or ‘lined up’ or whatever word is better. I’d be absolutely shocked if there’s a hidden player just waiting for the Jackson trade.

[mmwd6 220]

15 minutes ago, Kent said:

DO we have a plan for pick 13??

I'd like to think we package it with one of our (or freos) F1 to move up this year

[Adam The God 30,221]

3 minutes ago, DeeSpencer said:

Maybe targeted is the wrong word because clearly we would’ve reached out to a bunch of players but ‘arranged’ or ‘lined up’ or whatever word is better. I’d be absolutely shocked if there’s a hidden player just waiting for the Jackson trade.

We also don't know whether something might pop up suddenly after the Jackson trade has been completed.

The way Fremantle operate though, this'll probably go down to the wire and there won't be any time post Jackson trade to utilise what we get in any other way.

[Kent 2,909]

32 minutes ago, mmwd6 said:

I'd like to think we package it with one of our (or freos) F1 to move up this year

i really hope so! Looking at who is touted at this spot doesn't really excite

[Redleg 40,899]

Eagles looking at giving 2 to North, in a deal to get JHF and Rioli to Port with them getting Port's 8 and F1st. 

They think they will get the boy they want at 8, likely Reuben Gibney from WA.

That just puts them out of the LJ trade and we are left fighting with Freo.

Not looking flash for us atm.

I would also back North to use 2 on Cadman.

Edited October 6, 2022 by Redleg

[Pennant St Dee 13,172]

1 minute ago, Redleg said:

Eagles looking at giving 2 to North, in a deal to get JHF and Rioli to Port with them getting Port's 8 and F1st. 

They think they will et the boy they want at 8, likely Reuben Gibney from WA.

That just puts them out of the LJ trade and we are left fighting with Freo.

Not looking flash for us atm.

I personally think they will try and on trade the F1 to get another Rd 1 this season and take 2 from Busslinger, Ginbey and Hewitt

[Stiff Arm 4,419]

4 hours ago, buck_nekkid said:

13 + F1 + north’s F2 isnt too bad, but doesnt get us the Cadman.  We have a potential midrange fs next year, so going early there might suit to strike before brown comes into play.  Need to improve this year’s pick significantly before it will get done, either by being able to trade up or they get it in.

I agree, it doesn't get us The Cadillac, which is disappointing, but we have JVR and Tmac coming in in 2023 and maybe even Petty up forward for cameos. Perhaps Lamb and Taylor also have eyes on the 2023 draft which is meant to be a ripper. That would net us our 1st (18!) and Fre's 1st (12ish) and Norf's 2nd (20ish). That's a very good hand in a strong draft.

I still think the key to us improving next year is a strong preseason and an exceptional run with injuries throughout the season

[Kent 2,909]

8 minutes ago, Stiff Arm said:

I agree, it doesn't get us The Cadillac, which is disappointing, but we have JVR and Tmac coming in in 2023 and maybe even Petty up forward for cameos. Perhaps Lamb and Taylor also have eyes on the 2023 draft which is meant to be a ripper. That would net us our 1st (18!) and Fre's 1st (12ish) and Norf's 2nd (20ish). That's a very good hand in a strong draft.

I still think the key to us improving next year is a strong preseason and an exceptional run with injuries throughout the season

I wouldn't be relying too much on T Mac next year.Reliabilty post another foot injury is a real concern in my view.  We need ready made replacements for all our tall forwards.

[Roost it far 8,256]

3 minutes ago, Kent said:

I wouldn't be relying too much on T Mac next year.Reliabilty post another foot injury is a real concern in my view.  We need ready made replacements for all our tall forwards.

I'm actually amazed anyone even discuss's TMac or BBBB as integral to our forward half next year.

[deelusions from afar 1,810]

6 minutes ago, Stiff Arm said:

I agree, it doesn't get us The Cadillac, which is disappointing, but we have JVR and Tmac coming in in 2023 and maybe even Petty up forward for cameos. Perhaps Lamb and Taylor also have eyes on the 2023 draft which is meant to be a ripper. That would net us our 1st (18!) and Fre's 1st (12ish) and Norf's 2nd (20ish). That's a very good hand in a strong draft.

I still think the key to us improving next year is a strong preseason and an exceptional run with injuries throughout the season

I love the idea of getting Cadman but it's high risk as we have to give up a lot and there's a good chance (like many key forwards) he will be a bust.  Impossible to judge, but if the talent pool of this draft is shallow, where would he be ranked in other drafts? 

He will also likely need a few years before he makes an impact at AFL level.  I think if JVR is ready to play 15  games and Petty is tried forward (if Turner can play his role in defence) this will be enough.  Gawn will likely play forward and TMac / BBB will come in only if their form demands it.

Surely our needs would be better served by targeting someone who can play wing / half forward next year - would need to have 2 of the following 3 qualities to replace what we already have (excellent speed, excellent disposal skills, excellent endurance).

[Gawndy the Great 9,011]

35 minutes ago, Redleg said:

Eagles looking at giving 2 to North, in a deal to get JHF and Rioli to Port with them getting Port's 8 and F1st. 

They think they will get the boy they want at 8, likely Reuben Gibney from WA.

That just puts them out of the LJ trade and we are left fighting with Freo.

Not looking flash for us atm.

I would also back North to use 2 on Cadman.

Yep they’ll take Warlord and Cadman 1 & 2. 

[Stiff Arm 4,419]

5 minutes ago, CYB said:

Yep they’ll take Warlord and Cadman 1 & 2. 

After Ashcroft. 

Sheezel at 4? Tsatas at 5? 

 

[DemonSam 171]

How is pick 2 going to North? JHF has done f-all and is a midfielder who come a dime a dozen all because he was pick 1? pfft.

[kev martin 9,887]

I don't mind if we keep Jackson for another year and he becomes the free agent, if we don't get what we want for him.

We have his contract and if they want it then they should fork up.

Play him on the wing, and encourage him to sign with us, saying Freo or WC don't value him and will stuff him around. Gives him another year to get over his home sickness. 

Play hard ball MFC.

Edited October 6, 2022 by kev martin

[Diamond_Jim 12,569]

9 minutes ago, DemonSam said:

How is pick 2 going to North? JHF has done f-all and is a midfielder who come a dime a dozen all because he was pick 1? pfft.

Must say this thought has entered my mind. I suppose the difference is that JFH is contracted for another year.

If this fiasco has taught us anything I hope we sign Kozzie soon !!

[DeeSpencer 25,680]

16 minutes ago, kev martin said:

I don't mind if we keep Jackson for another year and he becomes the free agent, if we don't get what we want for him.

We have his contract and if they want it then they should fork up.

Play him on the wing, and encourage him to sign with us, saying Freo or WC don't value him and will stuff him around. Gives him another year to get over his home sickness. 

Play hard ball MFC.

Might want to read up on trades, free agency and contracts 

[kev martin 9,887]

8 minutes ago, DeeSpencer said:

Might want to read up on trades, free agency and contracts 

Where do I do this?

Does it say we have to get the trade done, after a player gives a request? 

Why can't we just keep him?

 

[Lord Travis 10,729]

9 minutes ago, kev martin said:

Where do I do this?

Does it say we have to get the trade done, after a player gives a request? 

Why can't we just keep him?

 

He's out of contract.
That's the key part of why we hold less leverage than say North do with Jason Horne-Francis, who is under contract and they can therefore hold him to his contract.

[Queanbeyan Demon 6,843]

11 minutes ago, kev martin said:

Where do I do this?

Does it say we have to get the trade done, after a player gives a request? 

Why can't we just keep him?

 

All the rules and EBAs are on the web. Easy peazy.

[Queanbeyan Demon 6,843]

48 minutes ago, DemonSam said:

How is pick 2 going to North? JHF has done f-all and is a midfielder who come a dime a dozen all because he was pick 1? pfft.

Take your point DS. Having watched a fair bit of Norf this year (me mate is mad Norf), there was nothing I saw that indicates JHF will not be, at a minimum, an 'A-grader'. If he avoids serious injuries, is coached well, AND is seriously committed, he's a superstar in the making. He's genuinely tough to boot. Just my opinion though. :-)

Edited October 6, 2022 by Queanbeyan Demon

[Gawndy the Great 9,011]

58 minutes ago, Stiff Arm said:

After Ashcroft. 

Sheezel at 4? Tsatas at 5? 

 

Sounds about right. 

[Gawndy the Great 9,011]

Just now, Queanbeyan Demon said:

Take your point DS. Having watched a fair bit of Norf this year (me mate is mad Norf), there was nothing I saw that indicates JHF will be, at a minimum, an 'A-grader'. If he avoids serious injuries, is coached well, AND is seriously committed, he's a superstar in the making. He's genuinely tough to boot. Just my opinion though. :-)

It’s funny as I also put Rowell in the same bucket and he’s had a few extra years in the system (admittedly some of it injured)   . Dominated junior footy, but his impact on the game is not as good a so thought it would be. 

[deelusions from afar 1,810]

Given WA is a two team town, what's to stop Freo and WCE doing a deal which seems lopsided but with a player.  Not unlike Freo trading Lachie Weller to the Suns and receiving pick 2 a few years back.  eg

WCE trade pick 2 to Freo and in return Freo trade 13 and Player X (an average player).

WCE and Freo "try" to do a deal with Melbourne but can't come to an arrangement by the end of the trade period.

LJ says to Melbourne he's really sorry but he is homesick - it's not his fault that a deal wasn't done.  LJ goes into PSD and given he's already moved to WA, North don't pick him.  So WCE get him for merely a pick slide (or whatever the deal is) and Freo boost their draft hand.  Everyone wins... except us.

We would say they draft tampered but they say we just don't appreciate the value of Player X.  Given the AFL turns a blind eye to teams that do dodgy things, they would probably waive it through.  

Could that happen?