AFL Trade Radio

[grazman 7,499]

43 minutes ago, whatwhatsaywhat said:

bizarre decision from dunkley for mine

i do think it's hilarious that there's been so much gnashing and wailing about oliver walking out on us...but it is clearly not happening; meanwhile the dogs just one of their key players

Maybe not though - Josh  alerted the Bulldogs to some unprofessional behaviour in terms of preparation and commitment by other senior players who promised to deal with it, but haven't.  He's obviously had enough and Essendon have provided the lure with the opportunity to play with his younger brother.   Looking at the interview with his dad when we drafted Kyle they look like a family of straight shooters. 

Edited November 5, 2020 by grazman

[DubDee 26,191]

Why TF would Dunkley want to go to the cheats?!  must be money or a falling out with the Dags

[DubDee 26,191]

2 minutes ago, grazman said:

Maybe not though - Josh  alerted the Bulldogs to some unprofessional behaviour in terms of preparation and commitment by other senior players who promised to deal with it, but haven't.  He's obviously had enough and Essendon have provided the lure with the opportunity to play with his younger brother.   Looking at the interview with his dad when we drafted Kyle they look like a family of straight shooters. 

going to the bombers for their professional conduct?  thats the funniest thing I've heard all day!

he better check what meds the PE staff give him

[rjay 25,204]

34 minutes ago, Red and Blue realist said:

This is where we could get involved, assuming Essendon get pick 8 for Saad because the dogs won't want an early pick in this years draft. I'd ask about sending our 1st round (2021), pick 26 & 53 (2020) and Hannan to the Dogs and TMac to the bombers, the Dogs sending Dunkley to Ess while we get picks 8 and 14 this year. The Bombers don't have any 2nd round picks this year

Dees: Out 2021 1st, pick 26 & 53 (2020) Hannan & TMac In: pick 8 & 14 2020. 

Dogs: out Dunkley, pick 14 In: 2021 1st (from Dees) & pick 26 & 53 (2020) & Hannan

Ess: out pick 8 In: Dunkley & TMac

Except Tommy is not worth a cracker...

[Redleg 41,770]

8 minutes ago, DubDee said:

Why TF would Dunkley want to go to the cheats?!  must be money or a falling out with the Dags

Didn’t like playing ruck.

[58er 6,688]

17 hours ago, Dr.D said:

You don't offer 3 year contracts to players you think are spuds. So the dogs obviously see what i see in him. 190cm small forward that can run and jump and has kicked a clutch goal in finals. 

Seems like we had Mitch for about 4 years fir ONE BIG GLORIOUS goal that none of us will ever forget.

Good luck with the Dogs Mitch and thanks fir the memory. 

[Demonland 73,266]

 

[rjay 25,204]

2 minutes ago, Demonland said:

 

I hope they stand firm as I also hope Treloar stands firm at Collingwood....

Make a contract great again...

[Moonshadow 17,678]

47 minutes ago, DubDee said:

Why TF would Dunkley want to go to the cheats?!  must be money or a falling out with the Dags

Money, length of contract, not played out of position, possibly play with bro, stay on Melb city.

Also s*** hot drugs 

[Engorged Onion 10,224]

58 minutes ago, DubDee said:

going to the bombers for their professional conduct?  thats the funniest thing I've heard all day!

he better check what meds the PE staff give him

seriously, that's a pretty out of line comment.

staff have all moved on. It's not endemic to the walls of the club (even though the moved from windy hill to tullamarine).

don't tar current staff for previous staff's failings.

[BW511 2,705]

He’s been shunted to HFF and rotating ruck, I’d leave too.

He is a gun onballer, not a makeshift ruckman

[DubDee 26,191]

16 minutes ago, Engorged Onion said:

seriously, that's a pretty out of line comment.

staff have all moved on. It's not endemic to the walls of the club (even though the moved from windy hill to tullamarine).

don't tar current staff for previous staff's failings.

I will never let that organisation off the hook just because the staff were suspended/sacked. It was the most disgraceful lack of care for players in the history of the AFL. Testing random Unapproved drugs on their players having no idea what they might do. 

This is endemic to the club due to its arrogance and expecting to win regardless of the consequences. Why does Daniher, Saad, Fantasia want to leave? Their culture is shot

[old dee 23,927]

3 minutes ago, DubDee said:

I will never let that organisation off the hook just because the staff were suspended/sacked. It was the most disgraceful lack of care for players in the history of the AFL. Testing random Unapproved drugs on their players having no idea what they might do. 

This is endemic to the club due to its arrogance and expecting to win regardless of the consequences. Why does Daniher, Saad, Fantasia want to leave? Their culture is shot

They have been an Arrogant mob since I can remember which is now a fair while and nothing has change.  

[Sir Why You Little 37,242]

1 hour ago, Demonland said:

 

Wow ? again. Clubs are getting so much better at this game...

It’s really on now...

[old dee 23,927]

3 minutes ago, Sir Why You Little said:

Wow ? again. Clubs are getting so much better at this game...

It’s really on now...

Time they respected contracts they sign, the clubs are expected to honour their side. 

[Sir Why You Little 37,242]

12 minutes ago, old dee said:

Time they respected contracts they sign, the clubs are expected to honour their side. 

When it suits....

[Pates 9,661]

16 minutes ago, old dee said:

Time they respected contracts they sign, the clubs are expected to honour their side. 

Ummm Pies with Treloar....

Both clubs and players are no longer respecting the idea of a contract and what it means. Clubs see it as insurance to make sure if the player wants to leave they have all the power, players are seeing it as cushions for job/salary security but then suddenly if there’s the chance to play in a premiership contending team they get “disgruntled”. 

[old dee 23,927]

3 minutes ago, Pates said:

Ummm Pies with Treloar....

Both clubs and players are no longer respecting the idea of a contract and what it means. Clubs see it as insurance to make sure if the player wants to leave they have all the power, players are seeing it as cushions for job/salary security but then suddenly if there’s the chance to play in a premiership contending team they get “disgruntled”. 

Or earn more.

[old dee 23,927]

4 minutes ago, Pates said:

Ummm Pies with Treloar....

Both clubs and players are no longer respecting the idea of a contract and what it means. Clubs see it as insurance to make sure if the player wants to leave they have all the power, players are seeing it as cushions for job/salary security but then suddenly if there’s the chance to play in a premiership contending team they get “disgruntled”. 

I have said elsewhere that this a problem of Collingwoods making. I hope they stay in the poo. 

[Whispering_Jack 30,952]

The second day of the trade period is an almost nothing day and, true to form, almost nothing happened.

The biggest news of the day was that the only deal done was the trade of Kyle Hartigan from the Adelaide Crowd to Hawthorn for a future fourth round pick. In draft terms, that’s about the lowest level of currency you can get. 

That left the various commentators on AFL Trade Radio with plenty of time to discuss the futures of Jeremy Cameron, Josh Dunkley and Adam Treloar and some of lesser lights who are currently homeless, the sum total of such discussions amounting to almost nothing.

[Chelly 830]

2 minutes ago, Whispering_Jack said:

The second day of the trade period is an almost nothing day and, true to form, almost nothing happened.

The biggest news of the day was that the only deal done was the trade of Kyle Hartigan from the Adelaide Crowd to Hawthorn for a future fourth round pick. In draft terms, that’s about the lowest level of currency you can get. 

That left the various commentators on AFL Trade Radio with plenty of time to discuss the futures of Jeremy Cameron, Josh Dunkley and Adam Treloar and some of lesser lights who are currently homeless, the sum total of such discussions amounting to almost nothing.

The bad news is that even less happens on the third day of the trade period than the second.

[Demonland 73,266]

 

[Slartibartfast 17,789]

2 hours ago, rjay said:

Except Tommy is not worth a cracker...

We get where you stand on TMac. 

[rjay 25,204]

35 minutes ago, Baghdad Bob said:

We get where you stand on TMac. 

Actually it's not where I stand 'Bob'...it's where the competition sees him now.

Yep, I have been a critic since 2019. I reckon he lost all form (he didn't recover from the 2018 prelim) for whatever reason and we played him when he should have spent time at Casey.

They lost the opportunity in 2019 to send a message, see if he could regain form, confidence....rest him if he was injured...whatever.

Why I keep going over it now is that some seem to think he has trade value when he has next to none.

There isn't a queue of clubs wanting his services.

We accuse others of overrating their players but in this case some of the trade scenarios are ridiculous.

They (fans on this site) seem to think some magic trade will happen or that a club needs him...we have been crying out for another key forward and we went and got someone else...it shows us and the rest of the completion where we value him.

Why would we think another club, say GWS as was suggested would need him to replace Cameron...if he could then we should hold him because we need that player probably more than them.

We are probably at the head of the line for a club that needed him. We don't think he's got it to come back into form or we are not willing to risk it. We are in a similar position to Collingwood with Dawes, they knew he was done, they needed a KPF yet moved him on...he was gone.

I hope someone does take him on as it will relieve some salary cap stress but I don't know that there is anyone as dumb as we were when we took on Dawes.

If we have to hold him then I hope he can really turn it around next season and stick it up me and anyone else that doubted him.

It would be great to see....

Tommy has been a great servant and a credit to himself to carve out the career he has but his time may be up.

[BDA 22,960]

9 hours ago, rjay said:

Actually it's not where I stand 'Bob'...it's where the competition sees him now.

Yep, I have been a critic since 2019. I reckon he lost all form (he didn't recover from the 2018 prelim) for whatever reason and we played him when he should have spent time at Casey.

They lost the opportunity in 2019 to send a message, see if he could regain form, confidence....rest him if he was injured...whatever.

Why I keep going over it now is that some seem to think he has trade value when he has next to none.

There isn't a queue of clubs wanting his services.

We accuse others of overrating their players but in this case some of the trade scenarios are ridiculous.

They (fans on this site) seem to think some magic trade will happen or that a club needs him...we have been crying out for another key forward and we went and got someone else...it shows us and the rest of the completion where we value him.

Why would we think another club, say GWS as was suggested would need him to replace Cameron...if he could then we should hold him because we need that player probably more than them.

We are probably at the head of the line for a club that needed him. We don't think he's got it to come back into form or we are not willing to risk it. We are in a similar position to Collingwood with Dawes, they knew he was done, they needed a KPF yet moved him on...he was gone.

I hope someone does take him on as it will relieve some salary cap stress but I don't know that there is anyone as dumb as we were when we took on Dawes.

If we have to hold him then I hope he can really turn it around next season and stick it up me and anyone else that doubted him.

It would be great to see....

Tommy has been a great servant and a credit to himself to carve out the career he has but his time may be up.

Hard to argue with too much of that. I’m hopeful though that someone picks him up as defensive depth but we’ll be paying a chunk of his salary, half or so I reckon. If he doesn’t move then its Casey next year and a negotiated pay-out in 2022.