My 3 word player analysis V Collingwood

[joeboy 3,166]

Jones - a broken man

Viney - devoid of ideas

Gawn - our only champion

Oliver - prolific without benefitting

Brayshaw - couldn’t hurt opposition 

Hore - tried but loose

May - a welcome addition 

Lever - glad he survived 

Fritsch - lost in battle 

Salem - probably suffering concussion 

Frost - a major loss

Hibberd - past his best

Baker - stunned by headlights

Harmes - gave his all

Petracca - seemingly without purpose 

Hannan - had little involvement 

Weideman - hardly gave yelp

Spargo - couldn’t justify selection 

Garlett - an embarrassing performance 

Hunt - tried but failed

T. McDonald - played without heart

Wagner - little to commend

 

[dimmy 1,307]

Bit harsh on Braysahw and Hore. We looked a lot more purposeful with Max, Clarrie, Gus and Harmesy around the ball.

[Matsuo Basho 1,053]

Jones - Retire gracefully champ

 Viney - Bullocking without brains 

Gawn - Elevated reputation further 

Oliver - Hampered by injury 

Brayshaw - Tried but outclassed  

Hore - Gone past Jetta

May - Cavalry arrives finally 

Lever - Solid considering lay-off  

Fritsch - Brave and polished  

 Salem - Rattled by bump  

Frost - Missed his pressure 

Hibberd - Staggering form loss 

Baker - Plenty of potential  

Harmes - Tried guts out 

Petracca - Better in middle  

Hannan - Straight to Casey 

Weideman - Didn’t do enough 

Spargo -  Not enough tricks 

Garlett - Last Melbourne game  

Hunt - Wasted in attack 

T. McDonald - Laughing after loss 

Wagner - A witches hat 

[Deemania since 56 6,654]

38 minutes ago, dimmy said:

We looked a lot more purposeful with Max, Clarrie, Gus and Harmesy around the ball

It was a better blend this week against a tough side. Viney disappoints - limited options in his game now.

[Sorry kids 635]

Hard on Wiedeman.    can be excused until we learn to kick accurately or to space. In the mean time he continues to learn his craft the hard way.Mc Donald on the other hand needs a rest or spell at Casey.

[Deespicable 2,726]

1 hour ago, joeboy said:

Jones - a broken man

Viney - devoid of ideas

Gawn - our only champion

Oliver - prolific without benefitting

Brayshaw - couldn’t hurt opposition 

Hore - tried but loose

May - a welcome addition 

Lever - glad he survived 

Fritsch - lost in battle 

Salem - probably suffering concussion 

Frost - a major loss

Hibberd - past his best

Baker - stunned by headlights

Harmes - gave his all

Petracca - seemingly without purpose 

Hannan - had little involvement 

Weideman - hardly gave yelp

Spargo - couldn’t justify selection 

Garlett - an embarrassing performance 

Hunt - tried but failed

T. McDonald - played without heart

Wagner - little to commend

 

Another disgraceful effort by you JoeBoy - makes me wonder if you actually ever go to the game.

Fritsch - best game 2019

Brayshaw - shades of 2018

Harmes - our prime mover

Petracca - another step forward

Weid - finally showing something

[Juk3b0x 166]

Jones - Can’t hit target

Viney - lost his tricks  

Gawn - gives it everything 

Oliver - kick the football

Brayshaw - leave in middle

Hore - better than most 

May - won his battles  

Lever - will only improve  

Fritsch - look better today

Salem - something wasn’t right  

Frost - missed his dash

Hibberd - past his best

Baker - deserves another chance 

Harmes - only composed mid

Petracca - untapped potential frustrates 

Hannan - had little involvement 

Weideman - given no chance 

Spargo - coughed up regularly 

Garlett - physicality is embarrassing  

Hunt - only moving target  

T. McDonald - useless legless liability

 Wagner - little to commend

[dimmy 1,307]

Salem : Got sore head

Petracca : Strong at ground level

Garlett, Spargo : Too many fumbles

Harmes : Strong Competitive midfielder

Brayshaw : Attacking Inside Mid

Brayshaw : Tighten disposal

Team : Only kick to space /Make them run into kick

Hannan : Learn right foot

Gawn : Great Great Great

Hore : Find of Season

Lever : Settled and survived

May : Showed good promise

Frost : Missed him (did not think I would ever say this)

Oscar Mc : Cannot be blamed this week

Clarrie : Three more blinks per disposal = massive improvement to side

Tom Mc : Too many roles

[Red But Mostly Blue 4,547]

I thought Harmes was good, and tried hard!

Weid was much better, and looked more confident. He'll get better, especially once he starts getting some better delivery

Trac was much better in the midfield.

Fritter was decent. I think he provides much better value up at half forward.

[Straight Sets Simon 23,113]

Weideman - Needs perfect delivery

[At the break of Gawn 4,460]

Weid was our best forward.

Tmac should go back to Casey against Freo - he’s not going to find the form at this level. He’s had 12 weeks.

I’m not 100% convinced he’s injured. Has not once alluded to it in interviews and has continuously talked about his form issues and ways to try and get out of his slump.

[junk 342]

I think Petracca will be traded especially if Dunkley comes on.

[Docs Demons 1,792]

38 minutes ago, Clint Bizkit said:

Weideman - Needs perfect delivery

Well that will  not happen!!!

[Dame Gaga 2,453]

Max - Superb Supreme Sublime

 

[Docs Demons 1,792]

34 minutes ago, At the break of Gawn said:

Weid was our best forward.

Tmac should go back to Casey against Freo - he’s not going to find the form at this level. He’s had 12 weeks.

I’m not 100% convinced he’s injured. Has not once alluded to it in interviews and has continuously talked about his form issues and ways to try and get out of his slump.

Both he and the Weid DO NOT lead to ball carriers. Both drop back and oppo just cut us off to often.

[rjay 24,950]

25 minutes ago, junk said:

I think Petracca will be traded especially if Dunkley comes on.

Petracca was good today...the only one who didn't fumble & looked poised with ball in hand.

[picket fence 17,172]

43 minutes ago, Clint Bizkit said:

Weideman - Needs perfect delivery

If Weeds was the filth would kick 5 plus per game!

[Dockett 32 1,239]

28 minutes ago, junk said:

I think Petracca will be traded especially if Dunkley comes on.

Looking at our forward line today and most of the season,  l reckon there are a lot in the queue ahead of him. Probably all the forwards actually.

In a decent side with a properly functioning forward line l think he would go ok.

[Redleg 40,948]

1 hour ago, junk said:

I think Petracca will be traded especially if Dunkley comes on.

Hilarious. Your name perfectly describes your post.

[dave 183]

1 hour ago, junk said:

I think Petracca will be traded especially if Dunkley comes on.

absolute bollocks from an obvious bung-nut!!

[Skin Deeamond 339]

1 hour ago, dave said:

absolute bollocks from an obvious bung-nut!!

What’s a bung-nut?

[Happeninghunts 7]

10 hours ago, Matsuo Basho said:

Jones - Retire gracefully champ

 Viney - Bullocking without brains 

Gawn - Elevated reputation further 

Oliver - Hampered by injury 

Brayshaw - Tried but outclassed  

Hore - Gone past Jetta

May - Cavalry arrives finally 

Lever - Solid considering lay-off  

Fritsch - Brave and polished  

 Salem - Rattled by bump  

Frost - Missed his pressure 

Hibberd - Staggering form loss 

Baker - Plenty of potential  

Harmes - Tried guts out 

Petracca - Better in middle  

Hannan - Straight to Casey 

Weideman - Didn’t do enough 

Spargo -  Not enough tricks 

Garlett - Last Melbourne game  

Hunt - Wasted in attack 

T. McDonald - Laughing after loss 

Wagner - A witches hat 

I actually agree with you,  apart from Hunt.  Isn't he our leading goal kicker this year?

[La Dee-vina Comedia 16,814]

11 hours ago, Deespicable said:

Another disgraceful effort by you JoeBoy - makes me wonder if you actually ever go to the game.

Fritsch - best game 2019

Brayshaw - shades of 2018

Harmes - our prime mover

Petracca - another step forward

Weid - finally showing something

Problem is, he should be taking leaps and bounds, not steps. He started well, but I felt went missing for long periods in the game.

[Matsuo Basho 1,053]

2 hours ago, Happeninghunts said:

I actually agree with you,  apart from Hunt.  Isn't he our leading goal kicker this year?

He is. What an indictment!

Hunt for me is a back flanker every day of the week and twice on Sundays. We miss his run and carry greatly.

[ArtificialWisdom 4,045]

1 hour ago, Matsuo Basho said:

He is. What an indictment!

Hunt for me is a back flanker every day of the week and twice on Sundays. We miss his run and carry greatly.

Do we? For the most part our midfield and backline performed admirably yesterday. There was some skill errors coming out of the back 50 but that was attributable to collingwoods pressure and besides God knows Hunt isn't going to help with skill.

If we are going to have a pure defencive forward like ANB was last year I think Hunt is a good choice. At least he has genuine pace.