Just wanna check . . . is that the same Hogan that:

• has the ball constantly kicked on top of his head
• has the ball kicked to his defensive side
• regularly competes against two or three opponents because we move the ball slowly or in unpredictable patterns
• has the ball dropped in front of him
• was a lock for AA in the middle of the season
• was rated top 15 players in the comp by The Roar a month ago
• flies against (take your pick) Pedo/Max/Harmes/Trac/Hotdog stand vendor
• runs his guts out to make position at half forward for a clear receive only to see the ball fumbled or turned over by (take you pick) ANB/Spargo/Jones/Tyson/Frost
• is so bugged by the time he does get the ball that he can't kick straight?

Yeah . . . trade him I recon.

Take a second to look at the posters who agree at all with the OP.  

Once you have, you'll have all the answers you need.  Joke of a thread.

Hogan is playing injured. He needs a week or two off, but we can't afford to drop him this close to finals. I'd say drop him this week since we're no chance of winning but he would probably like to go to Perth. 

i wouldve traded him earlier. poor attitude and i dont care what his set shot stats are, he is a terrible kick. 

Under the bridge downtown 

I lol’ed 

Hogan isn't our problem. But If I were Hogan I would ask for a trade if our delivery inside 50 doesn't improve. It isn't fair to even bag Hogan at this point. We have the worst delivery inside 50 of a team that I have ever seen, and that includes my junior football sides when we couldn't kick at all.

1 minute ago, KingDingAling said:

Hogan isn't our problem. But If I were Hogan I would ask for a trade if our delivery inside 50 doesn't improve. It isn't fair to even bag Hogan at this point. We have the worst delivery inside 50 of a team that I have ever seen, and that includes my junior football sides when we couldn't kick at all.

I'm not saying trade Hogan because of any problem with his form. In fact I think he has the ability to deliver us a premiership playing at CHF.

What I am saying is that we may have a chance of covering Hogan with Weideman, Mc Donald etc while adding significantly to our list through the draft or by trade. Cannot think of another player on our list that we could cover for who has decent trade value.

Time to get smart as a football club. We have a decent list and the club would be wanting if the analysis was not done.

Yeah, bugger it, we're no good, trade veryone with currency, time for a rebuild.

32 minutes ago, Dr.D said:

i wouldve traded him earlier. poor attitude and i dont care what his set shot stats are, he is a terrible kick. 

my issue is he has been in system for awhile and every year same thing. JW got traded for the same thing !

Lot of people in here who need a cuddle I think

37 minutes ago, Dr.D said:

i wouldve traded him earlier. poor attitude and i dont care what his set shot stats are, he is a terrible kick. 

He is a really bad kick

1 hour ago, north westerly said:

I’m not one to sensationalise, but do we honestly think he’s the answer at FF.

Trade him for two first rounders while he has some currency !

Must be a full moon, the nuffies are out.

9 minutes ago, Little Goffy said:

Yeah, bugger it, we're no good, trade veryone with currency, time for a rebuild.

We have an improving list built around a core of solid performers

But we've always held on to guys we like who don't perform because we see them through rose coloured glasses

Hogan I think is one

8 minutes ago, Gipsy Danger said:

Lot of people in here who need a cuddle I think

Best comment I have read, I need one. 

Our list, Hogan included, is not the [censored] problem. For once we actually have a good list!!! We have a better list than half the teams currently in the 8. 

The problem is we are mentally [censored] and we are not well coached. 

Hogan is a gun and the other 17 clubs would be lining up for him.  Unfortunately our style of play is not suited to anyone playing deep forward.  He is far from the problem - his dodgy kicking today not withstanding.

He continually over runs under the kick, then complains like a baby when it's not lace out. 

If he asks to go home you let him go and get Adam Cerra or Langdon in return, any day of the week. 

11 minutes ago, Graeme Yeats' Mullet said:

He is a really bad kick

He's a bad set shot kick, but a good field kick.

You watch T Mac wait and time his marking properly. Hogan cannot do this. Even the weed is a better contested mark.

Can those posters that are in the “no to trading Hogan camp” please enlighten the rest of us which games he’s dominated this year. Or more to the point, his numbers/stats in our losses. 

For those who keep bringing up his potential AA form, again, against which sides? 

What he achieved in his first two seasons counts for nothing now. He is clearly not the player we all thought he’d be which ever way you spin it. 

Im all for trading him, but would want a gun mid in return. One that fits our age/talent profile. Then target a Peter Wright or similar.

Firstly, Hogan is playing injured and should have been rested for the Gold coast match. 

Secondly, every player has a bad day, sure a FF should not miss from 20 metres out slight angle, but that is footy and that is life. no need to overreact 

he has had some really good games for us this year and games in past seasons. everyone should just calm down. 

1 minute ago, red&blue1982 said:

He's a bad set shot kick, but a good field kick.

Not today worst disposal efficiency in the team

But if you're right then he's not our full forward solution so he shouldn't be played there

He also is not a strong lead and mark, I'm sure his teammates kicking on his head doesn't help much but we need a full forward who can lead and mark

9 minutes ago, red&blue1982 said:

He's a bad set shot kick, but a good field kick.

Just as he is a excellent mark leading up the ground, but struggles when the ball comes in high or in pack marking situations but spends more time deep than TMac. On the other hand TMac takes the big marks and today aside is a better shot on goal yet it he who has to go down back or into the ruck. Would love to see TMac left at FF for the rest of the year.

11 minutes ago, Bombay Airconditioning said:

Im all for trading him, 

What a surprise.

@Dappa Dan put it best in the post match thread and he might like to cross post it here.