1 hour ago, Satyriconhome said:

 

No the wisdom tooth issue came at completely the wrong time, when he still wasn't picked I asked, as above, he dropped a bit of form, so Casey to build it back

Not sure which bit you are not getting with Goodwin, if Gus' fitness was below the expected standard, he would be on bench at Casey or rehab group

As I said, "He's obviously match fit now (to at least get selected), but his two way running needs to get much much better.  One questions whether he's been doing all of the extras that some players do."

He's always at the rear during the preseason running sessions.

There's a reason Petracca is now running up the front and Brayshaw is bringing up the rear.  And it has to be application.

Maybe you just don't pay attention when you're at training.

Gaz, the epitome of wisdom, good character, judgement and honour..

... Speaking of absolute fl0gs, did you also all hear Eddy commentating on the weekend and nearly put his foot in it regarding Tarzan or something? 

 

20 hours ago, ProDee said:

Nothing beats match fitness.  He's now had runs in the JLT and a few at Casey, so I suspect it's at AFL level, but he's well behind the better runners at AFL level.

Guess we will find out this Sunday (if he replaces Tyson)

11 minutes ago, Petraccattack said:

Guess we will find out this Sunday (if he replaces Tyson)

Yeah.  His percentage game time will be interesting.

8 hours ago, Satyriconhome said:

 

 if Gus' fitness was below the expected standard, he would be on bench at Casey or rehab group

Nothing builds fitness like sitting on a bench.

21 minutes ago, Deestroy All said:

Nothing builds fitness like sitting on a bench.

If this was true, I’d be fit enough to put my hand up for a game

I'm a great benchsitter, especially with chips

12 minutes ago, Jibroni said:

I'm a great benchsitter, especially with chips

Sounds like a solid preseason

Isn’t he friends with the Bradshaw families

3 hours ago, Demons1858 said:

Isn’t he friends with the Bradshaw families

At this point I think we can disregard Gary having any loyalty to anyone but himself.

On 12/04/2018 at 9:27 PM, bush demon said:

Gary Lyon is an all-time great of the MFC and he can errrr, say what he likes.

Sure but he he cant 'demand' the club does anythinG. He was also part of the cabal that nearly saw this club go under. Well intentioned but an unmitigated disaster.

he can stay well away from the club as far as I am concerned.

As I have bored people with before: we are not big enough to eat each other alive from past ills.

23 years of irrelevance, the near merger, the bubbling debt, the non-tanking verdict, the Neeld choice - they make up a rich tapestry of failure that we have all endured in the past and have stuck by the club.

If you are a Demon at heart you are welcome inside the house in my view. 

And you can certainly query why a player isn’t selected...

11 hours ago, Demons1858 said:

Isn’t he friends with the Bradshaw families

I'm intrigued by how often he gets called Bradshaw. Seems a difficult typo to be made so systematically. Is it a weird autocorrect type thing? Surely nobody actually thinks that is his name?

6 minutes ago, Nasher said:

I'm intrigued by how often he gets called Bradshaw. Seems a difficult typo to be made so systematically. Is it a weird autocorrect type thing? Surely nobody actually thinks that is his name?

Autocorrect.  

2 minutes ago, buck_nekkid said:

Autocorrect.  

Weird that "Bradshaw" would be a word common enough to be in anyone phone dictionary, but it does explain it.

Just now, Nasher said:

Weird that "Bradshaw" would be a word common enough to be in anyone phone dictionary, but it does explain it.

Really frustrates me how my phone naturally goes to Bradshaw before Brayshaw. 

Ah well anyway, I think Gus had a good pre-season but didn’t set the world on fire and probably lacked in the one percenters and hard two way running. 

I’m really hopeful of him showing his true talents, plus he knows how to kick goals which will be good for this midfield/rotation thing we’ve got going on with Hogan/Petracca/Oliver. 

31 minutes ago, Nasher said:

Weird that "Bradshaw" would be a word common enough to be in anyone phone dictionary, but it does explain it.

blame her, my wife cant stop watching the re runs.... 

Edited April 14, 20187 yr by Danelska

44 minutes ago, Danelska said:

blame her, my wife cant stop watching the re runs.... 

and i wonder, do they even afl in nyc??

On 12 April 2018 at 2:49 PM, stevethemanjordan said:

I’d have had Brayshaw in the side over ANB, Melksham and Tyson for any of the rounds so far.

Cearly there’s something more than ‘form’ that we’re not privy to.

ANB and Melksham have been seriously underwhelming to date. And Tyson hasn’t been much better imo.

Yet none of them have been dropped.

Given the quality of the opposition last week, and the fact there's been only one match, there's not really enough VFL form to go on Steve. Tonight's match should be a better indicator.  Up till this week it is really only what the selectors have seen on the track, which isn't as strong an indicator at the end of the day.

It is absolutely rediculous that the VFL starts 3 weeks after the AFL.  Would hate to be a selector at the start of the season when injuries / poor form / general soreness kick in over the first 3 matches.

We will only really know where Stretch / Brayshaw / Balic  & Maynard are vs say Tyson / Melksham & Nibbler, when the former have had a decent run at it at AFL level and we have a body of work to compare.  Some will no doubt also throw in the Pedders v Weid debate as well.

In the mean time I'm happy with the word coming out of the FD that supposedly tells us they are only looking at 'in form' for 'out of form' options for the ins / outs each week, no doubt match ups / roles & the weather playing a significant part also.

Edited April 14, 20187 yr by Rusty Nails

5 hours ago, Pates said:

Really frustrates me how my phone naturally goes to Bradshaw before Brayshaw. 

Ah well anyway, I think Gus had a good pre-season but didn’t set the world on fire and probably lacked in the one percenters and hard two way running. 

I’m really hopeful of him showing his true talents, plus he knows how to kick goals which will be good for this midfield/rotation thing we’ve got going on with Hogan/Petracca/Oliver. 

Serves you right for choosing a Crapple over an android Pates!  Wait ....this is a bloody Crapple also! ?