Jump to content

VFL FINALS WEEK 3

KC from Casey

By KC from Casey
in Melbourne Demons


Recommended Posts

DemonOX Trident

DemonOX   8,857

Posted
Posted
5 minutes ago, Males said:

Does our Melbourne Membership get us into the Grandfinal?

As a Dee's member we have to pay extra for finals, that way we save money on our memberships!!!

daisycutter Legend

daisycutter   30,022

Posted
Posted
Just now, Diamond_Jim said:

Salem until injured, Oliver, Dunn and a pass to Trengrove

Did  I miss any well performed MFC players. Not a great game by the rest.

The Casey boys were very good.

my impression too. lot of room for improvement from some. A few really carried the load. Dunny bog for mine


P-man Legend

P-man   13,367

Posted
Posted
3 minutes ago, Diamond_Jim said:

Salem until injured, Oliver, Dunn and a pass to Trengrove

Did  I miss any well performed MFC players. Not a great game by the rest.

The Casey boys were very good.

Garland was pretty good from what I saw. Don't know his final stats. 


demons123452000 Demon

demons123452000   131

Posted
Posted
2 minutes ago, dazzledavey36 said:

Well done to Daniel Cross to who has just won a premiership for Albury tigers.

mate in the o&m albury is so packed its a case of who comes second  its a joke


Diamond_Jim Legend

Diamond_Jim   12,779

Posted
Posted
2 minutes ago, P-man said:

Garland was pretty good from what I saw. Don't know his final stats. 

Yes ... you are correct. Missed what happened to him but I noticed he was absent in the second half and then they showed him during the final quarter in the track suit on the bench.

Redleg Legend

Redleg   42,189

Posted
Posted
11 minutes ago, big_red_fire_engine said:

Clinical win by the Scorps. Looking forward to witnessing Oliver's final ever VFL game next week.  Dunn did his potential trade value no harm. Joel Smith with a full preseason next year could be very interesting. 

I am still one for keeping Dunn. He was sensational today. Not only can he play defence, he can go forward and kick a long goal. I don't understand the desire ny many on here to trade him. 

Garland however to me is cooked.

A few observations.

ANB racks up possessions and does little with them. His disposal today was atrocious.

Salem will be a gun.

Oliver will be a canon. This kid is fantastic.

Weed has a long way to go, but will be better with more muscle.

McInerney showed a bit and if we could rookie him that would improve our ruck depth.

I am not a fan of Ben Kennedy.

Newton is limited.

Michie is a VFL player.

Spencer was great, in the ruck and around the ground. Gave a couple of frees away only because he tried so hard. He is a handy backup to Gawn.

Redleg Legend

Redleg   42,189

Posted
Posted
16 minutes ago, chook fowler said:

ANB was a pass. Kennedy really disappointing. McInerny looked much better than Spence who seems to be going nowhere fast.

Disagree I thought Spencer was good.

Redleg Legend

Redleg   42,189

Posted
Posted
6 minutes ago, big_red_fire_engine said:

Joel Smith. 

Thought he looked very promising. Nice disposal as well. Not slow either.


DeeSpencer Legend

DeeSpencer   26,711

Posted
Posted

Oliver - a beast built for finals
Salem - a class above until he fell victim to the North Port appealing cricket wickets
Dunn - excellent

ANB - effort is there but decision making bad
Joel Smith - needs to work on his consistency but he does some great things and a willing tackler
Garland - pretty solid, finished on the bench?

Michie - decent enough, tackling and contested ball were good
Mitch White - solid enough, especially before tweaking an ankle. Intercept marking very goo
Newton - similar to Michie
Matt Jones - the good and the bad, high work rate
Trengove - some classy moments but very slow and unable to pressure up forward or escape from contests

Weids - not his day, constantly in packs against 4 opponents and 3 team mates, couldn't impact defensively. Did bring the ball to ground though so there was a bit of positive
Kennedy - rarely sighted and scrappy, didn't get in to any space
Spencer - rubbish but did at least nullify Meese

Terlich, Grimes and maybe Hulett to come in next week. Salem particularly would be in doubt. Then there might be someone unlucky. Keilty, Hutchins, Smith in particular were great from the Casey boys and others made contributions. McInerny is a prospect.

mo64 Redleg

mo64   5,912

Posted
Posted
23 minutes ago, Redleg said:

Disagree I thought Spencer was good.

We must have been watching a different game. He did nothing in the ruck, and when the ball is kicked high in his vicinity, he can't read the flight of the ball to get in a position to mark. I'd rather have either of Footscrays's ruckmen in Minson or Campbell as back up to Gawn.

Baffling decision to give him a 1 year extension mid year. 

DeeSpencer Legend

DeeSpencer   26,711

Posted
Posted
34 minutes ago, Redleg said:

Disagree I thought Spencer was good.

Can't mark, doesn't spoil with authority, missed a simple set shot, gave away a bunch of silly frees. 

He cracks in and makes his presence felt but even at VFL level he doesn't have any footy smarts. The young fella showed more footy smarts in short bursts than Spencer has in 5 years.

And his hit out numbers are bogus because he doesn't have any control of the contest to hit to advantage. He limited the VFL's best ruckman and an important player, but I expected more. 

Campbell's not in great form and will play forward a fair bit but I expect Minson to work Spencer over in the ruck duels. Despite being one of the most physically imposing guys he still has very little strength in ruck contests. He's only a few cms shorter, has plenty of leap and is probably stronger but Gawn smashes him at training just as Jamar used to.


Redleg Legend

Redleg   42,189

Posted
Posted
15 minutes ago, mo64 said:

We must have been watching a different game. He did nothing in the ruck, and when the ball is kicked high in his vicinity, he can't read the flight of the ball to get in a position to mark. I'd rather have either of Footscrays's ruckmen in Minson or Campbell as back up to Gawn.

Baffling decision to give him a 1 year extension mid year. 

Must have been. 

Spencer started a lot our play by picking up the ball and giving it to a team mate. 

I would also say his pressure acts stats were high.  

It was hard to direct hit outs to a loose man, as there weren't any around the contest, due to the way both clubs play man on man, leading to a lot of ball ups  

He negated Meese's usual influence and was scragged relentlessly by Meese at every ball up.  

Thought he did ok. 


DeeSpencer Legend

DeeSpencer   26,711

Posted
Posted
10 minutes ago, dazzledavey36 said:

Not good news..

Casey Scorpions coach Justin Plapp already ruling Christian Salem out of the @VFL GF. 'Really bad concussion, that one', he said.

Would love the club (be that Melb or Casey) to put a complaint in to the VFL about the surface. Those practice wickets looked like they were ready to play on.

SaberFang Trident

SaberFang   7,151

Posted
Posted
4 minutes ago, DeeSpencer said:

Would love the club (be that Melb or Casey) to put a complaint in to the VFL about the surface. Those practice wickets looked like they were ready to play on.

Dreading next week at Etihad, another shitheap of a surface.

chook fowler Trident

chook fowler   19,783

Posted
Posted
1 hour ago, Redleg said:

Disagree I thought Spencer was good.

Spence tried I'll give you that but struggled against a smaller opponent in Meese and can't take a mark to save himself.


Archived

This topic is now archived and is closed to further replies.

Go to topic listing
×
×
  • Create New...