WELCOME TO THE MELBOURNE FOOTBALL CLUB - MICHAEL HIBBERD

[stuie 7,374]

4 minutes ago, AngryAtCasey said:

So your obviously assuming that we're destined for a bottom 4-6 finish then if you think our 2nd Round Pick next year will be around 26 after free agent compensation etc?

Errrrr no, but you seem to think we're going to win the flag if you think next year's second rounder will be lower than 36...

 

[beelzebub 23,254]

42 minutes ago, Bring Back Barassi said:

Looks more like we met them half way

epedience can open up other opportunities whilst time exists.

we're not finished yet imho

[stuie 7,374]

8 minutes ago, Lucifer's Hero said:

I think Newton's fate was sealed before we got Lewis but don't want to update info until these things are said by the club (Ditto Dawes, rookies etc)

I was simply answering your question about pick 84 and the number of vacancies we may have.

I'm just walking through the hypotheticals..

 

[jnrmac 19,949]

1 hour ago, Jaded said:

Why?

Hibberd is a very very good player, and will make a great structural difference to our side, by allowing Hunt and Salem to play wings. He is in his prime at 26. 

Pick 29 has a 50-50 chance of being a dud. 

We have so many kids on our list, draft picks aren't what we need right now. 

Good deal, and welcome Hibbo. My Essendon friend is crying into his coffee as we speak!

I think its more like 20/30 chance of being a poor pick............

 

29	Eric MacKenzie	West Coast	Claremont	2006
29	Tom Clurey	Port Adelaide	Murray U18	2012
29	Byron Donnellan	Geelong	Donald	1990
29	Touk Miller	Gold Coast	Calder U18	2014
29	Matthew Connell	West Coast	Subiaco	1991
29	Ben McKinley	West Coast	Northern U18	2005
29	Todd Curley	Western Bulldogs	West Perth	1995
29	Lewis Roberts-Thomson	Sydney Swans	NSW-ACT U18	2001
29	Adam Hunter	West Coast	Swan Districts	1999
29	Luke Shackleton	Collingwood	Tasmania U18	2002
29	Scott Lycett	West Coast	Port Adelaide (SANFL)	2010
29	Jack Gunston	Adelaide	Sandringham U18	2009
29	Tim Schmidt	Sydney Swans	West Adelaide	2003
29	Jason Torney	Richmond	South Adelaide	1994
29	Brendan Whitecross	Hawthorn	Zillmere	2007
29	Craig Walker	Melbourne	North Hobart	1986
29	Sam Phillipou	Western Bulldogs	Woodville-West Torrens	1992
29	Nathan Turvey	Hawthorn	South Fremantle	1996
29	Andrew Pascoe	Collingwood	Norwood	1987
29	Dayne Beams	Collingwood	Southport	2008
29	Marc Woolnough	Geelong	Southport	1997
29	Alex Forster	Fremantle	Norwood	2011
29	Rory Lobb	Greater Western Sydney	Swan Districts	2013
29	Scott Mollard	Essendon	Central U18	1993
29	Alex Morgan	Essendon	Oakleigh U18	2015
29	Wayne Campbell	Richmond	Golden Square	1989
29	Matt Rosa	West Coast	North Ballarat U18	2004
29	Tyson Stenglein	Adelaide	Subiaco	1998
29	Jamie Charman	Brisbane Lions	Northern Eagles	2000
29	Tim Allen	St Kilda	Mornington	1988

[ArtificialWisdom 4,045]

16 minutes ago, AngryAtCasey said:

So we don't go a full year without injecting any young talent.

2 days ago I would have agreed with you but I think now the Hibbard and Lewis deals are in, unless we can get an overwhelimgly good deal we should secure all our picks next year leaving us in a strong position to draft or trade next year with a full list of 2017 and 18 draft picks

[The Chazz 4,077]

3 minutes ago, stuie said:

You do understand that IF Dunn gets traded THEN the rest of the scenario changes yeah?

 

Presumably for the better for us.  Which would then validate my thinking of not upgrading the two rookies this year.

[Demonland 70,705]

 

[Nasher 33,607]

3 minutes ago, jnrmac said:

I think its more like 20/30 chance of being a poor pick............

 

29	Eric MacKenzie	West Coast	Claremont	2006
29	Tom Clurey	Port Adelaide	Murray U18	2012
29	Byron Donnellan	Geelong	Donald	1990
29	Touk Miller	Gold Coast	Calder U18	2014
29	Matthew Connell	West Coast	Subiaco	1991
29	Ben McKinley	West Coast	Northern U18	2005
29	Todd Curley	Western Bulldogs	West Perth	1995
29	Lewis Roberts-Thomson	Sydney Swans	NSW-ACT U18	2001
29	Adam Hunter	West Coast	Swan Districts	1999
29	Luke Shackleton	Collingwood	Tasmania U18	2002
29	Scott Lycett	West Coast	Port Adelaide (SANFL)	2010
29	Jack Gunston	Adelaide	Sandringham U18	2009
29	Tim Schmidt	Sydney Swans	West Adelaide	2003
29	Jason Torney	Richmond	South Adelaide	1994
29	Brendan Whitecross	Hawthorn	Zillmere	2007
29	Craig Walker	Melbourne	North Hobart	1986
29	Sam Phillipou	Western Bulldogs	Woodville-West Torrens	1992
29	Nathan Turvey	Hawthorn	South Fremantle	1996
29	Andrew Pascoe	Collingwood	Norwood	1987
29	Dayne Beams	Collingwood	Southport	2008
29	Marc Woolnough	Geelong	Southport	1997
29	Alex Forster	Fremantle	Norwood	2011
29	Rory Lobb	Greater Western Sydney	Swan Districts	2013
29	Scott Mollard	Essendon	Central U18	1993
29	Alex Morgan	Essendon	Oakleigh U18	2015
29	Wayne Campbell	Richmond	Golden Square	1989
29	Matt Rosa	West Coast	North Ballarat U18	2004
29	Tyson Stenglein	Adelaide	Subiaco	1998
29	Jamie Charman	Brisbane Lions	Northern Eagles	2000
29	Tim Allen	St Kilda	Mornington	1988

You can't look at it like that.  What if pick 30 had a better strike rate? Would you then conclude that you'd prefer to have pick 30 than pick 29?

[MadAsHell 4,209]

9 minutes ago, stuie said:

Errrrr no, but you seem to think we're going to win the flag if you think next year's second rounder will be lower than 36...

 

Well Pick 36 this year was held by a club that was knocked out in a semi, so I hardly think we're going to win the flag.  You obviously don't think any free agents will move next year if you think Pick 36 will stay with the premiers.

[Little Richard 6,220]

4 minutes ago, Nasher said:

You can't look at it like that.  What if pick 30 had a better strike rate? Would you then conclude that you'd prefer to have pick 30 than pick 29?

Kind of like flipping a coin a hundred times and getting 70% heads. Those results aren't going to affect your next coin toss at all.

[stuie 7,374]

5 minutes ago, AngryAtCasey said:

Well Pick 36 this year was held by a club that was knocked out in a semi, so I hardly think we're going to win the flag.  You obviously don't think any free agents will move next year if you think Pick 36 will stay with the premiers.

I didn't say it would stay with the premiers, but that's a pretty big gamble to say we have to at least make a semi for the trade to simply be equal worth.

Also, who even knows if FA compensation will exist next year? Will there be priority picks for anyone next year? Just more gambles. I prefer to play it safe than gamble away our future.

 

[Dr. Gonzo 23,977]

17 hours ago, ProDee said:

That's not my recollection.

We would've had to have been pretty ignorant to not see the writing on the wall, or at the very least factor it in as a possibility.

[P-man 13,366]

Just happy to get it done. The upgrade softens it slightly given our ability to find players around that pick.

Dodoro was never going to budge. I wouldn't have put it past him to keep Hibberd on for next season if we didn't play ball.

Hopefully that's the last we have to deal with them for a while.

[Ethan Tremblay 30,510]

Hibberd vs another skinny kid from the draft? We're one of the youngest teams in the comp. This is a great result. 

[jnrmac 19,949]

28 minutes ago, Nasher said:

You can't look at it like that.  What if pick 30 had a better strike rate? Would you then conclude that you'd prefer to have pick 30 than pick 29?

I just did. I was responding to a comment that pick 29 has a 50/50 strike rate. I say its worse than that. If you want to have a discussion about whether you would prefer Michael Hibberd OR have pick 29 and be able to choose from a pool of 500 to find someone better good luck.  I'll leave you to it.

It was about whether Hibberd is worth pick 29 which I happen to think he is. He is exactly of the age, hardness, experience etc that we need.

[Willmoy1947 4,017]

2 hours ago, beelzebub said:

we are now a football team relying less on the magical maybe out one of raw kids and focusing on ready to go types for TODAY. Tomorrow will be fine.

Welcome Michael

First name terms now Beez

[daisycutter 29,491]

anyone know what bomberblitz are saying?

[Little Richard 6,220]

58 minutes ago, Ethan Tremblay said:

Hibberd vs another skinny kid from the draft? We're one of the youngest teams in the comp. This is a great result. 

I'm sure we could have drafted an obese kid if we really wanted to.

[monoccular 17,360]

2 hours ago, stuie said:

Geez that's a massive slide in points from 47 to 57, didn't realize the difference was so great.

As for our list, as it stands we have 1 free spot right? So if we traded Dunn and delisted Dawes that makes 3 spots. Then using 1 draft pick and upgrading two rookies fills those 3 spots. Correct? And we don't have to use all our picks, just 3.

I know we can use our last picks to upgrade, but why would we bother using pick 84 in the draft?

 

Chris Grant.   Drug Lord Jim?

[Willmoy1947 4,017]

10 minutes ago, daisycutter said:

anyone know what bomberblitz are saying?

Sh#T, bugger and F##K

[chook fowler 19,306]

5 minutes ago, willmoy said:

Sh#T, bugger and F##K

How naughty of them

[At Least I Saw a Flag 5,177]

Is Hibberd a better player than Melksham? Are they similar types? Did MFC need both? Are there any other questions I should be asking? If yes, what are they?

Edited October 19, 2016 by bingers
wrong spelling

[old55 23,120]

2 hours ago, AngryAtCasey said:

Next move.  Dunn, Pick 57 & 59 (340 points) to the filth for Picks 47 (316) & 83 (0) .  Puts them in a better position re father/sons.

The trade next years future 2nd Round Pick to Saints for 36.

Can't work Garland into it somewhere

[Bluey's Dad 3,419]

38 minutes ago, daisycutter said:

anyone know what bomberblitz are saying?

They called their draft forums "Essendon is not appealing draft board".

I lol'd.

[Gator 17,261]

1 hour ago, Dr. Gonzo said:

We would've had to have been pretty ignorant to not see the writing on the wall, or at the very least factor it in as a possibility.

Which is not what you said.