I just thought i'd start this thread so I could say let's drop OMac, Kent, Newton etc, etc, etc.

Nev Jetta, I don't know where we'd be without you. The only player who doesn't get intoxicated on their own bathwater after a win (over sides that are even worse than us).

I've said it before and I'll say it again, we play DUMB football sometimes. There was one point when Tmac marked on the back flank. Garland was well clear and calling for it on the wing. Tmac decides to switch to the opposite flank. Bad idea, bad kick, kicks inaccurately to a one on two. Contest, port win it and a Port goal. This was in the second quarter when we were fighting late in the quarter to get back. JUST DUMB!!!!! Momentum gone. Balloon pricked by stupidity! ARGHHHHH!

Need experience vs the Hawks...  Trenners and Dunn in for starters

Could be the start of a very, very lean run...

Trenners needs 3 come in I don't care who goes out from Wagner Newton Harmes etc....

ATma ofters ignores obvious safe choice 4 a risky switch play across half back 2 a contest they rebound & goal not smart footy we have a lot of dumb footballers in our team maybe some like Tmac  r a little 2 arrogant 4 their own good

It's not that hard to spell entire words.

O Macdonald out Dunn in. We are playing the hawks. At least Dunn is experienced. They will tear Oscar apart. Dawes has to come back to give us another target up the ground and help Gawn in the ruck. Bring in Trenners for Kennedy or Kent. 

Out: Oscar, Newton, Tyson, Garland

In:  Trengove Dunn Grimes, Dawes

Garland could have a cracked cheekbone  according to roos. So can you get reported for accidently throwing your elbow back and doing that damage? 

Roos: I've got to take responsibility for not making more changes for this week. We spoke about it at match committee

Sounds like he may think that decision this week and may make a few. 

I thought Garland was ok

I hope the selectors start this week with a clean sheet of paper and look long and hard at the players to ensure we are picking a team we think will win rather than picking a team we hope might win.

I would drop 7 on their play and form today and Viney might get a week on top of that for,being stupid.

OMac and Garland out of the backs with Wagner in line fora drop as well. Replace them with Dunn, Frost and Grimes. They coUtd not be any worse. 

Oliver, Vdb and Trengove to come into the midfield in place of Kennedy, Bugg and ANB.

get Dawes or Pedersen in in place of Kent.

 

Out - O MacDonald, Kent, Harmes, Garland)

In - Dunn, Trengove, Grimes, Pederson, 

out: Oscar, Harmes, Garland, Kennedy, Tyson

In: Trengove, Frost, Dunn, Oliver, van Demon

Wake half the team and see if they can be bothered turning up.

In mix for Outs: Newton, ANB, maybe Kent and OMac (not sure we have a better option than him though), Garland (concussion?)

In mix for Ins: Trenners, Frost (back), Dawes/Pedo (forward) and Oliver

Require a jolly good flogging: Tyson, Garlett, Kennedy and Hogan's set shot.

Updates please?: Lumumble, Salem, AvB

It makes no difference who plays. We'll lose by at least 10 goals.

2 minutes ago, Moonshadow said:

Wake half the team and see if they can be bothered turning up.

In mix for Outs: Newton, ANB, maybe Kent and OMac (not sure we have a better option than him though), Garland (concussion?)

In mix for Ins: Trenners, Frost (back), Dawes/Pedo (forward) and another mid.

Require a jolly good flogging: Tyson, Garlett, Kennedy and Hogan's set shot.

Updates please?: Lumumble, Salem, ANB

Ollie Choo Choo presumably. Corky should be ok.

Garland should be dumped and never play AFL again.

Out: Oscar, newton, Anb, harmes 

In: frost, trengove, Oliver, Pedersen.

 Hawks are just travelling. We will win next week

OMFG  we are a developing team ..  saw a post elsewhere about our young/inexperienced list being a convenient "Ëxcuse" for our performance 

For me its more like the "Reason"

We will learn from this and realistically be in contention by 2018 as befits our current progress

Still hard to listen to though 

 

 

In line to be dropped: Harmes, Kent, OMac, ANB, Newton, Kennedy (if injured), Tyson (if ill).

Too hard to say who will come in until Casey plays but we need a second tall (Pedersen/Dawes), we need to replace OMac who is simply not ready for AFL football right now. Oliver comes back if he's fit, and maybe Grimes or Trengove get their chance.

outs. Viney (suspended for stupidity) garland o.mcd newton kent and Hunt... no passengers from now

ins. dunn frost trengove grimes pedersen oliver vandenburg

Jetta  T.mcd Dunn

Vince Frost Wagner

Stretch Trengove Harmes

Kennedy Pedersen Petraccccccccca

Garlett Hogan Watts

Gawn Tyson N.Jones

VDBERGER Grimes Oliver bugg

I thought Kent was alright. OMac definitely isn't up to it at the moment. We've missed Lumumba, he was in his best form for us before this prolonged concussion. Dunn is the absolute must include though, for god's sake

Garland was OK. But OMac is painful to watch. It's just like watching another young Zac Dawson. Seriously, what does he bring?

Dunn in for Omac.

Thought Wagner made some bad choices although he had reasonable numbers. Harry O in if fit.

I thought Watts was really good - medium numbers at high efficiency. But we need a proper second tall forward/2nd ruck (Watts to be the Gunston role).

Dawes or Pedo required back in ASAP. Maybe Newton out for that one.

Out OMac, Wagner, Newton.

In Dunn Dawes and Harry O.

Does it matter who is in or out?  Play any 22 fit players. This is the classic deck chairs shuffling match.  There is not the mental hardness  and resolve to overcome teams that habitually  kick the proverbial sand in our face. If we win it will be a greater aberration than last years win over Geelong.  

Out: Newton, ANB, Oscar, Garland, Kent, Viney ( if susp)

In: Grimes, Pedersen/Dawes, Frost, Dunn, Oliver, Trengove (if Viney susp)

FB: Jetta   Frost   Dunn
HB: Vince  T Mc   Wagner
C:  Bugg  Jones  Stretch
HF: Petracca  Hogan  Kennedy
FF: Garlett   Watts   Pedda/Dawes
Foll: Gawn   Oliver   Tyson
Int: Hunt  Harmes  Grimes Trengove