Why o why o why...........nah please let him go to Essendon or Carlton.

Dud - pass

Look, I was going to just write 'No' but that isn't fair - I don't see him with a role in this team. Far too slight to be back up ruck and Watts or Howe would be a better option as a third tall in the forward line.

I really cannot understand how he played on Sat Night with Stringer, Crameri, and Dickson in that forward line.

He is also not a great footy player, soft, and with adequate to sub par skills.

So...

No.

FFS close this thread there is genuine possibilities and then there is stupidity

It would finally be the end for me.

It would be confirmation that God hates me.

Haha god no

How has this thread got to two pages already. Delete!

#PutOutYourSpuds

a giant King Edward

Hell no to this bloke.

Hes another Jack Watts.

A poor mans Colin Garland, and Garland ain't all that rich.

I'm barracking for GWS if this bloke comes to the Dees.

Can u get a free agent and put him straight onto the rookie list?

Garland is a much better footballer

Someone please make this stop, I can't handle it!

Is there any player we're not considering?

He's a wingman, but not in a sophisticated team, he's best chance is actually in the role he played for the Dogs most of this year in a helter skelter team. But they're clearly trying to move him on.

It's still a position of huge weakness for us but I think we'd rather keep playing the extra inside mid and being a bit slow/uncreative than wasting time with Grant.