Changes for Round 4

[Adzman 2,154]

We have Gawn, Spencer, Fitzpatrick and Pedo and none of them fill me with confidence. Our tall timber stocks might need reviewing if one or two of these names can't claim and hold onto a spot with frosty out.

Jamar has 1 year left at best. Russian looks gassed. Who has what it takes to be a top ruck?

[Cheesy D. Pun 1,762]

I think Spencil will come in for Frost and one of JKH and Kent needs to go.

Watts is on very thin ice.

I reckon JKH is not yet up to the tempo of the game at AFL level but I don't think he's going to get that by playing VFL. I'd like to see him stay. Also, I'd suspect Kent's early hit on <insert adelaide player here> will come under scrutiny.

[highroller 112]

no changes unless forced with Frost and or Bernie if the tribunal gets him.

If Bernie is out lets just revert back to round 1 team and drop Dawes. Michie can take Viney's place.

[Dee-licious 1,949]

Are we one too tall with Frost? Once he went off we didnt feel too small. Although I would like some support for Jamar I just think we are one too tall. Saying that I dont think we drop anyone unless we have too (injury or suspension). Some bad individual moments but not enough to really demand someone being dropped. What an odd feeling.

[dazzledavey36 54,302]

out : Frost, Jetta ( ducking to avoid conflict cost us a goal) Kent

In : Gawn, Grimes & Michie.

Assuming the casey form is much the same as last week.

Worst post of the year.

[Fork 'em 6,983]

Vince might not play.
Kent might not either.

[Barney Rubble 1,576]

I can't even deal with this. Seriously. Can you find the footage. All I saw from Jetta was him keeping Betts to 1 goal and winning a heap of contested possessions.

Are you one of the clowns who think Jetta took a dive in the first game?

Kent???? For Michie. Laughable. Yeah he misses some chances. But seriously. He's not going anywhere.

Last quarter.

And no. I wasn't one of the clowns.

Jetta is one of my fav. players.

But when you duck like he did today, sorry he must pay the penalty.

[Wiseblood 24,637]

Last quarter.

And no. I wasn't one of the clowns.

Jetta is one of my fav. players.

But when you duck like he did today, sorry he must pay the penalty.

He won't though because he gave Betts an absolute bath.

I notice though that you aren't dropping Watts even though his was far more blatant... care to explain?

[Lil_red_fire_engine 11,116]

I think we are still playing 2 mids short in the 21. Brayshaw should start. One of JKH or Kent should play as sub. Frost out injured. Just bring in another runner (Michie, Toumpas, Jones or Grimes) and put up with Dawes playing small minutes as ruck relief. Its not like Richmond have two recognised rucks.

[Samael 560]

We still need run and speed. Particularly in a substitute if we're hoping they get through to 3/4 time to make an impact.

Yet I don't want to add Toumpas unless they are confident it will be a real Toumpas. Confident. Skilled. Speedy. Hard at it.

Would love to drop Watts. Maybe the sub role? But if we don't play a 2nd ruck we need someone who can draw the ball. Notice I didn't say take a mark. I think he stays. But if Roos, Jones or anyone else gets the question about his play this week they better not sugar coat the answer.

So someone in for Frost. I agree it's worth the risk of Dawes rucking. Don't mind the Watts rucking idea either.

Yeah Michie's probably the frontrunner for the spot. But I want to see reports that he's really impacting the game and running!!! Otherwise Matt Jones, Roh Bail, James Harmes or even Billy Stretch in as the sub. Why not?

So his three goals last week did nothing for you. Played of the HBF in the last quarter and kicked a ripper on the run. I think he would contribute more than JKH did today.

[Moonshadow 17,675]

It's a shame that selection is based upon what we have rather than those who deserve to play next week. Otherwise Watts, Dawes, Kent and one or two others would be playing at Casey.

[Demon Dynasty 17,109]

Matt Jones > Jetta - Looked lost down back today... more work needed at VFL level. Jones isn't the greatest player of all time but at least he runs lines out of half back and makes his opponent work hard going the other way. Jetta rarely does this. Jones would need to clean up his disposal skills and choices coming off HB though as he was pretty horrid last year and will often undo his good work with some pretty bad clangers in mid field. I would rank Jones a fair margin above Jetta at this stage of their carreers in a team ranking sense.

Michie > JKH - doesn't look ready for rigours of AFL right now week in and week out. Would only play him within a 40 meter arc of goal at this early stage of his career hovering around HULK in small stints for 10 minutes here and there IF he is in. Lost anywhere else. Loves to kick goals and knows where the goals are unlike most of our other forwards atm and worth persevering with in this role. However, at this stage of their careers i would also rank Michie well ahead of JKH in a total match (output) team ranking.

Perderson > Watts - [Pedersen] for all day gut running/effort/attack on the ball/ball carrier and occasional overhead mark. Can kick occasional goal but not the most gifted player in general play. Watts the opposite of all this and probably about the same output on the scoreboard if Pedo played up forward. Pedo will at least bring more balls to the ground in a contest as well which might give our smalls a few more opportunites to goal. I don't expect Pedo will give all that much more in a scoreboard sense than Watts but at least he wont do as many of the moral sapping things that we see Watts do a little too often.

I would only play Dawes through HB and Ruck (when resting the Russian). Useless up forward and will only get in the road of the Hulk's development. Replace with Howe for the X factor and ability to take an overhead keping the ball in OUR forward line for longer periods of time easing the pressure off our D a little.

Edited April 18, 2015 by Rusty Nails

[Moonshadow 17,675]

Matt Jones in for Jetta. Now I've heard it all!

[Wiseblood 24,637]

Matt Jones in for Jetta. Now I've heard it all!

I can't even fathom how someone could even suggest dropping Nev. Betts hardly saw it all day!

[dee-luded 2,959]

OUT: Frost

IN: Pedersen

Let's reward our team's good efforts this week by setting this as our base team. You want in? Earn it in the VFL.

could be Frost inj, & Watts vomited. for Spencil, & Bail/MJones/Toumpas? or as you say, just the one change with Pedo for frosty. frosty hasn't given us a lot since the first game, I think.

I think we need better marking power up front, & also some more willing run.

[Queanbeyan Demon 6,840]

Out Watts, in Kylie Minogue

[Fork 'em 6,983]

Lol

[Chook 15,012]

Pedo for the ruck replacement. Watts will never be dropped, so he's in. Dawes is a useful player for our structure and on-field leadership.

Edited April 18, 2015 by Chook

[Nasher 33,607]

I hope today puts an end to all the talk of having Dawes as the fill in ruck. For all the talk of concrete hands, they've got nothing on his bricks for feet. The guy can't jump at all.

Question for Pig Dog et al, when was this alleged duck of Jetta's that cost a goal? If it's the occasion I'm thinking of, my view was that he fumbled it then got pushed off the ball while surrounded by three crows players on his own. I'm not ever in favour of dropping a player over a single incident, but if that's the one then you are being harsh to the point of ridiculousness.

[Barney Rubble 1,576]

I hope today puts an end to all the talk of having Dawes as the fill in ruck. For all the talk of concrete hands, they've got nothing on his bricks for feet. The guy can't jump at all.

Question for Pig Dog et al, when was this alleged duck of Jetta's that cost a goal? If it's the occasion I'm thinking of, my view was that he fumbled it then got pushed off the ball while surrounded by three crows players on his own. I'm not ever in favour of dropping a player over a single incident, but if that's the one then you are being harsh to the point of ridiculousness.

That is the incident, I looked at it several times.

The fumble was only because he took his eye off the ball because the forth coming high tackle.

[Nasher 33,607]

That is the incident, I looked at it several times.

The fumble was only because he took his eye off the ball because the forth coming high tackle.

So in that split second, reflex moment he should have __________________ instead?

I stand by my comment of harsh to the point of ridiculousness then. If you want to blame his fumble on a lack of desire to have his head removed from his body, then I'll never endorse that and I doubt Roos will either. I get criticising players for soft efforts - a non-marking effort by one of our forwards today sticks to mind - but jeez, I think players also have a right to safety.

Edited April 18, 2015 by Nasher

[Barney Rubble 1,576]

So in that split second, reflex moment he should have __________________ instead?

I stand by my comment of harsh to the point of ridiculousness then. If you want to blame his fumble on a lack of desire to have his head removed from his body, then I'll never endorse that and I doubt Roos will either. I get criticising players for soft efforts - a non-marking effort by one of our forwards today sticks to mind - but jeez, I think players also have a right to safety.

My opinion your opinion.

As for the other incident I only watched the 2nd half.

[dees189227 12,373]

what about Pedersen for Frost, and Grimes for JKH.

[Gator 17,281]

Watts is the softest "good" player I've seen. But he's not going to get dropped over a couple of spilt marks when marks are routinely dropped by others.

If I'd been in charge he'd no longer be on the list, but he'll play because he is on the list and if we want to beat Richmond a good Watts game can make a difference.

[What 18,810]

We've gone in 1 midfielder short the last 2 weeks.

In both games one of Dawes or Frost shouldn't have played and Michie should have.

Must get the balance right against the Tigers and every week after that