WELCOME TO THE MELBOURNE FOOTBALL CLUB - HERITIER LUMUMBA

[bing181 8,174]

.... She now realises that gay men are normal .... On the flip side, I don't flaunt any overt gay behaviour ...

If gay men are normal, what would gay behaviour be, overt or not?

[beelzebub 22,225]

bb I think Roos is the one who needs to be convinced.

U along with all of us are not important enough for the club to concern themselves with convincing us.

In terms of my opinion, my viewpoint for my understandings etc..... I need to be convinced.

Of course thats irrelevant to anything the club would consider. its been a while actually since they wanted my opinion, think it was the summit now I think of it and they didnt put much of what I suggested to use then either...lol

[Biffen 12,343]

The fact that Harry takes himself extremely seriously seems to be his major character flaw.

Australians tend to be quick to shoot down pretentious people who concern themselves wrih moral questions or individual rights ( different from the group).

I don't mind people who take a stand but FFS make it over something important.

Harry is a solo act.

Not destined to be in a band.

I have gay mates who would be very, very difficult to offend.

Some of the filthiest language in the world comes from queens.

His first issue with Buckley was over Seedsmans haircut which looked like a very lesbian type of boys cut so they called him"les".

When I read that I actually thought Buckley was a fairly humorous type to come up with that one and the ask"are you ok with that Harry?"

Harry wasn't Ok with that .

Harry lives in a PC bubble- not in reality.

I wish him the best in politics or whatever his field is .

As a footballer he is irrelevant.

He stands on principles and Pepsi ads also.

[Demonsterative 1,961]

If gay men are normal, what would gay behaviour be, overt or not?

I don't ham it up is what I meant, I thought that was obvious. I also don't swear in front of her (In other words ham it up). I thinks that's a fairly generic term that I hope you understand.

Your not attacking me coz I outed myself in this thread? Coz that would be wrong and I would take HL like offence to that.....

[Biffen 12,343]

Good on you Demonstrative for being open with us all.

Although I would love it if you turned up to work in full drag singing " it's raining men".

I think the Muslim lady would probably love it as well.

And it would make " the office" look tame.

[ILLDieADemon 804]

We need some e experience in defence.

Might be worth it for a couple of seasons.

[binman 38,528]

At no stage did I say BT's account was gospel. In fact, I qualified it with this rider: "Make of it what you will."

You're right in that we all have different opinions about journos and the reliability and accuracy of their stories. I'm inclined to believe that the info that's out there on this one - including BT's - is close to bang on.

Let's face it, it doesn't paint H in a particularly good light. If it was largely untrue, or there was an alternative version of events, either H or his manager would have moved to set the record straight by now.

Fair enough. But i would not be surprised if there was more to this story than has come out. I heard BT again give that spiel today and he made it clear there were a number of issues. The poster was - according to BT - the straw that broke the camels back, so to speak and cam after he had already raised concerns about the culture of homophobia at the club. Interestingly for those accusing him of grandstanding that was kept in house and HT didn't make any public statement (indeed he hasn't made any full stop, except i suppose meeting with an opposition coach!)

[Dr John Dee 1,057]

Time to get off your Soap Box Dr! Not sure why HL seems to think that the gay community needs his assistance? Maybe he is pink suede himself.

As a out and very proud gay man I'm offended by HL's behaviour. Lighten up FFS. Gone are the days that the Gay Community need to fight every battle to get acceptance in mainstream society. We have moved past that school boy banter and have moved onto more pressing issues such as rights for Civil Union, rights to parenthood etc etc.

Me and my community use this kind of humour on a daily basis. Why? Coz it's funny.

Me and my community.

So who's on a soapbox then? When did you get to speak for your 'community' as if that's a single, undifferentiated thing?

[jabberwocky 2,301]

Me and my community.

So who's on a soapbox then? When did you get to speak for your 'community' as if that's a single, undifferentiated thing?

Ffs.

He uses self deprecating humour with his gay mates. Is he not able to say that?

Edited September 6, 2014 by jabberwocky

[Dr John Dee 1,057]

Ffs.

He uses self deprecating humour with his gay mates. Is he not able to say that?

FFS read his post.

[jabberwocky 2,301]

FFS read his post.

I did, the difference being that I comprehended it.

[Dr John Dee 1,057]

I did, the difference being that I comprehended it.

Congratulations! A real achievement, especially comprehending it without any grasp of the difference between a group of mates and a community. Mind you, with a name like Jabberwocky perhaps you believe that words mean what you want them to rather than what they actually mean.

Edited September 6, 2014 by Dr John Dee

[Bitter but optimistic 21,329]

In fact, my sexuality has been on the end of some very inappropriate jokes in the workplace, and I have used inappropriate comments about heterosexuality. It's all part of the fun at laughing at and with myself and others. No one is getting hurt. No one is fearful, nor are they angry.

I work with a Muslim lady, who has very strong homophobic views. We don't talk about them but we know they are there. We get along really well and through just being me, she is learning a lot about the gay community. She now realises that gay men are normal and harmless. On the flip side, I don't flaunt any overt gay behaviour or discussion her way. I respect her faith and culture to much to do that.

If I went down the HL pathway of defending gay rights, I would just reinforce any fixed and uneducated views my Muslim colleague has or had. The best way to break down social stigmas is via engaging people. Not putting them off side.

Sh ite Demonsterative!! Outing on a good, solid, blokey, farting and arse slapping football place. You have shaken my world!!!!

[Biffen 12,343]

Sh ite Demonsterative!! Outing on a good, solid, blokey, farting and arse slapping football place. You have shaken my world!!!!

And now is not the time for you to divulge your sexual proclivities.

We have neither the time nor the stomach to read it.

Although when DC releases his novel

"50 babes of Grey" the Wednesday tennis world will be outraged.

[Bitter but optimistic 21,329]

At least most of us have some morals. I believe dc is totally lacking in this area.

My proclivities shall continue to be proclivitus.

[Bitter but optimistic 21,329]

And now is not the time for you to divulge your sexual proclivities.

We have neither the time nor the stomach to read it.

Although when DC releases his novel

"50 babes of Grey" the Wednesday tennis world will be outraged.

Be more of a memoir I would think.

[beelzebub 22,225]

FFS read his post.

what do you read into it that many of us dont ?

I rate your post SJD im interested

[Nasher 33,107]

what do you read into it that many of us dont ?

I rate your post SJD im interested

He was implying that one gay man does not have the right to speak on behalf of the entire gay community.

[Demonsterative 1,961]

Actually I do have the right to speak on behalf of my community. I can call it my community as I am very much a part of it. The fact is 'gay culture' is very much about taking the [censored] out of sexuality. It ain't all about that, but it's very much is there all to see.

Does dr John Dee have the right to question me, sure he does. But he can't question my experience.

[Tough Kent 2,049]

Reading this thread makes me realise how much I miss watching Melbourne play footy. Now that's really saying something.

Edited September 6, 2014 by Tough Kent

[Ethan Tremblay 28,436]

Actually I do have the right to speak on behalf of my community. I can call it my community as I am very much a part of it. The fact is 'gay culture' is very much about taking the [censored] out of sexuality. It ain't all about that, but it's very much is there all to see.

Does dr John Dee have the right to question me, sure he does. But he can't question my experience.

I like to think that I speak on behalf of the hetro community.

Straight or gay, does anyone really care these days? I like a person for being a good decent person not who they're preference in gender is.

HL is still a toss, he'd help us on field but I doubt he'd help the culture off the field.

Edited September 6, 2014 by Ethan Tremblay

[Moonshadow 16,273]

Actually I do have the right to speak on behalf of my community. I can call it my community as I am very much a part of it. The fact is 'gay culture' is very much about taking the [censored] out of sexuality. It ain't all about that, but it's very much is there all to see.

Does dr John Dee have the right to question me, sure he does. But he can't question my experience.

I've known plenty of young gay people, including direct family who have struggled to come out, feeling like all the snide remarks and put downs about being gay, the social prejudices, family rejections, etc, which are too much for them and it's easier to hide who you are. The consequences for young gay people I have known have often been disastrous and paint a different picture. I don't deny your own experience Demonsterative, and yours might be true for others, but IMO you only have the right to speak for yourself and not all gay people.

[Biffen 12,343]

I'd like to speak on behalf of all the mimes in Australia.

I think it's important to speak up for people who cant find their voice.

[Dr. Gonzo 22,520]

Which is an indictment on the world we live in and unfortunately we have people like yourself to thank for it.

Haha you clown - I never said I was offended by it I couldn't give a stuff really about the specific example thats been mentioned, but it's the reality of the world we live in and it's clear this has been repeated behaviour. Sorry we don't live in a world anymore where idiots can hide behind their pathetic attempts at humour as a way to mask their bigotry and racism. I know you probably think somehow your rights are being trampled on by the PC brigade but for those who don't have to put up with idiots in the workplace anymore I'm sure it makes their life easier.

If the only way you can relate to people is by pathetic attempts at lowest common denominator "humour" then it says a whole lot more about you than the people who may take offence - in fact it's likely they're taking offence at your cringeworthy humour than your racism or bigotry.

[Biffen 12,343]

He was implying that one gay man does not have the right to speak on behalf of the entire gay community.

Only Harry can do that.