My 3 word player analysis V GWS

[joeboy 3,174]

N.Jones - not usual drive

Grimes - loose and careless

Watts - almost no influence

Viney- had no influence

Frawley - worth persevering with

Byrnes - waste of position

Tyson - prolific and tried

Dunn - great first half

Kent - had little influence

Cross - persistent and professional

Pederson - disciplined and effective

Vince - was rarely sighted

Kennedy- Harris - very little opportunity

McDonald - disciplined and effective

Evans - few effective possessions

Howe - classy and composed

Bail - prolific but wasteful

M.Jones - prolific but wasteful

Terlich - horrible decision maker

Fitzpatrick - continued poor season

Georgiou - outstanding under pressure

Spencer - had no idea

Edited April 6, 2014 by joeboy

[Older demon 2,799]

N.Jones - not usual drive

Grimes - loose and careless

Watts - almost no influence

Viney- had no influence

Frawley - worth persevering with

Byrnes - waste of position

Tyson - prolific and tried

Dunn - great first half

Kent - had little influence

Cross - persistent and professional

Pederson - disciplined and effective

Vince - was rarely sighted

Kennedy- Harris - very little opportunity

McDonald - disciplined and effective

Evans - few effective possessions

Howe - classy and composed

Bail - prolific but wasteful

M.Jones - prolific but wasteful

Terlich - horrible decision maker

Fitzpatrick - continued poor season

Georgiou - outstanding under pressure

You forgot Spencer - waste of space

[Devil In Disguise 2,278]

Bail - prolific but wasteful? He only had 13 disposals. You are kidding. He should be dropped along with Grimes & that dud Byrnes.

[DeeSpencer 26,273]

Howe was ok, but not composed. Double hand spoil on the boundary line, missed spoil in the last quarter that led to a Kelly goal but worst of all multiple running torpedos from the back half, I mean what the heck is that all about.

[ILLDieADemon 804]

You could have summed it up in three words for the hole list.

They are [censored]!

[spirit of norm smith 16,615]

We are stuffed.

Only 4-5 players showed AFL standards.

Byrnes, Bail, Evans MUST be DROPPED and ultimately delisted.

[Sad Dee 12]

Watts seemed to be showing some urgency in the contest.

Byrnes - small and slow. Not a good mix.

Kent - he looks OK to me. Has pace and has a go.

Terlich - got caught twice at key times. Didn't look good.

Spencer - like his endeavour but, when your opponent gets 60 hit outs, that's a disaster.

Fitzpatrick - was he playing?

[spirit of norm smith 16,615]

from today

AFL standard: Jones, Tyson, Cross, Howe, Frawley, Grimes, Vince, Watts

Tryers who are in 22nd-30 player depth status: Terlich, M Jones, McDonald, Dunn, Pedersen

Delist: Spencer, bail, byrnes, evans, Fitzpatrick

Developing: Viney, JKH, Gerogiou, kent

You cannot have too many Tryers and Delistees and Developing in your best 22

[Curry & Beer 5,444]

very closely agree joeboy, bit harsh on Watts though

about 6-7 decent players today

[biggestred 5,237]

MFC - Not good enough

MFC - Total utter shite

MFC - i give up

MFC - no one cares

MFC - just fold already

MFC - [censored] this [censored]

[Frosty Demon 153]

True we have very few up to the standard. This is our main problem.

[Frosty Demon 153]

Grimes; admire his courage and commitment but not up to AFL standard. Let Frawley go has been no good since his all Australian year. Watts? sick of waiting, perhaps he will have an impact back at local level.

[Demon Disciple 12,452]

Grimes; admire his courage and commitment but not up to AFL standard. Let Frawley go has been no good since his all Australian year. Watts? sick of waiting, perhaps he will have an impact back at local level.

He's one of the few who might have decent currency on the trade table. Not only that, it would send a huge message to those who remain on the list after our much needed end of year cull, that no-one is safe, not even the captain.

[Undeeterred 3,127]

He's one of the few who might have decent currency on the trade table. Not only that, it would send a huge message to those who remain on the list after our much needed end of year cull, that no-one is safe, not even the captain.

Way to build the culture and purge the memory of rooting Jnrmac, Bruce and Green before their time. Idiotic.

[Undeeterred 3,127]

from today

AFL standard: Jones, Tyson, Cross, Howe, Frawley, Grimes, Vince, Watts

Tryers who are in 22nd-30 player depth status: Terlich, M Jones, McDonald, Dunn, Pedersen

Delist: Spencer, bail, byrnes, evans, Fitzpatrick

Developing: Viney, JKH, Gerogiou, kent

You cannot have too many Tryers and Delistees and Developing in your best 22

Howe and Vince were dreadful today (though are AFL standard normally).

Dunn is close to our best and most reliable at the moment. He's not 'depth'.

[samcantstandya 1,068]

Howe and Vince were dreadful today (though are AFL standard normally).

Dunn is close to our best and most reliable at the moment. He's not 'depth'.

I agree Dunn is playing well and is definitely in the best 22.

[Glenn Molloy 494]

N.Jones - trying too hard
Grimes - robotic and jittery
Watts - sporadic, nice skills
Viney- better for run
Frawley - he's a backman
Byrnes - tried but struggled
Tyson - clever but overwhelmed
Dunn - has finally matured
Kent - shows a bit
Cross - battled hard again
Pederson - better down back
Vince - needs dry track
Kennedy- Harris - shows some promise
McDonald - disciplined and effective
Evans - dropped chest marks
Howe - showed his adaptability
Bail - back to Casey
M.Jones - fringe/depth player
Terlich - copped a spray
Fitzpatrick - just too inconsistent
Georgiou - hard to beat

Spencer - tried but beaten

[Pitchy 196]

copped a spray - haha! That he did.

[Ted Lasso 19,549]

He's one of the few who might have decent currency on the trade table. Not only that, it would send a huge message to those who remain on the list after our much needed end of year cull, that no-one is safe, not even the captain.

Howe and Trengove are the two i'd be floating as trade bait

[Little Richard 6,265]

Howe and Trengove are the two i'd be floating as trade bait

Howe maybe though Trengove is one I think it would be more advantageous to keep and hope that he improves radically because we'll get next to nothing for him.

[Ted Lasso 19,549]

Howe maybe though Trengove is one I think it would be more advantageous to keep and hope that he improves radically because we'll get next to nothing for him.

That's a good point, if we got a second round pick we'd be pretty happy i reckon

[Little Richard 6,265]

That's a good point, if we got a second round pick we'd be pretty happy i reckon

That's an issue though, I wouldn't want to give him away for anything less than an end of first rounder. He's obviously not worth that but there's something inside me that knows that if Trengove goes to another team, he'll become a great player again.