Dylan Shiel

[Adam The God 30,613]

For the same reason we want to spend pick 2 for Rockliff, Shuey, et al.

Skip the dev stage, give the bloke a role and watch him become a star.

I would trade him an established mid, but he has the skills to be Ryan O'Keefe. Get Roos to help him with his finger that's up his arse and get him to work hard off a wing/hff.

I can see where you're coming from with this comparison, rpfc, but IMO Howe's field-kicking is nowhere near O'Keefe's. Work-rate and discipline can be worked on, but field-kicking has that ceiling.

[blue and red in the head 95]

Would anyone be happy with pick 2 and Howe for shiel and gws 2nd round pick (19/20)

[beelzebub 23,390]

why the un-love for Howe ?

[Machsy 2,858]

For the same reason we want to spend pick 2 for Rockliff, Shuey, et al.

Skip the dev stage, give the bloke a role and watch him become a star.

I would trade him an established mid, but he has the skills to be Ryan O'Keefe. Get Roos to help him with his finger that's up his arse and get him to work hard off a wing/hff.

He really looks like a ROK type player...

/retro cliche

[Machsy 2,858]

Would anyone be happy with pick 2 and Howe for shiel and gws 2nd round pick (19/20)

No.

Pick 2 for Shiel is pretty much correct weight.

[beelzebub 23,390]

No.

Pick 2 for Shiel is pretty much correct weight.

I would have thought so...No need for embellishing or dealing past the sale .

[deanox 10,045]

Would anyone be happy with pick 2 and Howe for shiel and gws 2nd round pick (19/20)

No need for Howe in that. A fairer deal would be:

Pick 2 for Sheil and pick 20

but I'd be happy with sheil for pick 2.

[beelzebub 23,390]

how about pick 2 and Blease, Tapscott, Bail, Pedersen, Jetta and Nicholson thrown in for good measure ?

( hell I WOULD throw in #20 if that got that deal through..lol )

Edited October 16, 2013 by beelzebub

[stuie 7,374]

thats right, the last time we allowed one of our players be exploited by our marketing brains-trust, we almost destroyed his career before it even started.

Ohhhh so now it's the marketing team's fault Watts has struggled.... FMD

[beelzebub 23,390]

Ohhhh so now it's the marketing team's fault Watts has struggled.... FMD

didnt you get the memo ??

[CatFishPig 465]

This thread is killing me.. I keep coming back thinking good news, only to find dribble..

[What 18,810]

This thread is killing me.. I keep coming back thinking good news, only to find dribble..

Its the same for every single thread in this sub forum

[spirit of norm smith 16,617]

Dear Dylan

Melbourne Football Club is pleased to offer you a 5 year $500,000 a year (total $2.5million) offer to join us as we embark on re-energizing our club. With Paul Roos leadership, you will form a vital part of a new midfield, alongside Nathan Jones, Jack Viney, Jimmy Toumpas and Jack Trengove. You will play footy on the might MCG, and help us rise once more to excite our loyal supporters.

The Melbourne Football Club would see you as a future leader and a key part of our future.

Peter Jackson

(Dylan Shiel in exchange for MFC pick 2)

[JT9 104]

Dear Dylan

Melbourne Football Club is pleased to offer you a 5 year $500,000 a year (total $2.5million) offer to join us as we embark on re-energizing our club. With Paul Roos leadership, you will form a vital part of a new midfield, alongside Nathan Jones, Jack Viney, Jimmy Toumpas and Jack Trengove. You will play footy on the might MCG, and help us rise once more to excite our loyal supporters.

The Melbourne Football Club would see you as a future leader and a key part of our future.

Peter Jackson

(Dylan Shiel in exchange for MFC pick 2)

If only our club had this conviction.

Make a stand with pick 2 , get guys like this or take it to draft

[dee-luded 2,959]

No need for Howe in that. A fairer deal would be:

Pick 2 for Sheil and pick 20

but I'd be happy with sheil for pick 2.

strait swap Howe for Shiel?

[Demon Forever 219]

strait swap Howe for Shiel?

you have lost it

[dee-luded 2,959]

you have lost it

must have.

[Adam The God 30,613]

If only our club had this conviction.

Make a stand with pick 2 , get guys like this or take it to draft

How do you know they haven't?

[CBDees 3,167]

strait swap Howe for Shiel?

Sheil for pick #2 and keep Howe [for Sheil to kick to]

[Coup Cooper 610]

strait swap Howe for Shiel?

No

[jackaub 1,402]

Frawley for Shiel Simple really!He wont sign so off he goes to GWS!

Its time all at MFC stopped having love-ins over players they are just a means to an end in a ruthless competetive business enviorement

The important thing here is the clubs' future not about any indivigual player

If Frawley wont sign then trade him don't wait and lose the opportunity

[whelan45 203]

Maybe everybody should calm down a bit?

[The Song Formerly Known As 6,479]

when did people fall out of love with Jeremy Howe?

He was our bloody leading goal kicker this season in an area that the ball rarely came down into and when it did it was kicked atrociously?!

Will be much better with some key forwards on the park to take much of the focus off of him.

Get a clue people.

[Dr. Gonzo 24,444]

when did people fall out of love with Jeremy Howe?

He was our bloody leading goal kicker this season in an area that the ball rarely came down into and when it did it was kicked atrociously?!

Will be much better with some key forwards on the park to take much of the focus off of him.

Get a clue people.

I don't think anyone wants to get rid of him because they (we) think he's rubbish. It's more about the fact he has currency and is surplus to our needs up forward. If he can develop into a genuine midfield role I'd prefer to keep him, but I don't see it - he's more of a forward flanker type, something we have an over-abundance of.

[Cheap Seats 3,310]

Frawley for Shiel Simple really!He wont sign so off he goes to GWS!

Its time all at MFC stopped having love-ins over players they are just a means to an end in a ruthless competetive business enviorement

Agree

I support the club not the player - don't get me wrong love Frawley and he's a gun.

THis club will remain a [censored] kicker until it gets ruthless in all aspects of it's operations