Casey Scorpions v Williamstown

[hardtack 10,127]

That post shouldn't really be dignified with a response.

But still you couldn't resist.

[Gorgoroth 12,331]

The times Toumpas got the ball showed why he was pick 4, sure I would have liked to see more but I'm also happy to let him get settled at Casey now he knows what is expected at AFL level.

He played well enough in the NAB cup and in the first game was one of the highest for pressure acts.

[T-34 409]

I have not seen any reason why that kid was taken at pick 4, give me a reason why he was, i cant see it?

Maybe if you opened both eyes...........

[old dee 22,946]

did you know they left the best of the emergencies in Strauss in Melbourne!

Although spencer is a beast at VFL level!

They took Nicholson up I believe so that was probably a bonus for Casey

[Deecisive 1,658]

Give Jimmy some time to get used to the different tempo, he has excellent skills and was highly rated by virtually everyone above Ollie and others, he will do very well once he gets a bit more confidence and he is playing in a team that can deliver it to him better and help him around the ground.

[mjt 640]

hes probably the best kick in the team and runs to space well. Can win his own footy (not at alf level yet). Has exceptional character.

In hindsight I'd plug and play wines but outside skilled types can take time.

Judge him in 3 weeks time he's bound to have at least 1 good VFL game by then

I understand your post, the clubs had multiple outside players,in hindsight i would take wines as well, but who wants a 18 yr old that weighs 88kgs and would run through a brick wall, Im glad J Taylor is there because Todd Viney cant see two foot in front of himself.

[Deemotivated 550]

Glad I wasn't required to be employee of the month in the first 5 weeks of my first job at 18yo...

Give the kid a chance for FFS.

[mjt 640]

Glad I wasn't required to be employee of the month in the first 5 weeks of my first job at 18yo...

Give the kid a chance for FFS.

Fair enough, i would prefer a kid that wont need 3 yrs in the gym, but as one brain fart said, patience is a what ever, lets wait to 2018.

[Deemotivated 550]

From twitter

@CaseyScorpions: Toumpas hits Taggert with perfect pass on the lead and finishes with a bomb from outside 50! #PJVFL

Break Gillies legs... Long term

Injury list??? Lol

[hardtack 10,127]

we havent even heard a report about the game and people are still potting Jimmy T?

christ some people are pathetic

Let's face it, I don't think there is anyone at the club that mjt hasn't potted.

[BrisbaneDemon 1,501]

I understand your post, the clubs had multiple outside players,in hindsight i would take wines as well, but who wants a 18 yr old that weighs 88kgs and would run through a brick wall, Im glad J Taylor is there because Todd Viney cant see two foot in front of himself.

ahhhh hindsight it's a glorious thing, its easy to have pot shots at people from behind a computer isn't it. The bulldogs passed on Wines, i'm guessing their as incompetent as Melbourne as well.

[Deecisive 1,658]

having shots at guys who have just walked in the door is certainly not going to help their development or their love for the club.

[mjt 640]

ahhhh hindsight it's a glorious thing, its easy to have pot shots at people from behind a computer isn't it. The bulldogs passed on Wines, i'm guessing their as incompetent as Melbourne as well.

Are you confident in the players our club selected?

[mjt 640]

having shots at guys who have just walked in the door is certainly not going to help their development or their love for the club.

How did Dom Barry go tonight? there selections are a [censored] joke.

[bing181 8,180]

Hogan is next year, we recruit Jump Jockeys.

You're just being ridiculous.

Viney 82 kg. Kent 82 Kg. Toumpas 79 Kg. Terlich 83 Kg.

For comparison: no. 1 pick Lachie Whitfield: 75 kg. Jake Neade (has been more than useful ...): 67 Kg.

And seeing you refer to Stringer at the Dogs, apart from Dom Barry, all of our picks were heavier than all of their other picks.

Not that that has anything much to do with anything. Carlton's top goal scorer today is 74 kg.

[BrisbaneDemon 1,501]

Are you confident in the players our club selected?

Unfortunately you win some and you lose some, it happens in every team. If we cannot develop our top draft picks then we shouldn't be in the league.

[Footynut 302]

I look at players such as Garlett who did nothing much year one.

We seem to expect 18yo to walk in and change the team while playing in a team that lost its first 3 by 100 plus.

I think many here are heavily scarred by the Jack Watts experience and now are not prepared to wait for anyone.

Remember what a great first year Rhys Palmer had? Rising star....where is he now????

People on here need to recognise every individual is different and takes their own time.

The comments about Todd Viney are out of line given he knew Wines in depth and still went for Toumpas as most people agreed with.

Get some perspective and take a chill pill.

For what it's worth if you have been to training you would see Toumpas offers more from his shortened preseason than many others we have down there already.

[daisycutter 28,635]

They took Nicholson up I believe so that was probably a bonus for Casey

i told you they would only take one emergency od

you owe me a banana split (with extras)

[mjt 640]

You're just being ridiculous.

Viney 82 kg. Kent 82 Kg. Toumpas 79 Kg. Terlich 83 Kg.

For comparison: no. 1 pick Lachie Whitfield: 75 kg. Jake Neade (has been more than useful ...): 67 Kg.

And seeing you refer to Stringer at the Dogs, apart from Dom Barry, all of our picks were heavier than all of their other picks.

Not that that has anything much to do with anything. Carlton's top goal scorer today is 74 kg.

If im being ridiculous go back over the last 7 years.

[hardtack 10,127]

How did Dom Barry go tonight? there selections are a [censored] joke.

Do you know how he went, or are you just assuming? If the MFC is such a joke, please go and support some successful club... I would really hate for you to have to do the hard yards.

[Footynut 302]

If im being ridiculous go back over the last 7 years.

Just wondering why you haven't been recruiting for us for the last 7 years.

Sounds like your a gun in hindsight.

[ThreeOneSix 953]

Toumpas is soft and doesn't do repeat efforts at AFL level, I wouldn't think he'd do them at VFL either.

I watched the championships last year and they harped on about Toumpas and all he done was cherry pick off the backline.

Front runner and the last thing we need.

Meanwhile Ollie Wines was doing all the one percenters and the things that the MFC lack and we overlook him.

But our football department has got a lot of late picks right recently, Howe, McDonald, Matt Jones, Terlich looks a player.

Can't win em all I guess.

[mjt 640]

I look at players such as Garlett who did nothing much year one.

We seem to expect 18yo to walk in and change the team while playing in a team that lost its first 3 by 100 plus.

I think many here are heavily scarred by the Jack Watts experience and now are not prepared to wait for anyone.

Remember what a great first year Rhys Palmer had? Rising star....where is he now????

People on here need to recognise every individual is different and takes their own time.

The comments about Todd Viney are out of line given he knew Wines in depth and still went for Toumpas as most people agreed with.

Get some perspective and take a chill pill.

For what it's worth if you have been to training you would see Toumpas offers more from his shortened preseason than many others we have down there already.

Dont tell me about training, i live 5 minutes from Casey Fields, i have seem more sessions than you have, probably 100 since O8, the only decent greyhound i have seen train there in that time is T Scully, i tell you now jim isnt fit to tie his boots laces.

[Ted Lasso 16,928]

we have done really well with this draft in my opinion, Toumpas shows class but needs time, viney is going to be a star, Hogan looks a ready made star, kent looks fantastic, jones and terlich both look like very solid AFL players also

critics of Toumpas need to be more paitent, wouldn't be at all surprised if he ends up being the best of all those draftee's

[The heart beats true 16,440]

Mjt,

You have to look at the recent draftees in a slightly more long term view. 5 weeks doesn't maketh a career. Viney has looked good, Hogan looks sensational, Barry is a very long term project, Toumpas would look 100% better in a side not getting pumped by 100 points each week he's played. Calm down mate. These are 18 year olds. Every time I spend 5 minutes with my 18 year old nephew I'm shocked at what we expect from new recruits. Give em time.