Who should we pick up?

[Hannibal 5,814]

It’s so sad and embarrassing that this time of year is my most exciting as a Melbourne member. If it was a once off it would be palatable, however, it has been the case for far too long.

The reality is that year in year out we have to unearth immediate core team ingredients rather than adding cream.....we have a team, yes a team, of first round draft picks, most of whom can't run, won't work, get pushed over too easily AND don't hurt enough.

Enter;

1) Apatite for all contests

2) Absolute distain in a loss, both in a one on one contest and the teams end result

3) Willingness to work both ways

4) Sacrifice for the jumper and your mate

Enter J Viney and J Hogan to follow.

I’m 32 and look 42, during footy season I hate Monday’s even more so.

Mark Neeld was chosen for a reason, he has seen how the best do it, he’s methodical and uncompromising exactly what is required. Initially it got up a few people, but have a look at what we have been watching for the past 10 years. Frankly, I wouldn’t put up with anyone who didn’t stir things up, that would show a certain contentment.

I have faith that he will demand players whom will want to buy and take ownership of carrying the club forward, not content on getting buff (excludes a few) and having a kick on the weekend.

The fact that J Viney in round 1 2013 on debut will be one of our toughest and most uncompromising players should be an embarrassment to the club….but it will make the others learn very fast that this is the standard, not simply one out of the box.

Get the broom out, it hasn’t worked and let savages in.

Good post.

[King Kunta 97]

I dont think you realise how good Gaff is. Averaged 24.5 dsposals and 5 tackles this seaosn, just his 2nd season in the AFL.

the Eagles would REALLY want to be into Jack Martin or Jesse Hogan to do this trade.

Yeah as much as I would love to see him in the red and blue I can't see them fielding any offers.

He is ranked number 1 for uncontested possessions in the AFL which shows his ability to get the pill.

[Barney Rubble 1,576]

Saints Cull 4

Peake, Polo Crocker and Archer.

Woiuld we be interested?

I don't think so.

[Grimseyisgod 378]

No stkilda players worth a look there. Hahaha that post by Lace Out, that is amazing.. so true..

Gaff is a gun and i reckon pick 4 and bate would be perfect for him

[sylvinator 96]

Look, if Travis Cloke is in the picture, we should really be going for him. We need a 2nd big forward desperately, he's one of the best in the game, pay him $1.2 million a season, we have no other players than deserve to be on serious money, so why not! Carlton are obviously front runners, but we have the money to pay him and we have the picks to satisfy Collingwood. We're a chance in the same way we were a chance for Mitch Clark.

- Trade Pick 4 + Petterd or Gysberts for Cloke.

- Use pick 3 and 13 on the best midfielders available.

- Pick 23 is Viney.

- Try to get Pearce and Byrnes as free agents, we are crying out for some goal-kicking ability and outside run.

Suddenly we SLOWLY start to take shape to a team that can compete properly at AFL level.

McDonald Frawley Strauss

Grimes Rivers Garland

Trengove Sylvia Pearce

Howe Cloke Watts

Blease Clark Byrnes

Jamar Jones Viney

Interchange: McKenzie, Tapscott, Pick 3, pick 13. Maybe Taggert and Fitzpatrick can show something.

If we don't bring in 2-3 quality senior players who can play from the get-go we are going to struggle to win a game next season. our supporter base can't take much more of this

[BLWNBA 380]

Brett Peake.

[Grimseyisgod 378]

McDonald Frawley Strauss

Grimes Rivers Garland

Trengove Sylvia Pearce

Howe Cloke Watts

Blease Clark Byrnes

Jamar Jones Viney

Interchange: McKenzie, Tapscott, Pick 3, pick 13. Maybe Taggert and Fitzpatrick can show something.

look youve got an ok team there, but not a premiership winning one.

my best lineup would show

B: T.Mcdonald Frawley Rivers

HB: Grimes Garland C.Young (Hawks)

M: Trengove Wellingham Blease

HB: Howe Watts Sylvia

F: Tapscott Clark Brynes

Foll: Jamar Jones Viney

Int: Knights, Mckenzie, Pick 3 sub: Jetta (still think he fits in somehow)

[rpfc 27,693]

Jones, Trengove, Grimes.

Maybe Howe.

These are the only mids I would rate above Viney for Rd 1 2013.

I don't know whether to laugh or cry...

So I will 'craugh.'

It's not pretty...and a little bit creepy.

Bring on Viney, Pick 3 or 4 (I don't think we will have both - one way or the other), Pick 13, a smattering of solid pros from state leagues or Delisted FA, and, hopefully, a good mid in FA or in a Trade.

[old55 21,913]

Look, if Travis Cloke is in the picture, we should really be going for him. We need a 2nd big forward desperately, he's one of the best in the game, pay him $1.2 million a season, we have no other players than deserve to be on serious money, so why not! Carlton are obviously front runners, but we have the money to pay him and we have the picks to satisfy Collingwood. We're a chance in the same way we were a chance for Mitch Clark.

- Trade Pick 4 + Petterd or Gysberts for Cloke.

Cloke is a restricted free agent - trade is not required.

[Guest Rassilon]

If we don't bring in 2-3 quality senior players who can play from the get-go we are going to struggle to win a game next season. our supporter base can't take much more of this

Very nice observation. Difficult times ahead.

[Theo 263]

Very nice observation. Difficult times ahead.

At a coaches forum I attended in June CS stated that the MFC is likely to have the lowest supporter base of all Victorian Clubs within the next 10 years. It is an ageing supporter base and has a low number of young people coming through supporting the Club.

Some say this Club is irrelevant and stands for very little. Unless we start winning games on a consistent basis and win games against top clubs this Club will struggle to survive and have any relevance in the future.

[Grimseyisgod 378]

Honestly, i have been a mad Melbourne supporter since i was 5. I can honestly say this is the best shaping list ive seen since, we are closer to building a premiership list than ever before. There is a good base of players just need to bring in some new ones.

We have developed players and they will continue to develop.

Just wait for Melbourne to pick up players and do well in this draft

[McQueen 17,864]

Would be stunned if the Dons agreed to this. Reckon Pears and Hooker may be on the table though.

It'll be great to get a few ex-bombers at the Dee's. We might play okay for at least half a season then...

[Grimseyisgod 378]

haha cant wait till October 1

[PaulRB 6,130]

It'll be great to get a few ex-bombers at the Dee's. We might play okay for at least half a season then...

...Our normal season would kick in.

;-)

[Cheap Seats 3,308]

Anyone know anything about Josh Kennedy's contract at the Swans?? I've heard a whisper he is uncontracted?

I doubt he would leave Sydney but he's they type of guy i'd be throwing big coin at

[Grimseyisgod 378]

yeah Kennedy aint leaving no matter what price.

[Tatu 416]

Zack Clark isn't getting much of an opportunity at freo...... He's a good ruckman, but could be a better CHF?

[Grimseyisgod 378]

there are lots of players up for trade and lots of players at free agents, i know that we will expolre all guns.Hopefully we go for Wellingham, Embley, young, established players

[Left Field 313]

My top 4 would be Wellingham, Goddard, Russell and Young.

All 4 would walk straight into our 22.

[Vitamin Dee 849]

Don't be surprised if the club throw money at Chaplin, particularly if Rivers is likely to move on.

[rolly 149]

Don't be surprised if the club throw money at Chaplin, particularly if Rivers is likely to move on.

i'd rather they give sheahan or davis a crack...

Would much prefer the money to be used fora ready to go midfield or forward

[Bingo 254]

No stkilda players worth a look there. Hahaha that post by Lace Out, that is amazing.. so true..

Gaff is a gun and i reckon pick 4 and bate would be perfect for him

why would you want to dilute pick 4?

[Bingo 254]

look youve got an ok team there, but not a premiership winning one.

my best lineup would show

B: T.Mcdonald Frawley Rivers

HB: Grimes Garland C.Young (Hawks)

M: Trengove Wellingham Blease

HB: Howe Watts Sylvia

F: Tapscott Clark Brynes

Foll: Jamar Jones Viney

Int: Knights, Mckenzie, Pick 3 sub: Jetta (still think he fits in somehow)

I know Neeld wants us to be more defensive....is this why we have 2 half back lines? Or is it the fact that we can only attack from half back because we lose the clearances?

[Dee1987 277]

My 22 a bit of wishful thinking for Rnd 1 2013

B: Russell Frawley Rivers

HB: Mcdonald Garland Grimes

C: Gaff ( for pick 3) Viney Trengove

HF: Sylvia Watts Howe

F: Pearce Clark Monfries

Foll Jamar Wellingham Jones

Intr Blease Tapscott Gawn Dunn