Toumpas v Stringer v Wines

[Guest trenners]

olisik made a good point in the Under 18 carnival thread about Toumpas, Stringer and Wines.

I don't watch the under 18s very often but looking at today's game I would go with:-

■ Toumpas;

■ Stringer; or

■ Wines

Thoughts?

[Chook 14,701]

What about that Viney kid? I've heard he's pretty good.

[Brayshaw Self 847]

Toumpas.

[Guest trenners]

sorry forgot to mention him, I'm assuming that we are definitely taking him no matter what

[SidVicious 121]

Toumpas by the length of Bourke Street.

Get him please!

[Guest trenners]

does anyone think stringer could fall to pick 12? Or is he too highly rated

[Little Richard 5,943]

Stringer for me.

[furious d 447]

Thoughts?

Toumpas for me. Sounds like the perfect match for Viney at 3. Class and pace to go with Jacks mad attack at the footy.

If we are KOTD and Viney makes it through to the second round I'd take Toumpas and Wines.

Stringer could be a slider imo and he might still be there at our mid round compo pick but I'd take Mayes or Colquhuon before him if they were available.

[Goodvibes 3,596]

v Garlett

[Guest trenners]

v Garlett

Feel like garlett will be ready for us at pick 12

[Goodvibes 3,596]

Feel like garlett will be ready for us at pick 12

It'll probably be pick 13. I've got a feeling he will continue to climb. He could be worth the reach at pick 4.

[dazzledavey36 49,785]

Oliver Wines for sure! reminds me of dustin martin alot! good head on his shoulders too.

[Guest KingDingAling]

It'll probably be pick 13. I've got a feeling he will continue to climb. He could be worth the reach at pick 4.

Cant take him with pick 4, thats a big stretch I think.

I'd risk him being there at 13, look he probably wont be - but theres some good kids between 4 and 13, very good kids.

SA have an abundance of quality young talent that will go high.

Wines over Stringer and Toumpas.

I think Wines goes at 3, then we decide who we take at 4, which is wide open!

[Guest KingDingAling]

Oliver Wines for sure! reminds me of dustin martin alot! good head on his shoulders too.

Absolutely spot on, that is the comparison I made aswell, not Sylvia, Martin!

Well balanced on both sides, ferocious, desperate and has that shrug.

[Hannibal 5,814]

Toumpas at 3, Stringer at 4, Mayes at 12, Viney second round. I also really like Wines, but top 5 is too early and he won't last til 12.

Stringer is a brute.

That said, we might off-load one of our first round picks.

[Geddy Lee 582]

olisik made a good point in the Under 18 carnival thread about Toumpas, Stringer and Wines.

I don't watch the under 18s very often but looking at today's game I would go with:-

■ Toumpas;

■ Stringer; or

■ Wines

Thoughts?

What's the best place to read information about these guys; i.e. teams, positions, height etc.

[Left Field 313]

Toumpas clearly on that showing. Although he slowed down in the second half, his ball getting, composure, kicking action (especially the posture) and ball use were all fantastic.

By the way, that smallish leftie Kennedy (?) is a Shannon Grant lookalike. If he were available in the second round, I'd grab him. He will play a lot of footy - very nice penetrating kick and gets the ball well.

[demonoid 317]

Toumpas. 15 handball receives. Just the kind of player we need

[Left Field 313]

Toumpas. 15 handball receives. Just the kind of player we need

First time I've seen him but didn't strike me as an outsider. Good reader/presenter I guess. On a related note, the commentators spoke about Vic Country's lack of spread.

I didn't see the whole game.What did people think of Whitfield (clear #1 pick apparently)?

[Juicebox 628]

Toumpas. 15 handball receives. Just the kind of player we need

26 disposals (20 kicks) at 92% efficiency. Certainly is the type of player we need

[Nascent 7,729]

For those that have watched a bit of the championships, is Martin and Hogan worth going for in the mini draft?

Using Gold Coast and Adelaide as a guide.

Mini Pick # 1 -> Pick 4 and Mid 1st round compensation pick

Mini Pick # 2 -> Pick 10 and 1st round compensation pick

So if we wanted to get mini pick one, we would most likely have to part with pick 4 and 13.

Would people be happy with....

Mini Draft Pick # 1 - Jack Martin/Jesse Hogan

Pick # 3 - Jimmy Toumpas/Jake Stringer/Ollie Wines

2nd Round Pick - Jack Viney

[whatwhat say what 20,343]

whitfield is a jet.

toumpas (no 's'), wines at #3 and #4 for me, then kennedy with the mid-range pick, followed by viney with the second-rounder.

i'd love grundy with the mid-range pick, but he won't last - wouldn't be surprised to see gws snap him up.

[demonoid 317]

Martin looks tasty for a mini pick

[whatwhat say what 20,343]

Would people be happy with....

Mini Draft Pick # 1 - Jack Martin/Jesse Hogan

Pick # 3 - Jimmy Toumpas/Jake Stringer/Ollie Wines

2nd Round Pick - Jack Viney

i'd rate toumpas and wines over martin and hogan, and we could probably get both, but it'd be hard to be opposed to it.

[Guest KingDingAling]

For those that have watched a bit of the championships, is Martin and Hogan worth going for in the mini draft?

Using Gold Coast and Adelaide as a guide.

Mini Pick # 1 -> Pick 4 and Mid 1st round compensation pick

Mini Pick # 2 -> Pick 10 and 1st round compensation pick

So if we wanted to get mini pick one, we would most likely have to part with pick 4 and 13.

Would people be happy with....

Mini Draft Pick # 1 - Jack Martin/Jesse Hogan

Pick # 3 - Jimmy Toumpas/Jake Stringer/Ollie Wines

2nd Round Pick - Jack Viney

No way, not a hope in hell.

Your saying we package pick 4 and 13 to get Martin, not happening.

Garlett is the equal of Martin and we probably get him for 13 alone!

On top of that, at pick 4, we will get a better player than Martin.

So, 4 and 13, makes no sense at all for me.

O'Meara would go number 1 in this draft - or VERY close to it.

I think Martin is good - but the most I would go is pick 13 and a player.