Viney throws his hat in for Coach

[McQueen 17,864]

Well it's official, Todd Viney will be interviewed for the vacant coaching job.

http://www.afl.com.au/news/newsarticle/tabid/208/newsid/122414/default.aspx

No doubt his CV reads very well and he is a Demon though-and-through.

Fact remains, he is an in-experienced coach.

What are his chances?

[Supermercado 2,647]

Great, so now we lose Jack Viney as well...

[H_T 2,941]

He wants feedback from the club, "then we'll see how we go" he says.

[Demons 32 235]

Great, so now we lose Jack Viney as well...

Sooooo we hire Todd Viney and that means we don't draft Jack Viney?

Weird comment.

The question would have to be asked whether or not Jack Viney would be ok with it but I can imagine he would love his dad to coach.

I have seen many father/son coaching/playing duos in my life and alot of the time the kid loves it.

Sometimes they hate it, but I think MFC and the Viney family would be smart enough to not do it if Jack was against it at all....

Edited September 1, 2011 by Demons 32

[McQueen 17,864]

He wants feedback from the club, "then we'll see how we go" he says.

Still its fair to say that his focus isn't entirely on the Player Development role as it was.

All the feedback from the players has been very positive.

[ICU2 Jerry Jerry 257]

Great, so now we lose Jack Viney as well...

Yeah because a father can never coach a sun in pro sport. Just ask Andrew Gaze . . . .

[DemonDing 56]

Great, so now we lose Jack Viney as well...

i heard from a good source Jack is not happy with Todd because he wasnt aloud out on a school night...

[Jakovich13 16]

This smells of the club going to Viney and saying.."look, Malthouse is interested in coaching us but not until 2013... he needs a year off... can we come to some arrangement that you stay on for another 12 months and then we get our man after that..."

I hope this is not the case but its plausible..effectively putting the club on hold for 12 months..

[rpfc 27,644]

This smells of the club going to Viney and saying.."look, Malthouse is interested in coaching us but not until 2013... he needs a year off... can we come to some arrangement that you stay on for another 12 months and then we get our man after that..."

I hope this is not the case but its plausible..effectively putting the club on hold for 12 months..

It smells like we are going through the motions of selecting a new coach.

I hope we go through these motions until around mid October and then Malthouse signs two weeks after saying he is taking a break from footy.

[Ned 156]

I don't mind Todd at all. If we can't jag a premiership coach I'd be happy with Viney.

[DeeZee 6,853]

I dont think there would be any 12 month arrangement with Mick taking over after that, because if Viney is successful and well liked we would be silly to lose him, and he would probably want to stay.

Edited September 1, 2011 by DeeZee

[Hellaintabadplacetobe 4,110]

This smells of the club going to Viney and saying.."look, Malthouse is interested in coaching us but not until 2013... he needs a year off... can we come to some arrangement that you stay on for another 12 months and then we get our man after that..."

I hope this is not the case but its plausible..effectively putting the club on hold for 12 months..

Thought the same thing myself, although I don't think it would be putting the club on hold for 12 months, rather it would get us far closer to a flag if we indeed secure Mick in 12 months time!!

[IWAP 168]

Sooooo we hire Todd Viney and that means we don't draft Jack Viney?

Weird comment.

I interpreted Supermercado's comment differently. I thought he was implying that if Todd doesn't get the job, he may leave, and therefore we may lose Jack as well.

The last two caretaker coaches for Melbourne (Hutchison and Riley) both left after unsuccesfully applying for the job.

[Johnny Karate 559]

If we don't get Malthouse or Ross Lyon, I'd be happy with Viney. He's as well credentialled as any other assistant coaches out there, has shown some tactical nous and can now add a senior coaching stint (albeit 5 games) to his CV. I feel he has that nasty streak in him to demand more from the group.

[Dee1987 277]

NO WAY, I would be shattered. I like Todd but not as senior coach, assistant yes but would rather someone like Neeld. Viney as his 2nd in charge

[Real Demon 232]

I've got the utmost respect for Viney, but all of his talk since taking on the role has been that he doesn't want to coach.

Surely he has been around the game long enough to know now whether it's something he wants to seriously pursue or not.

Now after a win, he is contemplating throwing his hat into the ring.

Personally, I'd prefer he didn't................I don't think this is the sort of job you can afford to go into unsure of whether you truly want to do it or not.

And I'd hate to see a club legend chopped as coach if things don't work out.

[Dee1987 277]

Agreed he has only won one game big woop!!!! and if we lose too port would u really want someone who has lost too the bottom team???

[NorwoodDemon 20]

i signed up just for this

Todd Viney as a coach for the Demons would be a stupid decision hes crap!

MALTHOUSE OR NO ONE!!!!!

Melbourne have to get there hand out of their pockets, offer some good money to Malthouse and pester him like the Filth did when he was at West Coast!

[cooko 124]

MALTHOUSE OR NO ONE!!!!!

so if we dont get malthouse.. we shouldnt have a coach.. right..

Edited September 1, 2011 by cooko

[NorwoodDemon 20]

well yeah.... i was just excited but seriously

malthouse thats who we need its been too long since weve won a flag nearly 50 yrs kinda pathetic.

i just dont want Todd Viney, dont think he would win a flag.

[Demon Rob 2]

maybe todd can hand over the coaching at the end of next year and become 'director of coaching'

[PaulRB 6,041]

Red herring to buy time (one month).

Edited September 1, 2011 by PaulRB

[RudeBoy 164]

Todd may be a great coach, but to be honest, his record of three terrible losses and a modest victory against a team of teenagers is not the sort of resume which fills me with confidence.

[Hip & Shoulder 64]

Sooooo we hire Todd Viney and that means we don't draft Jack Viney?

Weird comment.

The question would have to be asked whether or not Jack Viney would be ok with it but I can imagine he would love his dad to coach.

I have seen many father/son coaching/playing duos in my life and alot of the time the kid loves it.

Sometimes they hate it, but I think MFC and the Viney family would be smart enough to not do it if Jack was against it at all....

I think you'd find Jack has been coached by his father since he started kicking a footy around the backyard.

[McQueen 17,864]

i signed up just for this

Todd Viney as a coach for the Demons would be a stupid decision hes crap

Todd, crap?

You've just signed up... Crap.