Warnock for...

[Mousey 47]

Yeah i agree, he is a great depth player, but if he wants to go to be more than that than so be it for a good deal.

[old55 23,590]

Warnock - Hale - Andrew Walker?

[Carlos Danger 380]

HAWTHORN has Josh Hill, David Hale and an unnamed defender on its wish list this trade week.

While the Hawks' general manager of player personnel and strategy Chris Pelchen has warned that the club won't trade if the asking price is too high, he has identified the Bulldogs forward and Kangaroos ruckman as targets.

However he has refused to comment on the defender in their sights, except to say it's not Chris Tarrant.

http://www.afl.com.au/news/newsarticle/tabid/208/newsid/103821/default.aspx

Warnock may well be that unnamed defender but who knows, pick 19 would be a viable trade for him but I don't see the Hawks putting it on the table. More likely to be their 2nd round pick and somebody not getting games in the seniors.

[Heart Beats True 1,233]

Warnock may well be that unnamed defender but who knows, pick 19 would be a viable trade for him but I don't see the Hawks putting it on the table. More likely to be their 2nd round pick and somebody not getting games in the seniors.

Apparently the unnamed defender is Cale Hooker from the Bombers - if you believe what is reported on BF.

[No16 1]

Latest rumour is that a deal has been done between St.Kilda and Melbourne. Robert Eddy and Jarryn Geary to Melbourne for Matthew Warnock, just soughting out a shuffle of draft picks.

Posted on FoxSports website...

Can't say that I like that trade....

[Mousey 47]

Latest rumour is that a deal has been done between St.Kilda and Melbourne. Robert Eddy and Jarryn Geary to Melbourne for Matthew Warnock, just soughting out a shuffle of draft picks.

Posted on FoxSports website...

Can't say that I like that trade....

Can u post the link cause i cant find it mate

[No16 1]

Can u post the link cause i cant find it mate

In the Fox Sports Trade week blog

[ox_5 163]

Can u post the link cause i cant find it mate

This is just a rumour in the Live Trade Blog. Nothing concrete. And considering its from people just putting out rumours, probably false.

[No16 1]

Fox Sports Trade Week Blog

[hoopla 418]

Latest rumour is that a deal has been done between St.Kilda and Melbourne. Robert Eddy and Jarryn Geary to Melbourne for Matthew Warnock, just soughting out a shuffle of draft picks.

Posted on FoxSports website...

Can't say that I like that trade....

Got to be false. Nobody would want Eddy after watching the Grand Finals ..... we certainly wouldn't

Got to be from someone with a twisted sense of humour

[The Albino Warrior 44]

Got to be false. Nobody would want Eddy after watching the Grand Finals ..... we certainly wouldn't

Got to be from someone with a twisted sense of humour

Yeah, had a Raph Clarke in that first one.

Just trying to work out what gap on the list these two would fill if the rumour turns out to be true?

Warnock clearly isn't starting 22 anymore, but extremely handy should injuries strike Garland, Frawley or Rivers.

[The Chazz 4,077]

I was thinking Warnock to Freo, Tarrant to Collingwood, Collingwoods first rounder to us. Then we could use pick 12 and 32 for Hale and 17, and then have pick 17 and 27 (approx - not sure what Pies'first pick was).

Collingwood buggered that up by using their firswt rounder on Kracker I think?

[H_T 3,047]

Collingwood buggered that up by using their firswt rounder on Kracker I think?

Yeah, I think pick 25 to GC for Krakouer.

[The Chazz 4,077]

Yeah, I think pick 25 to GC for Krakouer.

Had potential until the black and white scum stuffed it up!

They seem to be happy to use that 15-35 pick on a tried player don't they? Jolly, Ball, now Krakouer.

[No16 1]

Yeah, I think pick 25 to GC for Krakouer.

Pretty much Collingwood traded the compensation pick received for Josh Fraser to the Gold Coast for Krakouer...

[old55 23,590]

Yeah, had a Raph Clarke in that first one.

Just trying to work out what gap on the list these two would fill if the rumour turns out to be true?

Warnock clearly isn't starting 22 anymore, but extremely handy should injuries strike Garland, Frawley or Rivers.

I think we need 2 things, probably in this order:

- Fwd-ruck = Hale

- Lock-down small defender with good kicking skills

Agree Warnock is very handy but if he doesn't get more opportunities who could blame him for wanting to leave when he's OOC at the end of 2011.

Edited October 7, 2010 by old55

[Robbie57 2,020]

fox sports says:

1158: Trade murmur: Sam on the email: A deal has been done between St.Kilda and Melbourne. Robert Eddy and Jarryn Geary to Melbourne for Matthew Warnock, just soughting out a shuffle of draft picks.

[Grand New Flag 3,227]

I don't know much about either Eddy or Geary. Can someone help?

[The Big Ticket 94]

fox sports says:

1158: Trade murmur: Sam on the email: A deal has been done between St.Kilda and Melbourne. Robert Eddy and Jarryn Geary to Melbourne for Matthew Warnock, just soughting out a shuffle of draft picks.

Far-fetched much?

Those two couldn't crack our 22 at the moment. I call BS.

[Jaded No More 68,920]

fox sports says:

1158: Trade murmur: Sam on the email: A deal has been done between St.Kilda and Melbourne. Robert Eddy and Jarryn Geary to Melbourne for Matthew Warnock, just soughting out a shuffle of draft picks.

GTFO!!!

[The Albino Warrior 44]

Agree Warnock is very handy but if he doesn't get more opportunities who could blame him for wanting to leave when he's OOC at the end of 2011.

Me neither. If he has asked to be traded, they should do their best. He's been a great servant during several of our toughest years and just happens to have been overtaken by two very good young footballers.

The fact that Warnock played a fair bit of VFL at the end of the season means we can't go in to negotiations pretending he's our most precious commodity, but at the same time tall, dependable backmen are scarce in the AFL.

Do Geary and Eddy quite cut it?

[Dr. Mubutu 853]

fox sports says:

1158: Trade murmur: Sam on the email: A deal has been done between St.Kilda and Melbourne. Robert Eddy and Jarryn Geary to Melbourne for Matthew Warnock, just soughting out a shuffle of draft picks.

The deranged ramblings of a delusional Saints supporter, surely.

[The Big Ticket 94]

GTFO!!!

At this time last year, Jamar and Rivers were a done deal to Port in exchange for their first pick.

It's a BS rumor.

[Guest hangon007]

It's a BS rumor.

I'm with you sounds like BS. You would think we would prefer picks to get other deals done.

[Jarka 767]

I literally had to look up the two Saints players details because I have no idea who these are and what position they play. They're both 22 so if it's true perhaps the FD have seen something in them?

It's a big IF though