Team Changes for Round 7

[beelzebub 22,225]

In: Bail, Mcnamara

Out: Bate, Bennell

thatd be worth the look . Have nothing against Bennel, in fact he has much promise and a it of poise about him. One of a few who seems to be able to keep ( most of the time too ) but might do with a rest and a chance to run a it easier in the magoos

Bate needs to find something.from where ever...so a spell downstairs might help him as well. Good chance to give the other lads a run.

[Pello 1]

How bad must Bate play before he dropped ???

To all the Bate believers, have faith.

It's interesting to note that the much maligned Bater has had a hand in 14 out of the 63 goals kicked by MFC in the first 6 rounds so he's

been involved directly with 22% of all goals by way of 9 direct assists (the most in the club this year so far) + 5 he's kicked himself (4th highest goal kicker).

Baters stats this year so far say:

1st in direct goal assists - 9

4th in goals kicked - 5

4th in contested possesions - 36

8th in total disposals - 83

8th for inside 50's with - 15

10th for tackles with - 12

Of his 14 possessions against Geelong, 7 were contested, he had 2 direct goal assists and 3 inside 50's.

When delivery to the forward line is less hesitant, quicker and more accurate he'll kick bags.

Must stay in the team.

Don't forget to mention his disposal efficiency at 66% is not in the top 20! Of his 83 disposals 16 have been clangers. So 1 in every 5 disposals are a shocker. Also don't forget to mention he is 16th in the 1%'s.

I'm glad you find it pleasing that a key forward has got 5 goals out of 6 games - you're easily pleased.

His lack of intensity at the ball and in the chase and in putting overall pressure on the ball carrier is disgraceful.

He has had enough chances - replace him with ANYONE on one condition. That his replacement has a crack!

[Deestroy All 14,261]

Great post Nasher.

Jaded is on crystal meth.

Out.

Dunn, Bate

In.

McNamara, Whelan/Grimes

Bate should've been dropped before Newton. Newton is stiff this week, as I want to see Martin forward again, Newton would just get in the way.

Dunn, I've seen enough, ship him off.

T-Mac was great on Saturday, can slot in with Martin moving forward.

Whelan or Grimes doesn't bother me they're both awesome.

I'd like to see Hughes elevated. And Cheney deserves a game, but I think Bennell will get a gig on Subi.

[45HG 1,539]

In: Grimes, Whelan

Out: Dunn, Bennel

[Kit Walker 207]

I'd drop PJ and have Meesen run around all day tagging Dean Cox everywhere except inside about forward 50. Inside forward 50, I'd like to see Miller just repeatedly jump into him and have a third player come over the top.

We are no chance of breaking even in the ruck, whether with one ruckman or four, so anything that can be done to limit Cox's influence is worthwhile. Likewise, Meesen's big selling point is his endurance so it would be a great lesson to see how the best ruckman in the competition plays close up.

Bennell should also be left out and get some extended game time with Casey. In would come any two of Grimes, McNamara or Cheney.

[Johnny Karate 559]

Bell shouldn't and hopefully wont come in. He is a list clogger. I love his ticker and workrate but he is simply not up to AFL standard.

[Guest Digga]

Ridiculous - 8 tackles from Sylvia = well and truly deserving of spot. Also, his 15 touches were far better than anyone elses on the field. Although itd be nice, he doesnt need 25 - 30 touches to be damaging. Dropping the only player on our list (aside from davey) who is damaging by foot when we are in dire need of foot skills??

Exactly, and I think he looks alot more composed.

[Hannabal 4]

In: Grimes, Whelan

Out: Dunn, Bennel

We're very similar, Dog, but I prefer Cheney to Whelan as his younger legs will be more suited to Subi.

[beelzebub 22,225]

We're very similar, Dog, but I prefer Cheney to Whelan as his younger legs will be more suited to Subi.

Id prefer Cheney too, but simply as he's the future..yes I harp on it...but is the simple truth.

[Hannabal 4]

Id prefer Cheney too, but simply as he's the future..yes I harp on it...but is the simple truth.

You are a wise old salt, Bub.

[45HG 1,539]

Your point is well seen, but if Whelan doesn't play a few games this year, I will most likely venture to the top of Eureka Tower...and not for the sights. Dog?

[Hannabal 4]

Your point is well seen, but if Whelan doesn't play a few games this year, I will most likely venture to the top of Eureka Tower...and not for the sights. Dog?

For some reason I thought you're name was 45 hotdog

[45HG 1,539]

Haha, lucky you did otherwise you'd have called me "God"

[titan_uranus 22,351]

We'll agree to differ. His preseason form was superb and he's had 3 weeks back. His form in his 3 games at Casey has been solid with his first 2 weeks better than the weekend, but he got a lot of unassuming touches at Coburg and was asked to play different roles.

Fair enough. I must admit, I was swayed by seeing him against Coburg.

The Casey bye this week makes these decisions quite interesting.

[dee-luded 2,958]

Great post Nasher.

Jaded is on crystal meth.

Out.

Dunn, Bate

In.

McNamara, Whelan/Grimes

Bate should've been dropped before Newton. Newton is stiff this week, as I want to see Martin forward again, Newton would just get in the way.

Dunn, I've seen enough, ship him off.

T-Mac was great on Saturday, can slot in with Martin moving forward.

Whelan or Grimes doesn't bother me they're both awesome.

I'd like to see Hughes elevated. And Cheney deserves a game, but I think Bennell will get a gig on Subi.

Don't know about crystal meth, But IMO jaded has been peeping into her crystal balls, she wanted Belly back the other day. Love you Jaded.

[Jaded No More 57,820]

Well this thread has turned out very well for me...

I'm on drugs, I'm insane, I'm loved, I'm hated

Note to self: stay away from team changes topics

[QueenC 74]

Well this thread has turned out very well for me...

I'm on drugs, I'm insane, I'm loved, I'm hated

Note to self: stay away from team changes topics

Yep, God forbid your opinion differs from the masses !!!

[titan_uranus 22,351]

For those who want or believe that Wonaeamirri will return this week, DB's said he won't: http://www.melbournefc.com.au/news/newsart...69/default.aspx

That article also has this quote from DB about Stef Martin:

"We'll just take it week by week with Stef. We just thought on the weekend, we could get another marking player up there, as we weren't quite marking the footy as often,"

"He's quick and he's 198cm, Stef, so we might look at it (playing him up forward) again, but we're trying to groom him as a backman … he showed a little bit Stef and he had a goal assist to 'Robbo', which was great.

"He can ruck as well; he did some ruck work when he was down at 'Sandy' (Sandringham), so he's got some elements that we'd like to expand on for him."

Leaves the door open for him to go forward again. But that bit about rucking is interesting. Maybe, if the Meesen rumours are true, we'll see Martin get a go in the ruck this week.

[Rhino Richards 1,467]

I dont think there were many who said that TU. Only those who did not see the Coburg game on TV.

[Jaded No More 57,820]

I hope like hell Martin doesn't go into the centre circle this year.

While rucking around the ground is fine, you just know that with our luck, he'd jump too early, get kicked in the head and do a knee on his way down!

[Lil_red_fire_engine 10,171]

In: Bail, Mcnamara

Out: Bate, Bennell

Disagree on Bail and Bennell. Bennell will not lose his spot unless it is for "soreness" particularly with the opportunity for him to play in his home state this week. Bail moves beautifully but would want to show more intent for the contest and better disposal before he is promoted for mine.

[titan_uranus 22,351]

I dont think there were many who said that TU. Only those who did not see the Coburg game on TV.

No, there probably weren't. Certainly anyone who saw the Coburg game wouldn't have called for his inclusion.

[Jaded No More 57,820]

No, there probably weren't. Certainly anyone who saw the Coburg game wouldn't have called for his inclusion.

Well I saw the game and I called for his inclusion, must have been the crystal meth talking

To be honest I wanted Aussie in the team based on what he did last year, as opposed to how he played on Saturday (which I've admitted numerous times was badly).

[Je Roos Salem 661]

What has Bennell done to be dropped?

I hope he plays 22 games this year, he looks a really good running player for the future

Anyway, now that Meesen is probally gone 3 changes are intact

In- Spencer, Jetta, Cheney

Out- Maric, Meesen, Bate

[titan_uranus 22,351]

What has Bennell done to be dropped?

I hope he plays 22 games this year, he looks a really good running player for the future

Anyway, now that Meesen is probally gone 3 changes are intact

In- Spencer, Jetta, Cheney

Out- Maric, Meesen, Bate

Change to Dunn and you might well be on the money Steve.