For case for 2026 ....

High contact (with ground), high impact - contest result of kozzie kick

Result: kozzie suspended for 3 weeks

I know its a lottery at times, but this Comden/Mihocek one has me confused on where it'll land

New year, same sh*t

NoNothing in it..

No name north Melbourne player in preseason?

3 weeks

Probably gets off because Checkers thinks he was concussed in a different incident.

18 minutes ago, Demonland said:

I wonder how long before, they might ask questions if it was a bit before the tackle, like why didn’t he come off etc.

It was still a dangerous tackle though, his arms were pinned and ridden to the ground, yes he released him right at the last moment but it had potential to be a lot worse, you could see the concern on Comben's face after the event.

What a joke!!!

2 hours ago, Demonland said:

3 hours ago, Demon_spurs said:

It was still a dangerous tackle though, his arms were pinned and ridden to the ground, yes he released him right at the last moment but it had potential to be a lot worse, you could see the concern on Comben's face after the event.

Yep, yet another case of punish the outcome, not the dangerous action.

3 hours ago, Demon_spurs said:

It was still a dangerous tackle though, his arms were pinned and ridden to the ground, yes he released him right at the last moment but it had potential to be a lot worse, you could see the concern on Comben's face after the event.

The MRO still hasn't been given a brain for Christmas

Michael - it was a dangerous tackle, with a player's head driven into the ground.

If you can't see the you really need to stand down.

Edited Monday at 09:504 days by monoccular

6 hours ago, Demonland said:

For case for 2026 ....

Well, he couldn't have taken him fully to the ground unless he had partially disengaged his arm

4 hours ago, biggestred said:

No name north Melbourne player in preseason?

3 weeks

4 hours ago, biggestred said:

No name north Melbourne player in preseason?

3 weeks

No, Comben was a "won't be long" watch.

So whose Medical Report was that?

It doesn't say Melbourne's, Does it? Why not?

Ah yes, Michael Christian. You can guarantee that if Mihocek was still playing for the Pies, Comben would have been suspended.

Never will i forget his threat to resign if Maynard was rubbed out.

51 minutes ago, Return to Glory said:

Ah yes, Michael Christian. You can guarantee that if Mihocek was still playing for the Pies, Comben would have been suspended.

Never will i forget his threat to resign if Maynard was rubbed out.

The final straw for me in terms of knowing that the AFL is obviously corrupt

What made it worse was the half the football public had Maynard as not guilty. Incredible

But there again, a lot of fans still pine for the violent days of old. Brayshaw became an expendable entity. Disgusting

Spot on Macca

Some genius on reddit compiled 2025s MRO action.

Nothing to see here

Anyone know the MFC players that have already been done 2 or 3 times for umpire contact? 4th time will be a suspension.

My understanding is that Rivers got done twice last year, so he'll need to make a concerted effort to avoid umpire contact going forward.

20 minutes ago, Bring-Back-Powell said:

Anyone know the MFC players that have already been done 2 or 3 times for umpire contact? 4th time will be a suspension.

My understanding is that Rivers got done twice last year, so he'll need to make a concerted effort to avoid umpire contact going forward.

Surely the AFL can't do this retrospectively? It goes against natural justice. It would be like announcing that if you had 3 jay-walking fines in the last 5 years and got another one next year, you would be jailed. If you knew the newly announced consequences, you might have been more careful to not jay-walk all those years ago.

3 minutes ago, sue said:

Surely the AFL can't do this retrospectively? It goes against natural justice. It would be like announcing that if you had 3 jay-walking fines in the last 5 years and got another one next year, you would be jailed. If you knew the newly announced consequences, you might have been more careful to not jay-walk all those years ago.

It's a good point you make.

The article just says 4 times. 4 times in your career or 4 times in a season?

Adam Cerra had to go to the tribunal last year for making contact 4 times - over multiple years, NOT in 2025.

Edited Tuesday at 22:542 days by Bring-Back-Powell