6 Langford

5 Gawn

4 Oliver

3 Fritsch

2 Salem

1 Rivers

6 - Gawn

5 - Oliver

4 - Langford

3 - Salem

2 - Bowey

1 - Fritsch

9 hours ago, Ungarieboy said:

Oliver

Rivers

Langford

Petty

Fritsch

Culley

Yes I thought Petty wa good and deserved some points

Herald Sun

De Goey 3

Gawn 2

Pendlebury 1

6 Gawn

5 Langford

4 Oliver

3 Salem

2 Rivers

1 Fritsch

6: Clayton Oliver
5: Christian Salem
4: Max Gawn
3: Harvey Langford
2: Bayley Fritsch
1: Trent Rivers

Edited 13 hours ago13 hr by burnthefushias

9 hours ago, Dees1911 said:

Yep, same as putting a players success over and above teams success is meaninless and so Melbourne!!!

Your opinion. Who do you think are our great current players ?

6. Gawn

5. Langford

4. Rivers

3. Oliver

2. Salem

1. Fritsch

11 hours ago, Little Goffy said:

6 Gawn

5 Langford

4 May

3 Salem

2 Fritsch

1 Pickett

Difficult one. Many were good, but many came in and out of the game or had some very visible clangers.

may lmao

6 gawn

5 turner

4 fritsch

3 oliver

2 langford

1 petracca

Langford

Oliver

Salem

Gawn

Rivers

Fritta

6 Max Gawn

5 Clayton Olivier

4 Harvey Langford

3 Christian Salem

2 Christian Petracca

1 Bayley Fritsch

Honourable mentions

Steven May

Jake Bowey

Jack Viney

Trent Rivers

Kysaiah Pickett

17 minutes ago, Fritta and Turner said:

Langford

Oliver

Salem

Gawn

Rivers

Fritta

These are good. Please. Petty had one good quarter. Either play him to replace May or sell him for steak knives.

6. Gawn

5. Oliver

   4. Langford

      3. Salem

         2. Rivers

            1. Bowey

Gawn

Oliver

Langford

Salem

Fritsch

Bowey

Wanted to include May, Trac and Rivers but too many errors from all three frustrated me too much.

I get the angst with Steven May but for a defender to have 20 kicks, 3 handballs & 12 marks, yes 12 marks and a tackle, what would we have been beaten by without Steven???

7 minutes ago, DeeZone said:

I get the angst with Steven May but for a defender to have 20 kicks, 3 handballs & 12 marks, yes 12 marks and a tackle, what would we have been beaten by without Steven???

I hear you DeeZone, and wanted to include him, but his first quarter was poor, and the amount of time his kick outside D50 was marked by opposition players was frustrating.

6 OLIVER

Clarry we love ya

Return of the king

87% disposal efficiency.

Please stay for 2026

5 GAWN

the King

Definite All Australian

Smashed the pretense of Cameron

If only our players could kick it to him when resting forward

4 LANGFORD

wow he’s going to be the real deal

Composed beyond his years

Only 74% game time

Great goal

Our MFC RISING STAR

3 FRITSCH

He did his job

Good goals with smart play

Very reliable kick once again

2 RIVERS

Run and run

A few errors but his determination are what’s needed

1 LANGDON

Just a great first half on 35filth

Seemed to get moved to a half forward role after 1/2 time

apologies to Salem, Trac, Bowsa.

Trac had another yet another NEARLY game

14 hours ago, Dees1911 said:

Ruckman are over rated.

We have so called best of our generation

Yet we lose every week

Everyone gives him best on

Taps to no one

Handballs to no one

Sits behind ball and takes great marks, yet generates no real forward momentum..

Will be 8 x all Australian and we have been ok for maybe 3 x those years.

He is lauded for great leadership, but we are clearly a far from united group bar 2021.

I suppose the fact we won the clearances 38-26 must suggest the Collingwood ruckmen were hitting to Melbourne players

7 hours ago, Tarax Club said:

6 Max Gawn

5 Clayton Olivier

4 Harvey Langford

3 Christian Salem

2 Christian Petracca

1 Bayley Fritsch

Honourable mentions

Steven May

Jake Bowey

Jack Viney

Trent Rivers

Kysaiah Pickett

Ed Langdon