Congratulations Max Gawn on taking out his 2nd consecutive and 4th overall Demonland Player of the Year Award.

Your votes please. 6, 5, 4, 3, 2 & 1.

Max

Langford

Clarrie

Fritter

Viney

Salem

6 Gawn

5 Langford

4 May

3 Salem

2 Fritsch

1 Pickett

Difficult one. Many were good, but many came in and out of the game or had some very visible clangers.

4 minutes ago, chook fowler said:

Max

Langford

Clarrie

Fritter

Viney

Salem

Nailed it, Chook.

Ruckman are over rated.

We have so called best of our generation

Yet we lose every week

Everyone gives him best on

Taps to no one

Handballs to no one

Sits behind ball and takes great marks, yet generates no real forward momentum..

Will be 8 x all Australian and we have been ok for maybe 3 x those years.

He is lauded for great leadership, but we are clearly a far from united group bar 2021.

3 minutes ago, Dees1911 said:

Ruckman are over rated.

We have so called best of our generation

Yet we lose every week

Everyone gives him best on

Taps to no one

Handballs to no one

Sits behind ball and takes great marks, yet generates no real forward momentum..

Will be 8 x all Australian and we have been ok for maybe 3 x those years.

He is lauded for great leadership, but we are clearly a far from united group bar 2021.

he's one of the great players to ever play the game, ruckman or not

god never won a premiership either, so max has that on him

6: gawn
5: langford
4: salem
3: rivers
2: oliver
1: fritsch

6 Langford

5 Max

4 Oliver

3 Frittata

2 Rivers

1 Salem

God would kick 10

Max gets 50 hit outs , 10 go to us, maybe 20 to opposition,crest ???

No goals

Not disputing his greatness in position, more effectiveness along with trac, viney, Oliver.

Big 4, big money

Finished 15 th

19 minutes ago, chook fowler said:

Max

Langford

Clarrie

Fritter

Viney

Salem

second this

6. Oliver

5. Gawn

4. Langford

3. Rivers

2. Salem

1. Fritsch

Oliver

Rivers

Langford

Petty

Fritsch

Culley

6 Gawn fo being Gawn

5 Langford for composure

4 clarry starting to get back to his old self

3 rivers for a great second half, drove us forward

2 fritsch took his chances

1 Salem was tidy all night

28 minutes ago, Dees1911 said:

Ruckman are over rated.

We have so called best of our generation

Yet we lose every week

Everyone gives him best on

Taps to no one

Handballs to no one

Sits behind ball and takes great marks, yet generates no real forward momentum..

Will be 8 x all Australian and we have been ok for maybe 3 x those years.

He is lauded for great leadership, but we are clearly a far from united group bar 2021.

That's literally the worst take I've ever seen on this site and that's saying something.

Our side was pox for most of Robbie Flower's career. Does that make him not much good?

Get a grip. We'd probably be lucky to have four wins on the board this year if it wasn't for Gawn.

Edited August 22, 2025Aug 22 by Hopeful Demon

6 Oliver - welcome back!

5 Langford - gun gun gun

4 Fritsch - welcome back!

3 Gawn - Mr Reliable

2 Bowey - great season

1 Rivers

Least when Robbie got the ball he did something with it.

I just feel we are not getting best out of Max's dominance.

Ie.

His 2 weaknesses are kicking and hanballing.

Yet we never get runners for handball receive after mark and we always seem to be hanballing to max under pressure.

Other teams don't do this

6 - Max Gawn

5 - Christian Salem

4 - Clayton Oliver just kept getting better

3 - Harvey Langford ⭐️

2 - Jake Bowey brilliant year

1 - Bailey Fritsch

Then Tracc, JV, Mayzie and Trent Rivers, gave the Filth a real fright tonight and with a bit more composure could have nailed them.

6 - Max Gawn

5 - Christian Petracca

4 - Clayton Oliver just kept getting better

3 - Harvey Langford ⭐️

2 - Christian Salem

1 - Jake Bowey

46 minutes ago, Dees1911 said:

Least when Robbie got the ball he did something with it.

I just feel we are not getting best out of Max's dominance.

Ie.

His 2 weaknesses are kicking and hanballing.

Yet we never get runners for handball receive after mark and we always seem to be hanballing to max under pressure.

Other teams don't do this

give me gawn's years over flower's

comparing the success that one player has brought to the side is meaningless

6 Gawn - our everywhere man.

5 Salem - immaculate disposals.

4 Oliver - gave his all.

3 Petracca - but oh, that kicking!

2 Langford - constantly improving.

1 Bowey - tidy as usual.

8 minutes ago, whatwhat say what said:

give me gawn's years over flower's

comparing the success that one player has brought to the side is meaningless

Yep, same as putting a players success over and above teams success is meaninless and so Melbourne!!!

 

6. Max Gawn 

5. Clayton Oliver 

4. Jake Bowey 

3. Christian Salem 

2. Bayley Fritsch 

1. Christian Petracca

 

1 hour ago, Dees1911 said:

God would kick 10

Max gets 50 hit outs , 10 go to us, maybe 20 to opposition,crest ???

No goals

Not disputing his greatness in position, more effectiveness along with trac, viney, Oliver.

Big 4, big money

Finished 15 th

You must be the life of a party Dees 1911.

29 minutes ago, Dee-tonator said:

6 Gawn - our everywhere man.

5 Salem - immaculate disposals.

4 Oliver - gave his all.

3 Petracca - but oh, that kicking!

2 Langford - constantly improving.

1 Bowey - tidy as usual.

Oliver . 'Gave his all' (He always does)

Max

Clayton (don't leave us!)

Salem

Fritsch

Langford ( Our rising star)

Bowey ( A wonderful season)

And it’s goodbye to 2025 (men’s comp)!

A frustrating and unfulfilling year!

6: Oliver

5: Gawn

4:Salem

3: Bowey

2: Langford

1: Rivers