unsure if this has been posted, but, is there somewhere us Deees get together to watch interstate games (once it was the Bentleigh Club - gee - I'm going back!).

Go Dees

and I can't stand Saints!

Gee it's a worry viney is missing again

Really concerning about Viney. A month off from a delayed concussion and can’t even get through training. Let’s hope this isn’t going to be a long term or career ending.

Would be great to have Viney back in the side at some point but I’m now far more concerned with his long term health and well-being.

sadly i think it's time to officially begin to worry about jack's playing future

2 minutes ago, dees189227 said:

Gee it's a worry viney is missing again

Yep. I'm worried for Jack's health more than I'm worried for the team missing his presence...

1 minute ago, Jaded No More said:

Really concerning about Viney. A month off from a delayed concussion and can’t even get through training. Let’s hope this isn’t going to be a long term or career ending.

I suspect that in the scheme of things delayed concussion is worse than match day concussion.

It's now more than concerning given his age and game style.

Culley?

adams sub and sharp on the bench maybe?

Unless we decide to go in with an extra tall, I imagine either Laurie or Henderson will get the call up for Sunday.

Edited May 30, 2025May 30 by Demon Jack

very concerning. i hope he can recover without any lingering effects

12 minutes ago, Adina88 said:

Yep. I'm worried for Jack's health more than I'm worried for the team missing his presence...

100% and glad the club is taking no risks.

Jack is about to become a father for the third time. He has a whole life ahead of him. We have seen the devastating impact of concussion on individuals years down the track. His health and wellbeing is the most important thing.

Surely Laurie is the in, sub. Sharp into the 22.

Hope they are just being extra cautious with Viney. Don’t want any prolonged post concussion syndrome 🤞🏼

Surely it’s time to see if Laurie is up to AFL level & give him a full game

Happy with the club being cautious with Jack hoping to see him soon

On 29/05/2025 at 11:04, Bay Riffin said:

Same here. Viney had not gone through full contact training so we have to see how he pulls up from that first. It's not ticked off yet.

Sadly appears we were right, Viney out

"Forward Jacob van Rooyen will join the extended squad, with the final team to be confirmed at 5pm (AEST) on Friday."

Hope he stays at Casey, another week to build his skills/confidence. Would be nothing worse than to travel to Alice and not play.

Not sure how this plays out though in terms of like-for-like replacement. Perhaps Adams in to free Turner forward? Would have thought we'd bring in Henderson for Spargo with Laurie as emergency not JVR. But what would I know ...

7 minutes ago, bing181 said:

"Forward Jacob van Rooyen will join the extended squad, with the final team to be confirmed at 5pm (AEST) on Friday."

Hope he stays at Casey, another week to build his skills/confidence. Would be nothing worse than to travel to Alice and not play.

Not sure how this plays out though in terms of like-for-like replacement. Perhaps Adams in to free Turner forward? Would have thought we'd bring in Henderson for Spargo with Laurie as emergency not JVR. But what would I know ...

If it was me I'd go Sharp in for Spargo and Laurie sub.

Leave the rest of the structure the same.

Interesting that the team list on the AFL site just swapped JVR in for Viney into the 18. I suspect at 5 pm we will find that JVR is an emergency, because he is in Sydney ready to play for Casey tomorrow.

Vines is flying to Alice and will train (a little like Clayton did a couple of years ago!) and Henderson will come into the 23. Either Hendo or Sharp I expect to be sub. Don't expect Adams to play. Final question is which plane Bailey Laurie is on....?

Does Viney have a history of concussion issues?

If not, we may be jumping the gun with worrying about his career. The club are rightfully being extremely conservative with our VC

3 minutes ago, DubDee said:

Does Viney have a history of concussion issues?

He has a history of throwing himself recklessly into packs. That has to catch up with you at some point.

I love the guy, but how's that four year contract looking at the moment?

3 minutes ago, poita said:

He has a history of throwing himself recklessly into packs. That has to catch up with you at some point.

I love the guy, but how's that four year contract looking at the moment?

So no concussion history that you know of? Good to hear!

Contract is looking great, he has been in good form and is a key member of the squad

With the team playing better without him I think it's better to be as cautious as possible.

Laurie has to come in. He has to show something and needs to take his chance. I’d assume he would be sub however actually prefer to see him start.

6 minutes ago, spirit of norm smith said:

Laurie has to come in. He has to show something and needs to take his chance. I’d assume he would be sub however actually prefer to see him start.

yeah i don't agree

he's an inside midfielder

in terms of replacing spargo, i think henderson suits the role player specificity of like: like

I don’t recall Viney sitting out games with concussion or being flattened during games and showing concussed signs. I’m sure he’s had a few though. It’s clearly a concern if he’s still not playing as the incident wasn’t the worst which we’ve seen. Fingers crossed it’s all ok in the coming weeks.